"~^
(•:\\t:\\\ 1
MORE WONDERS
OF THE
INVISIBLE WOELD.
OR
THE WONDERS
OF
DISPLAYED.
7JV FIVE PARTS.
Fart I. — An Account ot the Sufferings of Margaret Rule.
written by the Rev. Cotton Mather.
Part II. — Several Letters to the Author, &c. and his Reply
relating to Witchcraft.
Part III. — The Differences between the Inhabitants of
Salem Village, and Mr. Parris, their Minister, in New-
England.
Part IV. — Letters of a Gentleman uninterested, endea-
vouring to prove the received opinions about Witchcraft
to be Orthodox. With short Essays to their Answers.
Part V.— A short Historical Account of Matters of Fact
in that Affair.
to which is added
A POSTCIIIPT,
relating to a book entitled " the LIFE OF SIR WM. PIIIPS."
COLLECTED BY
ROBERT CALEF,
Merchant, of Boston, in New-Endand
TRINTED LV LONDON, A. D. 1700.
-PRINTED IN SALEM, BY JOHN D. AND T. C. CUSniNG, .TPv
FOR CISHING AND APPLETOff
1323.
THE EPISTLE TO THE READER,
AND MORE ESPECIALLY TO THE NOBLE BARONS OF
THIS AGE, WHEREVER RESIDING.
GENTLEMEN,
X OU, that are freed from the slavery of a
corrupt education ; and that, in spite of human
precepts, example, and precedents, can hearken
to the dictates of scripture and reason ; for your
sakes I am content that these collections of
mine, as also my sentiments, should be exposed
to public view; in hopes that, having well con-
sidered and compared them with scripture, you
will see reason, as I do, to question a belief so
prevalent as that here treated of, as also the
practice flowing from thence ; they standing as
nearly connected as cause and effect ; it being
found wholly impracticable to extirpate the lat-
ter, without first curing the former. And if the
buffoon or satirical will be exercising their ta-
lents, or if the bigots wilfully and blindly reject
the testimonies of their own reason, and more
sure word, it is no more than what I expected
from them. But you, gentlemen, I doubt not,
are willing to distinguish between truth and er-
ror; and if this may be any furtherance to you
herein, I shall not miss my aim. But if you find
the contrary, and that my belief herein is any
way heterodox, I shall be thankful for the in-
formation to any learned or reverend person, or
cy THE EPISTLE
others, that shall take that pains to inform me
better, by scripture or sound, reason ; which is
what 1 have been long seeking for in this coun-
try in vain.
In a time when not only England in particu-
lar, but almost all Europe, had been labouring
against the usurpations of tyranny and slavery,
the English x4merica has not been behind in a
share of the common calamities ; more espe-
cially, New-England has met not only with such
calamities as are common to the rest, but with
several aggravations enhancing such afflictions,
hj the devastations and cruelties of the barba-
rous Indians in their eastern borders, &c. But
this is not all ; they have been harast (on many
accounts) by a more dreadful enemy, as will
herein appear to the considerate.
Were it, as w^e are told in Wonders of the In^
visible World, " that the devils were walking
about our streets with lengthened chains, making
a dreadful noise in our ears ; and brimstone
(eve.n without a metaj^hor) was making a hor-
rid and a hellish stench in our nostrils ;" and,
" that the devil, exhibiting himself ordinarily as
a black man, had decoyed a fearful knot of
proud, fro ward, ignorant, envious and malicious
creatures, to list themselves in his horrid ser-
vice, by enterin^^ their names in a book tendered
unto them ; and that they have had their meet-
ings and sacraments, and associated themselves
to destroy the kingdom of our Lord Jesus Christ,
in these parts of the world ; having each of them
their spectres, or devils, commissioned by them,
and representing of them to be the engines of
TO THE READER. v
their malice, by tlicsc wicked spectres seizing;
poor people about the country, with various and
bloody torments, and oi" those evidently preter-
natural torments some have died; and that they
have bewitched some even so far as to make them
self-destroyers, and others in many towns here
and there languished under their evil hands —
the people, thus afflicted, miserably scratched
and bitten ; and that the same invisible furies
did stick pins in them, and scald them, distort
and disjoint them, with a thousand other plagues;
and sometimes drag them out of their chambers,
and carry them over trees and hills, miles toge-
ther, many of them being tempted to sign the
devil's laws" — "those furies, whereof several
Imve killed more people perhaps than would
serve to make a village'' — If this be the true state
of the afflictions of this country, it is very deplora-
ble, and beyond all other outward calamities mis-
erable. But if, on the other side, the matter be, as
others do understand it, that the devil has been
too hard for us by his temptations, signs, and
lying wonders, with the help of pernicious no-
tions, formerly imbibed and professed ; together
with the accusations of a parcel of possessed,
distracted or lying wenches, accusing their inno-
cent neighbours, pretending they see their spec-
tres, i. e. devils in their likeness, afflicting of
them; and that God in righteous judgment (af-
ter men had ascribed his power to witches, of
commissioning d;:':;vils to do these things) may
have given them over to strong delusions to be-
lieve lies, &c. and to let loose the devils of envy,
hatred, pride, cruelty and malice against each
1*
vi THE EPISTLE
other, jet still disguised under the mask of zeai
for God, and left them to the branding one anoth-
er with the odious name of witch ; and upon the
accusation of those above mentioned, brother to
accuse and prosecute brother, children their pa-
rents, pastors and teachers their immediate
flock, unto death; shepherds becoming wolves;,
wise men infatuated ; people hauled to prisons ;
with a bloody noise pursuing to, and Insulting
over the (true) sufferers at, execution; while
seme are fleeing from that called justice, justice
itself fleeing before such accusations, when once
it did but begin to refrain further proceedings ;
and, to question such practices, some making
their escape cut of prisons, rather than bv an
obstinate defence of their innocencj to run so
apparent hazard of their lives ; estates seized,
families of cliUdren and others left to the mercy
of the wilderness (not to mention here the num-
bers proscribed, dead In prisons or executed,
&:c.)— All which tragedies, though begun in one
town, or rather by one parish, has pj ague-like
spread more than through that country, and by
its echo giving a brand of infamy to this whole
country throughout the world : — If this w^ere
the miserable case of this country in the time
thereof, and that the devil had so far prevailed
upon us, In our sentiments and actions, as to
draw us from so much as looking into the scrip
tures for our guidance in these pretended intrl-
eacles ; leading us to a trusting In blind guides,
^uch as the corrupt practices of some- other
<i;ountries, or the bloody experiments of Bodit),
'dixl si.jch other authors : — then, though our ca?f>
TO THE READEU. vli*
be most miserable, yd it must be said of New-
England, thou hast destroyed thysell', and brought
this greatest oC miseries upon thee.
And now, whether the witches (such as have
made a compact by explicit covenant witii the
devil, having thereby obtained a power to com-
mission him) have been the cause of our mise-
ries; or whether a zeal, governed by blindness
and passion, and led by precedent, has not here-
in precipitated us into far greater wickedness
(if not witchcrai'ts) than any have yjet been pro-
ved against those that suffered: — to be able to
distinguish aright in this matter, to which of these
two to refer our miseries, is the design of the
present work.
As to the former, I know of no sober man,
much less reverend christian, that, being asked,
dares affirm, and abide by it, that witches have
that power, viz. to commission devils to kill and
destroy; and as to the latter, it were well if
there were not too much of truth in it, which
remains to be demonstrated.
,- But here it will be said, What need of raking
in the coals that lay buried in oblivion? We
cannot recal those to life again, that have suf-
fered, supposing it were unjustly; it tends but
t;o the exposing the actors, as if they had pro-
ceeded irregularly.
Truly 1 take tills to be just as the devil
would have it, so much to fear disobliging men,
as not to endeavour to detect his wiles, that so
he may the sooner, and with the greater advan-
tages, set the same on foot ag^in (either here or
elsewhere), so dragging us through the pond
twice by the same cat. And, if reports do not
viii THE EPISTLE
herein deceive us, much the same has been act-
ing this present year in Scotland. And wliat
kingdom or country is it, that has not had their
bloody tits and turns at it ? And if this is such
a catching disease, and so universal, I presume
I need make no apology for my endeavours to
prevent, as far as in my power, any more such
bloody victims or sacrifices ; though indeed I
had rather any other would have undertaken so
offensive, though necessary, a task; yet, all
things weighed, I had rather thus expose my-
self to censure, than that it should be wholly
omitted. Were the notions in question innocent
and harmless, respecting the glory of God, and
well-being of men, I should not have engaged in
them; but finding them, in my esteem, so into-
lerably destructive of both, thisy together w^ith
my being by warrant called before the justices,
in my own just vindication I took it to be a call
from God, to my power, to vindicate his truths,
against the pagan and popish assertions, which
are so prevalent ; for though christians in gene-^
ral do own the scriptures to be their only rule
of faith and doctrine, yet these notions will tell
us, tliat the scriptures have not sufficiently, nor
at all, described the crime of witchcraft, where-
by the culpable might be detected, though it
be positive in the command to punish it by
death ; hence the world has been from time to
time perplexed, in the prosecution of the seve^
ral diabolical mediums of heathenish and po-
pish invention to detect an imaginary crime (not
but that there are witches such as the law of
God describes) which has produced a deluge of
TO THE READER. ix
blood; hereby rendering the commands of God
not only void but dangerous.
So also they own God's providence and go-
vernment of the world ; and that tempests and
storms, adlictlons and diseases, are of his send-
ing; yet these notions tell us, that the devil has
the power of all these, and can perform them
when commissioned by a witch thereto; and
that he has a power, at the witch's call, to act
and do, without and against the course of nature,
and all natural causes, in afflicting and killing of
innocents; and this It is that so many have died
for.
Also it is generally believed, that if any pian
has strength, it is from God the Almighty Be-
ing : but these notions will tell us, that the de-
vil can make one man as strong as many; which
was one of the best proofs, as it was com^ted,
against Mr. Burroughs the minister; though'
his contemporaries in the schools, during his mi-
nority, could have testified, that his strength
was then as much superior to theirs as ever
(setting aside incredible romances) it was disco-
vered to be since : thus rendering the power
of God, and his providence, of none elFect.
These are some of the destructive notions of
this age; and however the asserters of them
seem sometimes to value themselves much upon
sheltering their neighbours from spectral accu-
sations, they may deserve as much thanks as
that tyrant, that, having industriously obtained
an unintelligible charge against his subjects, in
matters wherein it was impossible they should
be guilty, having thereby their lives in his pow-
X THE EPISTLE
er, yet suffers them of his mere grace to live,
and will be called gracious lord.
It were too Icarian a task for one, unfurnished
with necessary learning, and library, to give any
just account from whence so great delusions
have sprung, and so long continued. Yet, as an
essay from those scraps of reading that 1 have
had opportunity of, it will be no great venture
to say, that signs and lying wonders have been
one principal cause.
It is written of Justin Martyr, who lived in
the second century, that he was before his con-
version a great philosopher; first in the way of
th^stoicks, and after, of the peripateticks, after
that of the pythagorean, and after that of the
platonist, sects; and after all proved of eminent
use in the church of Christ: yet a certain au-
thor, speaking of one Apollonius Tyaneus, has
these words : ^' That the most orthodox them-
selves began to deem him vested with power
sufficient for a deity; which occasioned that so
strange a doubt from Justin Martyr, as cited bj
the learned Gregory, fol. 37 : If God be the
creator and lord of the world, how comes it to
pass that Apollonius his telisms have so much
over-ruled the course of things? for we see that
they also have stilled the waves of the sea, and
the raging of the winds, and prevailed against
the noisome flies, and incursions of wild beasts,
&;c." If so eminent and early a christian were
by these false shews in jnich doubt, it is the less
wonder, in our dej)raved times, to meet with
what IS equivalent tliereto. Besides this, a cer-
tain author informs me, that Julian (alter vvards
TO THE READER. xi
called the apostate) bcinsc iustrucfed in the plii-
losopliy and disciplines of the heathen, by Liba-
rius his tutor, by this means lie came to love
philosophy better than the gosj^el, and so by de-
grees turned from Christianity to heathenism."
This same Julian did, when apostate, forbid
that christians should be instructed in the disci-
pline of the gentiles; which, it seems, Socrates,
a writer of the ecclesiastical history, does ac-
knowledge to be by tliC singular providence of
God ; christians having then begun to degenerate
from the gospel, and to betake themselves to
heathenish learning. And in the Mercury for
the month of February, 1695, there is this ac-
count, *' That the christian doctors, conversing
much with the writings of the heathen, for the
gaining of eloquence, a council was held at Car-
thage, which forbad the reading oi' the books of
the gentiles."
From all which it may be easily perceived,
that in the primitive times of Christianity, when
notj only many heathen of the vulgar, but also
many learned men and philosophers, had em-
braced the christian faith, they still retained a
love to their heathen learning; which, as one
observes, being transplanted into a christian soil,
soon proved productive of pernicious weeds,
which overran the face of the church; hence
it was so deformed, as the reformation found it.
Among other pernicious weeds arising from
this root, the doctrine of the power of devils,
and witchcraft, as it is now and long has been
understood, is not the least : the fables of Ho-
mer, Virgil, Horace and Ovid, &c. being for the
iLii THE EPiSTLE
elegancy of their language retained then (and so
are to this day) in the schools, have not only in-
troduced, but established, such doctrines, to the
poisoning the christian world. A certain author
expresses it thus : " That as the christian schools
at first brought men from heathenism to the
gospel, so these schools carry men from the gos-
pel to heatlienism, as to their great perfection."
And Mr. L JVl. in his Remarkable Providences^
gives an account, that (as he calls it) an old
council did anatiiematize all those that behoved
such power of the devils, accounting it a damna-
ble doctrine. But as other evils did afterwards
increase in the church (partly by such education)
so this insensibly grew up with tliem, though not
to that degree as that any council, I have ever
heard or read of, has to. this day taken off those
anathemas; yet alter this the church so far de-
clined, that witchcraft became a principal eccle-
siastical engine (as also that of heresy was) to
root up all that stood in their w^ay ; and besides
the w^ays of trial that we have still in practice,
they invented some which were peculiar to them-
selves; which, whenever they w^ere minded to
improve against any orthodox believer, they
could easily make effectual. That deluge of
blood, which that Scarlet Whore has' to answer
for, siied under this notion, how amazing is it!
The first in England, that I have read of, of
any note, since the reformation, that asserts this
doctrine, is the famous Mr. Perkins: he, as also
Mr. Gaul, Mr. Bernard, &c. seem all of them to
have undertaken one task; taking notice of the
fnultiplicity of irregular Avays to try them by.
TO THE READEK. xiii
invented by heathen and papists, they made it
their business, and main work, herein to oppose
such as they saw to be pernicious. And it' they
did not look more narrowly into it, but i'ol lowed
the hrst, viz. Mi". Perkins, whose education (as
theirs also) had forestalled him into such belief,
Avhom they readily followed, it cannot be won-
dered at. And tliat they were men liable to
err, and so not to he trusted to as perfect guides,
will manifestly appear to him that shall see their
several receipts laid down to detect them, by
their presumptive and positive ones ; and con-
sider how few of either have any foundation in
scripture, or reason; and how vastly they differ
from each other in both ; each having his art
by himself, which forty or an hundred more
may as well imitate, and give theirs, ad infinitum,
being without all manner of proof. But though
this be their main design, to take otf people
from those evil and bloody ways of trial, which
they speak so much against; yet this does not
hinder, to this day, but the same evil ways, or
as bad, are still used to detect them by, and that
even among protestants; and are so far justified,
that a reverend person has said lately here,
How else shall we detect witches.'^ And another,
being urged to prove by scripture such a sort
of witch as has power to send devils to kill
men, replied, that he did as firmly believe it, as
any article of his faith ; and that he (the inqui-
rer) did not go to the scriptures to learn the
mysteries of his trade or art. What can be
said more to establish their heathenish notions,
and to vilify the scriptures, our only rule ? and
xiv THE EPISTLE
that, after we have seen such dire effects there-
of, as has threatened the utter extirpation of
this whole country.
And as to most of the actors in these trage-
dies, though they are so far from defending
their actions, that they will readily own that
undue steps have been taken, &;c. yet it seems
*they choose that the same should be acted over
again, enforced by their example, rather than it
should remain as a warning to posterity, as
herein they have mist it. So far are they from
giving glory to God, and taking the due shame
to themselves.
And now', to sum up all in a few words, vre
have seen a bigoted zeal stirring up a blind and
most bloody rage, not against enemies, or irreli-
gious, profligate persons ; but (in judgment of
charity, and to view) against as virtuous and re-
hgious as any they have ]eft behind them in
this country, w^hich have suffered as evil doers
(with the utmost extent of rigour, not that so
high a character is due to all that suffered) and
this by the testimony of vile varlets, as not only
were known be'fore, but have been further ap-
parent since, by their manifest lives, whore-
doms, incest, &c. The accusations of these,
from their spectral sight, being the chief evi-
dence against those that suffered ; in which ac-
cusations they were upheld by both magistrates
and ministers, so long as they apprehended
themselves in no danger.
And then, though they could defend neither
the doctrine nor the practice, yet none of them
have, in such a puublic manner as the case re-
TO THE READER. xy
quires, testified against either ; thou<^h at the
same time they could not but be sensible what
a stain and lasting infamy they have brought
upon the whole country, to the endangering the
future welfare not only of this but of other pla-
ces, induced by their example; if not to an en-
tailing the guilt of all the righteous blood that
has been by the same means shed, by heathen
or papists, &c. upon themselves, whose deeds
they have so far justified, occasioning the great
dishonour and blasphemy of the name of God,
scandalizing the heathen, hardening of enemies ;
and, as a natural effect thereof, to the great in-
crease of atheism.
I shall conclude, only with acquainting the
reader, that of these collections, the first, con-
taining More Wonders of the Invisible World,
I received of a gentleman, who had it of the
author, and communicated it to use, with his
express consent, of which this is a true copy.
As to the letters, they are, for substance, the
same I sent, though with some small variation,
or addition. Touching the two letters from a
gentleman, at his request 1 have forborn nam-
ing him. It is great pity that the matters of
fact, and indeed the whole, had not been done
by some abler hand, better accomplished, and
with the advantages of both natural and acquir-
ed judgment ; but others not appearing, 1 have
enforced myself to do what is done; my other
occasions will not admit any further scrutiny/
therein. R. C.
Aifgu^t, 11, 1697.
PART 1.
ACCOUNT OF THE SUFFERINGS
OF
MARGARET RULE.
SIR,
1 NOW lay before you a very entertaining
story — a story which relates yet more Wonders
of the Invisible World — a story which tells the
remarkable afflictions and deliverance of one that
had been prodigiously handled by the Evil An-
gels. I was myself a daily eye-witness to a large
part of these occurrences, and there may be pro-
duced scores of substantial witnesses to the most
of them; yea, I know not of any one passage of
the story but what may be sufficiently attested.
I do not write it with a design of throwing it
presently into the press, but only to preserve
the memory of such memorable things, the for-
getting whereof would neither be pleasing to
God, nor useful to men; as also to give you, with
18
some others of peculiar and obliging friends, a
sight of some curiosities. And I hope this apo-
logy will serve to excuse me, if I mention, ag
perhaps I may, when I come to a tenth para-
graph in my writing, some things which 1 would
have omitted in a farther publication.
COTTON MATHEEv.
1^
ANOTHER BRAND
FLUCKT OUT OF THE BURMIJ^G,
OR
MORE WONDERS OF THE INVISIBLE WORLD;
Sect. 1. V^ITHIN these few years, there
died in the southern parts, a christian Indian,
who, notwithstanding some of his Indian weak-
ness, had something of a better character, of vir-
tue and goodness, than many of our people can
allow to most of their countrymen, that profess
the christian religion. He had been a zealous
preacher of the gospel to his neighbourhood,
and a sort of overseer or officer, to whose con-
duct was owing very much of what good order
was maintained among these proselyted savages.
This man, returning home from the funeral of
his son, was complimented by an Englishman,
expressing sorrow for his loss. Now, though
the Indians used upon the death of relations to
be the most passionate and outrageous creatures
in the world, yet this converted Indian hand-
somely and cheerfully replied. Truly I am sorry,
and I am not sorry: I am sorry that I have
buried a dear son ; but I am not sorry that the
will of God is done : I know that without the
will of God my son could not have died; and I
know that the will of God is always just and
20 SUFFERINGS OF
good, and so I am satisfied. Imaiediately upon
this, even within a few hours, he fell himself
sick, of a disease that quickly killed him ; in the
time of which disease, he called his folks about
him, earnestly persuading them to be sincere in
their praying unto God, and to beware of the
drunkenness, the idleness, the lying, v/hereby so
many of that nation disgraced their profession
of Christianity ; adding, that he was ashamed,
Avhen he thought how little service he had hi-
therto done for God ; and, that ii'God would pro-
long his life, he would labour to do better ser-
vice ; but that he was fully sure he was now go-
ing to the Lord Jesus Christ, who had bought
him with his precious blood; and for his part,
he longed to die, that he might be with his glo-
rious Lord ; and, in the midst of such passages,
he gave up the ghost; but in such repute, that
the English people, of good fashion, did not think
much of travelling a great way to his interment.
Lest my reader do wonder why I have related
this piece of a story, 1 will now hasten to abate
that wonder, by telling that wliereto this was
intended but for an introduction. Know then,
that this remarkable Indian being, a little before
he died, at work in the wood, making of tar,
there appeared unto him a black man, of a ter-
rible aspect, and more than human dimensions,
threatenmg bitterly to kill him, if he would not
promise to leave otf preaching, as he did, to his
countrymen, and promise particularly, that if he
preached any more, he would say nothing of
Jesus Christ unto them. The Indian was amaz-
ed, yet had the courage to answer, I will, in spite
MARGARET RULE. 21
of you, ^o on to preach Christ, more than ever
I did; and the God whom 1 serve will keep me,
that you shall never hurt me. Hereupon the
apparition, abating somewhat of his fierceness,
olfered to the Indian a book, of a considerable
thickness, and a pen and ink, and said, that if he
woiild now set his hand unto that book, he would
require nothing further of him ; but the man re-
fused ibe motion with indignation, and fell down
upon his knees into a fervent and pious prayer
unto God, for help against the tempter; where-
upon the demon vanished.
This is a story which I would never have ten-
dered unto my reader, if I had not received it
from an honest and useful Endishman, who is
IT
at this time a preacher of the gospel to the In-
dians; nor would the probable truth of it have
encouraged me to have tendered it, if this also
had not been a fit introduction unto a yet fur-
ther narrative.
Sect. 2. It was not much above a year or
two after this accident (of which no manner of
noise has been made) that there was a prodi-
gious descent of devils upon divers places near
the centre of this province ; wherein some scores
of miserable people were troubled by horrible
appearances of a black man, accompanie"d with
spectres, wearing these and those human shapes,
who oiFered them a book to be by them signed,
in token of their being listed for the service of
the devil ; and, upon tiieir denying to do it, they
were dragooned with a thousand preternatural
torments, which gave no little terror to the be-
holders of these unhappy people. There wa-
^t SUFFERINGS OP
one in the north part of Boston seized bj the
evil angels many months alter the general storm
of the late enchantments was over, and when
the country had long lain very quiet, both as to
molestations and accusations from the invisible
world : her name was Margaret Rule, a young
-woman : she was born of sober and honest pa-
rents, yet living ; but what her own character
was before her visitation I can speak with the
less confidence of exactness, because 1 observe
that wherever the devils have been let loose, to
worry any poor creature among us, a great part
of the neighbourhood presently set themselves
to inquire, and relate all the little vanities of
their childhood, with such unequal exaggerations,
as to make them appear greater sinners than any
whom the pilot of hell has not yet preyed up-
on. But it is affirmed, that, for about half a year
before her visitation, she was observably impro-
ved in the hopeful symptoms of a new creature ;
she was become seriously concerned for the
everlasting salvation of her soul, and careful to
avoid the snares of evil company. This young
woman had never seen the afflictions of Mercy
Short, whereof a narrative has been already
given ; and yet, about half a year after the glo-
rious and signal deliverance of that poor dam-
sel, this Margaret fell into an affliction, marvel-
lous, resembling hers in almost all the circum-
stances of it ; indeed the afflictions were so much
alike, that the relation i have given of the one,
would almost serve as the full history of the
other; this was to that little more than the se-
cond part of the same tune ; indeed Margaret'?
MARGARET RULE. 2$
oase was in several points less rcraarka!)lc than
Mercy's, and in some other tnirjgs tlie entertain-
ment did a little vary.
Sect. 3. It was upon the Lord's day, the
10th ol September, in thi^ year 1603, that M-^r-
garet Rule, after some hours of previots distur-
bance in the public assembly, ieil into odd fits,
which caused her (riends to carry her home,
where her fits in a few hours i{rew into a figure
that satisfied the spectators of their bein^; pre-
ternatural. Some cf the neighbours were for-
ward enough to suspect the rise of this mischief
in an house hard by, where lived a miserable
Avoman, who had been formerly imprisoned, on
the suspicion of witchcraft, and who had fre-
quently cured very painful hurts, by muttering
over them certain charms, which I shall not en-
danger the poisoning of my reader by repeating.
This woman had, the evening before Margaret
fell into her calamities, very bitterly treated
her, and threatened her; but f!ie hazard of
hurting a poor Avoman, that might be innocent,
notwithstanding surmises that might have been
more strongly grounded than those, caused the
pious people in the vicinity to try, rather,
whether incessant supplication to God alone
might not procure a quicker and snfer ease to
the afflicted, than hasty prosecution of any sup-
posed criminal ; and accordingly that unexcep-
tionable course was all that was ever followed:
yea, which 1 looked on as a token for good, the
afflicted family was as averse, as any of us, to
entertain thouglits of any other course.
Sect. 4. The young woman was assaulted
24 SUFFERINGS OF
bj eight cruel spectres, whereof she imagined
that she knew three or four; but the rest came
still w^ith their faces covered, so that she could
never have a distinguished view of the counte-
nance of those whom she thought she knew^;
she w^as very careful of my reiterated charges,
to forbear blazing their names, lest any good
person should come to suiTer any blast of repu-
tation, through the cunning malice of the great
accuser; nevertheless, having since privately
named them to myself, I will venture to say this
of them, that they are a sort of wretches, who
for these many years have gone under as vio-
lent presumptions of witchcraft, as perhaps any
creatures yet living upon earth; although I ani'
far from thinking that the visions of this young
w^oman were evidence enough to prove them
so. These cursed spectres now brought unto
her a book about a cubit long — a book red and
thick, but not very broad ; and they demanded
of her, that she would set her hand to that
book, or touch it at least with her hand, as a
sign of her becoming a servant of the devil.
Upon her peremptory refusal to do what they
asked, they did not alter renew the proffers of
the book unto her, but instead thereof they fell
to tormenting of her in a manner too hellish to
be sufficiently described — in those torments con-
fining her to her bed for just six weeks to-
gether.
Sect. 5. Sometimes, but not always, together
wnth the spectres, there looked in upon the
young woman (according to her account) a short
and a black man, whom thcv called their mas-
Margaret rule. 25
ter — a white, exactly of the same dimensions
and complexion and voice, with the devil that
has exhibited himself unto other infested peo-
ple, not only in other parts of this country, but
also in other countries, even of the European
world, as the relation of the enchantments there
informs us. They all profest themselves vassals
of this devil, and in obedience unto him they ad-
dressed themselves unto various ways of tortur-
ing her. Accordini^ly she was cruelly pinched
with invisible hands, very often in a day, and
the black and blue marks of the pinches became
immediately visible unto the standers by. Be-
sides this, when her attendants had left her
without so much as one pin about her, that so
they might prevent some feared inconveniences,
yet she would every now and then be miserably
hurt with pins, which were found stuck into her
neck, back and arms ; however, the wounds
made by the pins would in a few minutes ordi-
narily be cured ; she would also be strangely dis-
torted in her joints, and thrown into such exor-
bitant convulsions as were astonishing unto the
spectators in general. They that could behold
the doleful condition of the poor family without
sensible compassions, might have entrails in-
deed ; but I am sure they could have no true
bowels in them.
Sect. 6. It were a most unchristian and un-
civil, yea, a most unreasonable thing, to imagine,
that the fits of the young woman were but mere
impostures; and I believe scarce any but peo-
ple of a particular dirtiness will harbour such
an uncharitable censure. However, because I
3
2S SUFFERINGS OF
know not how far the devil may drive the ima-
gination of poor creatures, when he has pos-
session of them, that at another time, when they
are themselves, would scorn to dissemble any
thing, I shall now confine my narrative unto pas-
sages wherein there could be no room left for
any dissimulation. Of these, the first that I'll
mention shall be this: From the time that
Margaret Rule first found herself to be formal-
ly besieged by the spectres, until the ninth day
following, namely, from the lOth of September
to the 18th, she kept an entire fast, and yet she
was unto all appearance as fresh, as lively, as
hearty, at the nine days end, as before they be-
gan; in all this time, though she had a very ea-
ger hunger upon her stomach, yet, if any re-
freshment were brought unto her, her teeth
would be set, and she would be thrown into
many miseries ; indeed once or twice or so in
all this time, her tormentors permitted her to
swallow a mouthful of somewhat that might in-
crease her miseries, whereof a spoonful of rum
was the most considerable ; but otherwise, as I
said, her fast unto the ninth day was very ex-
treme and rigid: however, afterwards there
scarce passed a day wherein she had not liberty
to take something or other for her sustentation.
And I must add this, further, that this business
of her fast was carried so, that it was impossible
to be dissembled without a combination of mul-
titudes of people, unacquainted with one another,
to support the juggle ; but he that can imagine
such a thing of a neighbourhood, so filled with
virtuous 43eople, is a base man — I cannot call him
any other.
MARGARET RULE. 27
Sect. 7. But if tlie sufferings of this young
woman were not imposture, yet might they not
be pure distemper ? 1 will not here inquire of
our sadducoes, what sort of a distemper it is, that
shall stick the body full of pins without any
hand that could be seen to stick them; or
whether all the pin-makers in the world would
be willing to be evaporated into certain ill hab-
its of body, producing a distemper ; but of the
distemper my reader shall be judge, when I
have told him something further of those unu-
sual suiferings. 1 do believe that the evil an-
gels do often take advantage, from natural dis-
tempers in the children of men, to annoy them
with such further mischiefs, as we call preter-
natural. The malignant vapours and humours
of our diseased bodies maybe used by devils,
thereinto insinuating as engines of the execution
of their malice upon those bodies; and perhaps,
for this reason, one sex may suffer more trou-
bles of some kinds from the invisible world than
the other; as well as for that reason, for which
the old serpent made, where he did, his first ad-
dress. But I pray, what will you say to this ?
Margaret Rule would sometimes have her jaws
forcibly pulled open, whereupon something in-
visible would be poured down her throat; we
all saw her swallow, and yet we saw her try all
she could, by spitting, coughing and shrieking,
that she might not swallow ; but one time the
atanders-by plainly saw something of that odd li-
quor itself on the outside of her neck : she cried
out of it, as of scalding brimstone poured into
her, and the whole house would immediately
.28 SUFFERINGS OF
soent so hot of bxiiastone that we were scarce
able to endure it — whereof there are scores of
witnesses ; but the young woman herself would
be so monstrously inflamed, that it would have
broke a heart of stone to have seen her agonies.
This was a thing that several times happened;
and several times, when her mouth was thus
pulled open, the standers-by clapping their
hands close thereupon, the distresses that other-
wise followed would be diverted. Moreover
there was a whitish powder, to us invisible,
sometimes cast upon the eyes of this young wo-
man, whereby her eyes would be extremely in-
commoded; but one time some of this powder
was fallen actually visible upon her cheek, from
whence the people in the room wiped it with
their handkerchiefs; and sometimes the young
woman would also be so bitterly scorched with
the unseen sulphur thrown upon her, that very
sensible blisters would be raised upon her skin,
whereto her friends found it necessary to apply
the oils proper for common burnings; but the
most of these hurts would be cured in two or
three days at farthest. I think I may without
vanity pretend to have read not a few of the
best systems of physick that have been yet seen
in these American regions, but I must confess
that I have never yet learned the name of the
natural distemper whereto these odd symptoms
do belong: however, I might suggest perhaps
many a natural medicine which would be of sin-
gular use against many of them.
Sect. 8. " But there fell out some other mat-
ters far beyond the reach of natural distemper.
ivfAKGARET RULE. 29
This Margaret Rule once in the middle of the
night laniciiled sadly that the spectres threaten-
ed the drowning of a young man in the neigh-
bourhood, whom she named unto the company:
well, it was afterwards found that at that very-
time this young man, liaving been prest on board
a man of war, then in the harbour, was out of
some dissatisfaction attempting to swim ashore,
and he had been drowned in the attempt, if a
bvMt had not seasonably taken him up; it was
by computation a minute or two after the young
woman's discourse of the drowning, that the
young man took the water. At another time
siie told U-, that the spectres bragged and laugh-
ed in her hearing about an exploit they had lately
dane, by stealing fiom a gentleman his will soon
after he had written it; and within a few hours
after she had spoken this, there came to me a
gentleman with a private complaint, that having
written his will, it was unaccountably gone out
of the way ; how, or where, he could not imagine :
and besides all this, there were wonderful
noises every no w^ and then made about the room,
which our people could ascribe to no other au-
thors but the spectres ; yea, the watchers affirm,
that they heard those fiends clapping their hands
together with an aucHbleness wherein Tfi'ey could
not be imposed upon; and once her tormentors
pulled her up <o the cielingoi' the chamber, and
held her there, before a very numerous company
of spectators, who found it as much as they could
all do to pull her down again. There was also
another very surprising circumstance about her.
agreeable to what we have not only read m
.3^
30 SUFFERINGS OF
several histories concerning the imps that have
been employed in witchcraft, but also known in
some of* our own afflicted: we once thought we
perceived something stir upon her pillow at a
little distance from her; whereupon one present
laying his hand there, he to his horror appre-
hended that he felt, though none could see it, a
jiving creature not altogether unlike a rat, which
nimbly escaped from him ; and there were di-
vers other persons who w^ere thrown into a great
consternation by feeling, as they judged, at other
times, the same invisible animal.
Sect. 9. As it has been with a thousand
other enchanted people, so it was w'ith Margaret
Rule in this particular, that there were several
words which her tormentors would not let her
hear, especially the words Pray or Prayer, and
jet she could so hear the letters of those words
distinctly mentioned as to know what the*y
meant. The standers by were forced some-
times thus in discourse to spell a word to her ;
but because there were some so ridiculous as to
count it a sort of spell or a charm for any thus
to accommodate themselves to the capacity of
the sufferer, little of this kind was done. But
that which was more singular in this matter
was, that she could not use these words in those
penetrating discourses wherewith she would
sometimes address the spectres that were about
her. She would sometimes for a long while to-
gether apply herself to the spectres, whom she
supposedf the witches, with such exhortations
to repentance as w^ould have melted an heart
of adamant to have heard them ; her strains of
MARGARET RULE. 31
expression and argument were truly extraordi-
nary ; persons perhaps ol' the best education
and experience, and of attainments much beyond
hers, could not have exceeded them ; neverthe-
less, when she came to these words, God, Lord,
Christ, Good, ilepent, and some other such, her
mouth could not utter them; whereupon she
would sometimes, in an angry parenthesis, com-
plain of their wickedness in stopping that word,
but she would then go on with some other terms
that would serve to tell what she meant. And
I believe that if the most suspicious person in
the world had beheld all the circumstances of
this matter, he would have said it could not
have been dissembled.
Sect. 10. Not only in the Swedish, but also
in the Salem witchcraft, the enchanted people
have talked much of a white spirit, from whence
they received marvelloxts assistances in their mi-
series. What lately befel Mercy Short, from
the communications of such a spirit, hath been
the just wonder of us all ; but by such a spirit
was Margaret Rule now also visited. She says
that she could never see his face ; but that she
jiad a frequent view of his bright, shining and
glorious garments ; he stood by her bed-side
continually, heartening and comforting her, and
counselling her to maintain her faith and hope
in God, and never comply with the temptations
of her adversaries. She says he told her, that
God had permitted her afllictlons to befal her
for the everlasting and unspeakable good of her
own soul, and for the good of many others, and
for his own hnmortal glory ; and that she should
32 SUFFERINGS OF
therefore be of good cheer, and be assured of a
speedy deh'verance ; and the wonderful resolu-
tion of mind wherewith she encountered her
afflictions was but agreeable to such expecta-
tions. Moreover, a minister having one day with
some importunity prayed for the deliverance
of this young woman, and pleaded that as she
belonged to his flock and charge, he had so far
a right unto her as that he was to do the part
of a minister of our Lord for the bringing of her
home unto God, only now the devil hindered
him in doing that which he had a right thus to
do; and whereas he had a better title unto
her to bring her home to God, than the devil
could have unto her to carry her away from the
Lord, he therefore humbly apphed himself unto
God, who alone could right this matter, with a
suit that she might be rescued out of satan'S
hands. Immediately upon this, though she heard
nothing of this transaction, she began to call
that minister her father, and that was the name
w^hereby she every day before all sorts of peo-
ple distinguished him. The occasion of it she
says was thjs : the white spirit presently upon
this transac'ion did after this manner speak to
her: Margaret, you now are to take notice that
sucli a man is your father ; God has given you
to him; do you from this time look upon him
as your father, obey him, regard him, as your
father; lollow his counsels, and you shall do
well. And though theie was one passage more,
which I do as little know what to make. of as
any of the rest, I am now going to relate it:
more than three times have i seen it fulfilled in
MARGARET RULE. 36
bleness of her thoughts. INevcrtheless her for-
;ner troubles returned not; but we are noAV
Awaiting to see the good eflects of those troubles
ipon the souls of all concerned. And now I
thv>|)ose that some of our learned witlings of the
tfiFee-house, for fear lest these proofs of an in-
Jislble world sliould spoil some of their sport,
fci'ill endeavour to turn them all into sport; for
tvhich buffoonery their only pretence will be,
*'They can't understand how such things as
these could be done ;'* whereas indeed he that
is but philosopher enough to have read but one
little treatise, published in the year 1656, by no
other man than the chirurgeon of an army, or
but one chapter of^HehnonL which I will not
quote at this time too particularly, may give a
far more intelligible account of these appearan-
ces than most of these blades can give why and
how their tobacco makes them spit, or which
way the flame of their candle becomes illumi-
nating. As for that cavil, "The world would
be uhdone if the devils could have such power
as they seem to have in several of our stories,"
it may be answered, that as to many things, the
lying devils have only known them to be done,
and then pretended unto the doing of those
things ; but the true and best answer is, that by
these things we only see what the devils could
have power to do, if the great God should give
them that power; whereas now our histories
afford a glorious evidence for the being of a
God. The world would indeed be undone, and
horribly undone, if these devils, who now and
then get liberty to play some very mischievous
36 SUFFERINGS OP
pranks, were not under a daily restraint of some
Almighty Suj)erior from doing more of such
mischiefs. W herefore, instead of all apish shouts
and jeers at histories which have such undoubt-
ed confirmation, as that no man that has breed-
ing enough to regard the common laws of hu-
man society, will offer to doubt of them, it be-
comes us rather to adore the goodness of God,
who does not permit such things every day to
befdl us all, as he sometimes did permit to befal
some few of our miserable neighbours.
Sect. 12. And why, after all my unwearied
cares and pains to rescue the miserable from
the lions and bears of hell, which had seized
them, and after all my studies to disappoint the
devils in their designs to confound my neigh-
bourhood, must I be driven to the necessity of
an apology? Truly the hard representations
wherewith some ill men have reviled my con-
duct, and the countenance which other men
have given to these representations, oblige me
to give mankind some account of my behaviourr
No christian can (I say none but evil workers
can) criminate my visiting such of my poor flock
as have at any time fallen under the terrible
and sensible molestations of evil angels : let
their afflictions have been what they will, I
could not have answered it unto my glorious
Lord, if I had withheld my just counsels and
comforts from them; and if I have also with
some exactness observed the methods of the
invisible world, when they have thus become
observable, I have been but a servant of man-
kind in doing so ; yea^ no less a person than the
MARGARET RULE. 37
Venerable Baxter has more than once or twice
in the most publick manner invited mankind to
thank me for that service. I have not beeif in-
sensible of a greater danger attending me in this
fuliihnent of my ministry, than if I had been to
take ten thousand steps over a rocky mountain
iilled with rattle-snakes; but I have considered,
he that is wise will observe things; and the sur-
prising explication and conlirmation of the big-
gest part of the bible, w^hich I have seen given
in these things, has abundantly paid me for ob-
serving them. JNow, in my visiting of the mi-
serable, I v\as always of this opinion, that we
were ignorant of what power the devils miglit
have to do their mischiefs in the shapes of some
that had never been explicitly engaged in dia-
bolical confederacies, and that therefore, though
many witchcrafts had been ianly detected on
inquiries provoked and begun by spectral exhi-
bitions, yet we could not easily be too jealous of
the snares laid for us in the devices of Satan.
The world knows hov>^ many pages I have com-
posed and published, and particular gentlemen
in the government know how many letters I
have written, to prevent the excessive credit
of spectral accusations; wherefore I have still
charged the alHicted that they should cry out
of nobody for afflicting of them; but that, if this
might be any advantage, they might privately
tell their minds to some one person of discretion
enough to make no ill use ol their communica-
tions; accordingly there has been this elFect of
it, that the name of no one good person in the
world ever came under any blemish by mean$
as ^OFFERINGS OF
of an afflicted person that fell under my particu-
lar cognizance; yea, no one man, woman or
child ever came into any trouble for the sake of
any that were afflicted, after I had once begun
to look after them. How often have I had this
thrown into my dish, "that many years ago I
had an opportunity to have brought forth such
people as have in the late storm of witchcraft
been complained of, but that I smothered all;
and after that storm was raised at Salem, I did
myself offer to provide meat, drink and lodging
for no less than six of the afflicted, that so an
experiment might be made, whether prayer
with fasting, upon the removal of the distressed,
might not put a period to the trouble then ris-
ing, without giving the civil authority the trou-
ble of prosecuting those things which nothing
but a conscientious regard unto the cries of mi-
serable families could have overcome the reluc-
tancies of the honourable judges to meddle
with." In short, I do humbly but freely affirm
it, that there is not a man living in this world
who has been more desirous than the poor man
I to shelter my neighbours from the inconveni-
ences of spectral outcries; yea, I am very jea-
Jous I have done so much that way, as to sin
in what I have done ; such have been the cow-
ardice and fearfulness whereunto my regard un-
to the dissatisfaction of other people has pre-
cipitated me. I know a man in the world,
Tvho has thought he has been able to convict
some such witches as ought to die; but his re-
spect unto the pubilck peace has caused him
rather to trv whether he could not renew them
MARGARET RULE. . 39
by repentance ; and as I have been studious to
defeat the devils of their expectations to set
people together by the ears thus, I have also
checked and quelled those forbidden curiosities
Avhich would have given the devil an invitation
to have tarried amongst us, when I have seen
wonderful snares laid ibr curious people, by the
secret and future things discovered from the
mouths of damsels possest with a spirit of divi-
nation. Indeed I can recollect but one thing
wherein there could be given so much as a sha-
dow of reason for exceptions, and that is, my
allowing of so many to come and see those that
were afflicted. Now for that I have this to say,
that I have almost a thousand times entreated
the friends of the miserable, that they would
not permit the intrusion of any company, but
such as by prayers or other ways might be help-
ful to them ; nevertheless I have not absolutely
forbid all company from coming to your haunted
chambers ; partly because the calamities of the
families were such as required the assistance of
many friends ; partly because I have been wil-
ling that there should be disinterested witnesses
of all sorts, to confute the calumnies of such as
would say all was but imposture ; and partly
because I saw God had sanctified the spectacle
of the miseries on the afflicted unto the souls of
many that were spectators; and it is a very glo-
rious thing that 1 have now to mention : The
devils have with most horrid operations broke
in upon our neighbourhood, and God has at such
a rate overruled all the fury and malice of those
devils, that all the afflicted have not only heeu
4.0 SUFFERINGS OF
delivered, but 1 hope also savingly brought home
unto God, and the reputation of no one good per-
son in the world has been damaged; but instead
thereof the souls of many, especially of the ris-
ing generation, have been thereby awakened un-
to some acquaintance with religion; our young
people, who belonged unto the praying meetings,
of both sexes, apart, w^ould ordinarily spend
whole nights by whole weeks together in prayers
and psalms upon these occasions, in which de-
votions the devils could get nothing, but, like
fools, a scourge for their own backs; and some
scores of other young people, who were straa-
gers to real piety, were now struck with the
lively demonstrations of hell evidently set forth
before their eyes, when they saw persons cruel-
ly frighted, wounded and starved by devils, and
scalded with burning brimstone ; and yet so pre-
served in this tortured state, as that, at the end
of one month's wretchedness, they were as able
still to undergo another ; so that of these also it
might now be said, " Behold they pray." In the
^hole — the devil got just nothing — but God got
praises, Christ got subjects, the Holy Spirit got
temples, the church got addition, and the souls
of men got everlasting benefits. I am not so
vain as to say that any wisdom or virtue of mine
did contribute unto this good order of things;
but I am so just as to say, I did not hinder this
good. When therefore there have been those
that picked up little incoherent scraps and bits
of my discourses in this fruitful discharge of my
ministry, and so travestied them in their abusive
pamphlets as to persuade the town that I was
MARGARET RULE. 41
their common enemy in those very points, where-
in, if in any one thing whatsoever, I have sen-
sibly approved myselT as true a servant unto
them as possibly I could, though my life and soul
had been at stake for it — yea to do like satan
himself, by sly, base, unpretending insinuations,
as if I wore not the modesty and gravity which
became a minister of the gospel — I could not
but think myself unkindly dealt withal, and the
neglect of others to do me justice in this affair
has caused me to conclude this narrative with
complaints in another hearing of such monstroue
injuries.
4#
0:5^ The dates of the letters beginning on pages 56, 62 and HI
should have been printed 1693 (mstead of 1694) conformably to the
practice at that time beginning the yeai on the 25;h of March, and
^0 the dates of other letters in the book.
PART n.
SEVERAL LETTERS, &c.
Boston^ Jan* 11, 1693.
Mr. Cotton Mather,
Reverend Sir,
Finding it needful on many accounts, I
here present you with the copy of that paper
which has been se much misrepresented, to the
end that what shall be found defective or not
fairly represented (if any such shall appear)
they may be set right, — which runs thus :
September the Vdth, 1693. In the evening,
when the sun was withdrawn, giving place to
darkness to succeed, I with some others w^ere
drawn by curiosity to see Margaret Rule, and
so much the rather, because it was reported
Mr. M would be there that night. Being
come to her father's house, into the chamber
wherein she was in bed, I found her of a heal-
thy countenance, of about seventeen years old,
lying very still, and speaking very little ; what
she did say seemed asaf she were light-headed.
Then Mr. M (father and son) came up,
and othere with them 5 in the w^hole there wcrp:
44 LETTERS T©
about thirty or forty persons; they being set,
the father on a stool, and the son upon the bed-
side by her, the son began to question her :
Margaret Rule, how do you do ? then a pause
without any answer.
Question^ What! do there a great many
witches sit upon you? Answer, Yes.
Question, Do you not know that there is a
hard master? Then she was in a fit. He laid
his hand upon her face and nose, but as he said
without perceiving breath; then he brushed
her on the face with his glove, and rubbed her
stomach (her breast not being covered with the
bed-clothes) and bid others do so too, and said
it eased her — then she revived.
Q. Don't you know there is a hard master?
J, Yes.
Reply, Don't serve that hard master — ^you
know who.
Q. Do you believe ? Then again she was
in a fit, and he again rubbed her breast, &c.
About this time, Margaret Perd, an attend-
ant, assisted him in rubbing her. The afflicted
spake angrily to her, saying, Don't you meddle
with me— and hastily put away her hand. He
then wrought his fingers before her eyes, and
asked her if she saw the witches? A. No.
Q. Do you believe? J3, Yes.
Q. Do vou believe in you know who ? —
J. Yes.
Q. Would you have other people do so too-—
to believe in you know who? .y^. Yes.
Q. Who is it that afflicts you? A. 1 know
not, there is a great many of them.
MR. MATHER, &c. 4&
'About this time the father questioned, if she
knew the spectres. An attendant said, if she
did she would not tell. The son proceeded :
Q. You have seen the black man, have you
not? J, No.
Reply^ I hope you never will.
Q. You have had a book offered you, have
you not? Ji, No.
Q. The brushing of you gives you ease,
don't it ? A. Yes. She turned herself, and
a little groaned.
Q. Now the witches scratch you, and pinch
you, and bite you, don't they ? A. Yes.
Then he put his hand upon her breast and
belly, viz. on the clothes over her, and felt a.
living thing, as he said ; which moved the fa-
ther also to feel, and some others.
Q. Don't you feel the live thing in the bed ?
A, No.
Reply ^ That is only fancy.
Q. The great company of people increase
your torment, don't they ? A, Yes.
The people about were desired to withdraw.
One woman said, I am sure 1 am no witch, I
will not go; so others ; so none withdrew.
Q. Shall we go to prayers? Then she lay.
in a fit as before. But this time, tg, revive her,
they waved a hat, and brushed her head and
pillow therewith.
" Q. Shall we go to prayer, &c. spelling the
word. A, Yes.
The father went to prayer for perhaps half
an hour, chiefly against the power of the devil
aud witchcraft, and that God would bring out
46 LETTERS TO
the aSflicters. Durmg prayer-time, the son
stood by, and when they thought she was in a
fit, rubbed her and brushed her as before, and
beckoned to otb^ers to do the hke. Alter prayer
he proceeded:
Q. You did not hear when we were at prayer,
did you? Jl. Yes.
Q. You don't hear always — you did not hear
for some time past, a word or two, did you ?
Jl. No.
Then turning him about, said, this is just
another Mercy Short. Margaret Perd rephed,
she was not hke her in her fits.
Q. What does she eat or drink? Jl, She
does not eat at all, but drinks rum.
Then he admonished the young people to
take warning, ^Vc. saying it was a sad thing to
be so tormented by the devil and his instru-
ments. A young man present, in the habit of a
seaman, replied, " This is the Devil all over^
Then the ministers withdrew. Soon after they
were gone the afflicted desired ths women to be
gone, saying, that the company of the men wag
not offensive to her; and having hold of the
hand of a young man, said to have been her
sweetheart formerly, who was withdrawing, she
pulled him again into his seat, saying, he should
not go to night.
September the \9th, 1693. This night 1 renew-
ed my visit, and found her rather of a fresher
countenance than before. About eight personjr
were present with her. She was in a fit, scream-
ing and making a noise. Three or four per-
sons rubbed and brushed her_with their hands :
MR. MATHER, &c. 4 7
they said that the brushing did put them away,
If niey brushed or rubbed in tlie right place;
therefore they brushed and rubbed in several
places, and said that when they did it in the
right place she could fetch her breath, and by
that they knew. She being come to herself
was soon in a merry talking fit. A young man
came in, and asked her how she did. She an-
swered, very bad, but at present a little better.
He soon told her he must be gone, and bid
her good night; at which she seemed troubled,
saying that she liked his company, and said she
would not have him go till she was well; add-
ing, for I shall die when you are gone. Then
she complained they did not put lier on a clean
ca[>, but let her lie so like a beast, saying she
should lose all her fellows. She said she won-
dered any people should be so wicked as to
think she was not afflicted, but to think she dis-
sembled. A young woman answered, Yes, if
they were to see you in this merry fit, they
would say you dissembled indeed. She replied,
Mr. M said this was her laus^hingtime, she
must laugh now. She said Mr. M had been
there this evening, and she enquired how long
he had been gone. She said he stayed alone
with her in the room hali' an hour, and said that
he told her there were some that came for
spies, and to report about town that she was
not afflicted ; that during the said time she had
no fit; that he asked her it' she knew how ma-
ny times he had prayed for her to day; and
tiiat she answered, that she could not tell ; and
tlidt he replied, he had prayed for her nine
48 LETTERS TG
times to day, The attendants said that she
was sometimes in a f\t^ that none could open her
joints, and that there came an old iron-jawed
woman and tried, but could not do it; they
likewise said, that her head could not be moved
from the pillow. I tried to move her head, and
found no more difficulty than another person
(and so did others) but was not willing to offend
by lifting it up, once being reproved for endea-
vouring it ; they saying angrily, you will break
her neck. Tlie attendants said Mr. M
would not go to prayer with her when people
were in the room, as they did one night — that
night he felt the live creature. Margaret Perd
and another said they smelt brimstone. I and
others said we did not smell any ; then they said
they did not know what it was. This Marga-
ret said she wished she had been here when
Mr. M was here. Another attendant said,
If you had been here, you might not have been
permitted in, for her own mother was not suf-
fered to be present.
Sir, alter the sorest affliction and greatest
blemish to religion that ever belei this country,
and after most men began to fear that some un-
due steps had been taken, and alter his excel-
lency (with their Majesties' approbation as is
said) had put a stop to executions, and men be-
gan to hope there would never be a return of
the like; finding these accounts to contain in
them something extraordinary, I writ them down
the same nights, in order to attain the certainty
of them, and soon found them so confirmed that
I have (besides other demonstrations) the whole
MR. MATHER, &c. ..^
under the hands of two persons who arc ready
to attest the truth of it; but not satisfied here-
with, I shewed them to some of your particular
friends, that so I might have the greater cer-
tainty; but was much surprised with the mes-
sage you sent me, that I should be arrested for
slander, and at your calhng me one of the worst
oi' liars, making it pulpit news, with the name
of pernicious libels, &c. This occasioned my
first letter: [as followeth.]
September tJu 29th, 1693.
Revermd Sir,
1 having written from the mouths of several
persons, who affirm they were present with
Margaret Rule the 13th instant, her answers
and behaviour, &c. and having shewed it to
several of my friends, as also yours, and under-
standing you are offended at it, this is to acquaint
you that ilyou and any one particular friend will
please to meet me and some other indilierent
person with me at M?'. Wilkins's, or at Benj.
Harris's, you Intimatiiig the time, I shall be rea-
dy there to read it to you, as also a further ac-
count of j)roccedings the J 9th instant, which
may be needful to j.revent groundless prejudi-
ces, and let deserved blame be cast wliere it
ought. From, sir, yuurs, in what I mav,
k. c.
The effects of which, sir, (not to mention
that long letter only once rend to mc) uas, you
sent me word you would meet me at Mr. Wil-
Icins's; but, before (hat answer, at yuurs and
J LETTERS TO
your father's complaint, 1 was brought before
their majesties' justice, by warrant, for scanda-
lous hbels against yourself, and was bound over
to answ^er at sessions. I do not remember you
then objected against the truth of what I had
wrote, but asserted it was wronged by omis-
sions ; which, it" it were so, was past any power of
mine to remedy, having given a faithful account
of all that came to my knowledge : and, sir, that
vou might not be without some cognizance of
of the reasons why I took so much pains in it,
as also for my own information, (if it might have
been) I wrote to you my second letter to this
eifect :
JVovemher the 24th, 1693.
Reverend Sir,
Having expected some weeks your meeting
me at Mr. Wilkins's, according to what you in-
timated to me, and the time drawing near for
our meeting elsewhere, I thought it not amiss
to give you a summary of my tlioughts in the
great concern, which, as you say, has been agi-
tated with so much heat. That there are
witches is not the doubt ; the scriptures else
were vain, which assign their punishment to
be by death; but what this witchcraft is, or
wherein it does consist, seems to be the
whole difficulty: and as it may be easily demon-
strated, that all that bear that name cannot be
justly so accounted ; so that some things and
actions, not so esteemed by the most, yet upon
due examination w^ill be found to merit no bet-
ter character.
MR. MATHER, &c. i)l
In your late book you lay down a brief sy-
nopsis ol' what has been written on that subject,
by a triumvirate of as eminent men as ever
handled it (as you are pleased to call them) viz.
Mr. Perkins, Gaule and Bernard, consisting of
about thirty tokens to know them by, many of
them distinct from, if not thwarting, each other:
among all of which I can find but one decisive,
viz. tliat of Mr. Gaule, head iv, and runs thus :
'' Among the most unhappy circumstances to
convict a witch, one is a maligning and oppugning
the word, work or worship of God, and by any
extraordinary sign seeking to seduce any from it.
See Deut. xiii. 1. 2. Matt. xxiv. 24. Acts xiii.
8, 10. 2 Tim. iii. 8. Do but mark well the
places ; and lor this very property, of thus op
posing and perverting, they are all there con-
cluded arrant and absolute witches."
This head, as here laid down and inserted by
you, either is a truth or not; if not, why is it
here inserted from one of the triumvirate? If
it be a truth, as the scriptures quoted will abun-
dantly testify, whence is it that it is so little re-
garded, though it be the only head well proved by
scripture,or that the rest of the triumvirate should
so far forget their work as not to mention it ? It
were to be unjust to the memory of those other-
wise wise men, to suppose them to have any si-
nister design; but perhaps the force of a pre-
vailing opinion, together with an education there-
to suited, might overshadow their judgments, as
being wont to be but too prevalent in many other
cases. But if the above be truth, then the scrip-
ture is full and plain, what is witchcraft. And
52 LETTERS TO
if so, what need of his next head of hanging peo-
ple without as full and clear evidence as in oth-
ler cases? Or what need of the rest of the re-
ceipts of the triumvirate ? What need of pray-
ing that the afflicted may be able to discover who
it is that afflicts them ? or what need of search-
ing for teats for the devil to suck, in his old age 5
©r the experiment of saying the Lord's prayer,
&:c. with a multitude more, practised in some
places superstitiously inclined? Other actions
have been practised for easing the afflicted, less
justifiable, if not strongly savouring of witch-
craft itself, viz. fondly imagining by the hand, &c.
io drive off spectres, or to knock off invisible
chains, or by striking in the air to wound either
the afflicted or others, &c. I write not this to
accuse any, but that all may beware ; believing
that the devil's bounds are set, which he can-
not pass; that devils are so full of malice, that
it cannot be added to by mankind ; that where
he hath power he neither can nor wnll omit ex-
ecuting it; that it is only the Almighty that sets
bounds to his rage, and that only can coramis-
sionate him to hurt or destroy any.
These last, sir, are such foundations of truth,
in my esteem, that I cannot but own it to be
my duty to assert them, when called, though
with the hazard of my all ; and consequently to
detest such as these, that a witch can commis-
sionate devils to afflict mortals ; that he can, at
his or the witch's pleasure, assume any shape ;
that hanging or drowning of witches can lessen
his power of afflicting, or restore those that
were at a distance tormented, with many others
MR. MATHER, isic. 53
depending on these ; all tending, in my esteem,
highly to the dishonour of God, and the endan-
gering the well-being of a people ; and do fur-
ther add, that as the scriptures are full that
there is witchcraft (ut sup.) so 'tis as plain that
there are possessions, and that the bodies of the
possest have hence been not only afflicted, but
strangely agitated, if not their tongues improved
to foretel futurities, &c. and why not to accuse
the innocent, as bewitciiing them? having pre-
tence to divination to gain credence. This be-
ing reasonable to be expected from him who is
the father of lies, to the end he may thereby
involve a country in blood, malice and evil-sur-
mising, which he greedily seeks after, and so
finally lead them from their fear and depen-
dence upon God, to fear him and a supposed
witch, thereby attaining his end upon mankind;
and not only so, but natural distempers, as has
been frequently observed by the judicious, have
so operated as to deceive more than the vulgar,
as is testified by many famous physicians and
others. And as for that proof of multitudes of
confessions, this country may be by this time
thought competent judges wliat credence we
ouofht to orive them, having^ had such numerous
instances, as also how obtained.
And now, sir, if herein be any thing in your
esteem valuable, let me entreat you not to ac-
count it the worse for coming from so mean a
hand; which, however you may have received
prejudice, &c. am ready to serve you to my
power; but if you judge otherwise hereof, you
6-4 LETTERS TO
may take your own methods for my better irn
formation. Who am, sir, yours to command, in
what I may, R. C.
In answer to this last, sir, you replied to the
gentleman that presented it, that you had no-
thino- to prosecute against me ; and said, as to
your sentiments in your books, you did not bind
any to believe them; and then again renewed
your promise of meeting me, as before, though
not yet performed. Accordingly, though I wait-
ed at sessions, there was none to object ought
against me, upon which I was dismissed. This
gave me some reason to beheve that you intend-
ed all should have been forgotten ; but, instead
of that, I find the coals are fresh blown up, I
being supposed to be represented, in a late manu-
script. More Wonders of the, &c. as travestying
your discourse in your faithful discharge of
Your duty, &c. and such as see not with the au-
thor's eyes, rendered sadducees and widings, &c.
and the arguments that square not with the
sentiments therein contained, buffoonery ; rarely,
no doubt, agreeing with the spirit of Christ, and
his dealings with an unbelieving Thomas, yet
wliose infidelity was without compare less excus-
able ; but the author having resolved long since
to have no more than one single grain of patience
with them that deny, &e. the wonder is the less.
It must needs be that offences come, but wo to him
by whom they come. To vindicate myself there-
fore from such false imputations, of satan-likc
insinuations, and misrepresenting your action?^
MR. MATilKR, kc.
&CC, and to vlnilicate yourself, sir, as much as is
in my power, t'roiii those suo^i»esti()ns, said to be
insinuated, as it" you wore not the modesty and
gravity that becomes a minister of the gospel ;
which, it seems, some, that never saw tfie said
narratives, report tliem to contain ; I say, sir,
for these reasons, I here present you with the
first copy that ever was taken, &c. and purpose
for a week's time to be ready, if you shall inti-
mate your pleasure to wait upon me, either at
the place formerly appointed, or any other that
is inditi'ercnt ; to the end that, if there shall a|>
pear any defects in tiiat narrative, they may be
amended.
Thus, sir, I liave given you a genuine account
of my sentiments and actions in this affair ; and
do request and pray, that if I err, I may.be
shewed it from scrij>ture, or sound reason, and
not by quotations out of Virgil, nor Spanish rhe-
torick. For I find the withngs mentioned are
so far from answering your profound questions,
that they cannot so much as pretend to shew a
distinction between witchcraft in the common
notion of it, and possession ; nor so much as to
demonstrate that ever the jews or primitive
christians did believe that a witch could send a
devil to afflict her neighbours. But to all these,
sir, (ye being the salt of the earth, «kc.) I have
reason to hope for a satisfactory answer to him,
who is one tliat reverences your person and of-
fice ; and am, sir, yours to command, in what
I may, R. C.
56 LETTERS TO
Boston^ Jan, the 15th, 1694
Mr, R a
Whereas you intimate your desires, that
what is not fairly (I take it for granted you
mean truly also) represented in a paper you
lately sent me, containing a pretended narrative
of a visit by my father and self to an afflicted
young woman, whom we apprehended to be un-
der a diabohcal possession, might be rectified ; I
have this to say, as I have often ah^eady said,
that 1 do scarcely find any one thing in the
whole paper, whether respecting ray father or
self, either fairly or truly represented: Nor can
i think that any, that know my parent's circum-
stances, but must think him deserving a better-
character by far, than this narrative can be
thought to give him. When the main design
we managed, in visiting the poor afflicted crea-
ture, was to prevent the accusations of the
neighbourhood, can it be fairly represented that
our design was to draw out such accusations ?
which is the representation of the paper. We
have testimonies of the best witnesses, and in
number not a few, that when we asked Rule
whether she thought she knew who tormented
her, the question was but an introductionJo the
solemn charges which w^e then largely gave,
that she should rather die than tell the names
of any whom she might imagine that she knew,
your informers have reported the question, and
report nothing of what follows, as essential to
the giving of that question. And can this be
termed a piece of fairness ? Fair it cannot be,
that when ministers faithfully and carefully diii-
MR. MATHER, &c. 67
charge their duty to the miserable in tlieir
flock, httle bits, scraps and shreds of their dis-
courses should be tacked together to make them
contemptible, when there shall be no notice of
all the necessary, seasonable and profitable
things that occurred in those discourses ; and
without which, the occasion of the lesser passa-
ges cannot be understood : and yet I am furnish-
ed with abundant evidences, ready to be sworn,
that will positively prove this part of unfairness,
by the above mentioned narrative, to be done
both to my father and self. Again, it seems not
fair or reasonable that I should be exposed for
that which yourself (not to say some others)
might have exposed me for if I had not done,
viz. for discouraging so much company from
flocking about the possest maid; and yet, as I
persuade myself, you cannot but think it to be
good advice to keep much company from such
haunted chambers. Besides, the unfairness doth
more appear, in that I find nothing re])catcd of
what I said about the advantage which the
devil takes from too much observation and cu-
riosity.
In that several of the questions in the paper
are so worded as to carry in them a presuppo-
sal of the things Inquired after, to say tiic best
of it, is very unfair. But this is not all; the
narrative contains a number of mistakes and
falsehoods, which, were they wilful and design-
ed, might justly be termed gross lies. The re-
presentations are far from true,, when 'tis af-
firmed my father and self beln<i^ come into the
room, I began tiie discourse : I hope I under^
58 LETTERS TO
«tand breeaing a little better than so. For
proof of this, did occasion serve, sundry can de-
pose the contrary.
'Tis no less untrue, that either ray father or
self put the question, How many witches sit up-
on you? We always cautiously avoided that
expression, it being contrary to our inward be-
lief. All the standers-by will, I believe, swear
they did not hear us use it, (your witnesses ex-
cepted) and I tremble to think how hardy those
woful creatures must be, to call the Almighty,
by an oath, to so false a thing. As false a re-
presentation 'tis, that 1 rubbed Rule's stomach,
her breast not being covered. The oath of the
nearest spectators, giving a true account of that
matter, will prove this to be little less than a
gross (if not a doubled) lie ; and to be somewhat
plainer, it carries the ijace of a lie contrived on
urpose (by them at least to whom you arc
eholden for the narrative) wickedly and basely
to expose me : for you cannot but know hovr
much this representation hath contributed to
make people believe a smutty thing of me. I am
far from thinking but that in your own conscience
you believe, that no indecent action of that nature
could then be done by me before such observ-
ers, had I been so wicked as to have been in-
clined to wliat is base. It looks next to impos-
sible that a reparation should be made me for
the wrong done to (I hope, as to any scandal)
an unblemished, though weak and small, servant
of the church of God. Nor is what follows a
less untruth, that it was an attendant and not
myself who said, If Rule knows who afflicts her.
i:,
MR. MATHER, &c. 5B
yet she won't tell. 1 therefore spoke it that I
might encourage her to continue in that conceal-
ment of all names whatsoever; to this I am able
to furnish myself with the attestation of sufficient
oaths. 'Tis as far from true, that my appre-
hension of the imp, about Rule, was on her bel-
ly; for the oaths of the spectators, and even of
those that thought they felt it, can testily that it
was upon the pillow, at a distance from her bo-
dy. As untrue a representation is that which
follows, viz. that it was said unto her, tnat
her not apprehending of that odd, palpable,
though not visible, mover, was from her fancy;
for I endeavoured to persuade her that it might
be but fancy in others, that there was any such
thing at all. Witnesses eyevy way sufficient
can be produced for this also. It is ialsely re-
presented, that my father felt on the young wo-
man after the appearance mentioned, i'or his
hand was never near her; oath can sufficiently
vindicate him. 'Tis very untrue, that my father
prayed, for perhaps half an hour, against the
povver of the devil and witclicraft, and that God
would bring out the afflicters : witnesses of the
best credit can depose, that his prayer was not
a quarter of an hour, and that there was no more
than about one clause, towards the close of the
prayer, which was of this import; and this
clause also was guarded with a singular wariness
and modesty, viz. If there were any evil in-
struments m this matter, God would please to
discover them: and that tlierc was more than
common reason for that petition, I can satisfy
any one that will please to inquire of jne. And
60 LETTERS Td
strange it is, that a ge.uilemm) that from eigh-
teen to fifty-four hath been an exemphirj mi-
nister of the gospel; and tliat, besides a station
in the church ol God, as considerable as any
that his. own country can afford, hath for divers
years come off with honour, in his apphcation to
three crowned heads, and the chiefest nobihty of
three kingdoms; knows not yet how to make
one short prayer of a quarter of an hour, but
in New-England he must be hbelled for it.
Tliere are divers other down-right mistakes,
which you have permitted yourself (I would
hope not knovvin^ly and with a malicious design)
to be receiver or compiler of, which I shall now
forbear to animadvert upon. As for the appen-
dix of the narrative, I do find myself therein in-
juriously trealed; i'ov the utmost of your proof,
for what you say of me, amounts to little more
than this, viz. Some people told you, that others
told them, that such and such things did pass;
but Yt>^ niay assure yourself, that I am nut unfur-
nisl-ed with witnesses that can convict the same.
Whereas you would give me to believe the bot-
tom of these, your methods, to be some dissatis-
faction about the commonly received power of
devils and witches; I do not only with all free-
dom ofier you the use of any part of my library,
which you may see cause to peruse on that sub-
ject, but also, if yuu and any one else, whom you
please, will visit me at my study, yea, or meet
me at any other place, less inconvenient than
those by you proposed, I will with all the fair-
ness and calmness in the world dispute the point.
?! beg of God ihdt he would bestow as many
MR. MATIIEK, kc. Gl
blessings on jou, as ever on myseli'; and out of
a sincere wish that you may be made yet more
capable of these blessings, I take this occasion
to lay before you the faults (not few nor small
ones neither) which the paper contained, you
lately sent me, in order to be examined by me.
In case you want a true and full narrative of my
visit, whereof such an indecent travesty (to say
the best) hath been made, I am not unwilling to
communicate it; in mean time must take liberty
to say, it is scarcely consistent with common ci-
vility, much less christian charity, to oiler the
narrative, now with you, for a true one, till you
have a truer; or for a full one, till you have a
fuller. Your sincere (though injured) friend
and servant, C. Mather.
The copy of a paper received ivilh the above letter,
1 do testify that 1 have seen Margaret Rule,
in her afflictions from the invisible world, lifted
up from her bed, wholly by an invisible force, a
great way towards the top of the room where
she lay ; in her being so lifted, she had no as-
sistance from any use of her own arms or hands,
or any other part of her body, not so much as
her heels touching her bed, or resting on any
support whatsoever. And 1 have seen her thus
lifted, when not only a strong person hath thrown
his whole weight across her to pull her down,
but several other persons have endeavoured,
with all their might, to hinder her from being
so raised up; which I suppose that several oth-
ers will testify as well as myself when called un-
to it. Witness mv hand, Samuel Ave'-
6
62 LETTERS TO
We can also testify to the substance of what
is above written; and have several times seen
Margaret Rule so hfted up from her bed. as
that she had no use of her own Hmbs to help her
up; but it was the declared apprehension of us,
as w^ell as others, that saw it, impossible for any
hands, but some of the invisible world, to lift her.
Robert Earle,
John Wilkins,
Dan. Williams.
We, whose names are under- written, do testi-
fy, that one evening, when we were in the cham-
ber where Margaret Rule then lay, in her late
?iffliction, we observed her to be, by an invisible
force, lifted up from the bed whereon she lay,
so as to touch the garret floor, while yet neither
her feet, nor any other part of her body, rested
either on the bed or any other support, but were
also, by the same force, lifted up from all that
was under her; and all this for a considerable
while, we judged it several minutes; and it was
as much as several of us could do, with all our
strength, to pull her down. All which happened
-when there was not only we two in the chamber,
but we suppose ten or a dozen more, whose
names we have forgotten. ^.^^^^^^ Thornton
WiLLL\M Hudson
testifies to the substance of Thorniorfs testimony^
to which he also hath set his hand,
.. ^ ., Boston. January \^^\^M.
Mr. Cotton Mather, ^
Reverend Sir,
Yours of the 15lh instant 1 received yester-
day, and soon found I had promised myselt too
MR. MATHER, &c. tid
much by it, viz. either concurrence with, or ei
denial ol, those fundamentals mentioned in mine,
of November the 24th, finding this waved by
an invitation to your hbrary, (fee. I tliank God 1
have the bible, and do judge that sufficient to
demonstrate that cited head of Mr. Gaule to be
a truth, as also those other heads mentioned as
the foundations of rehgion. And in my appre-
hension, if it be asked any christian, whether God
governs the world, and whether it be he only can
commissionate devils, and such other fundamei>
tals, he ought to be as ready as in the question,
Who made him? (A little writing certainly
might be of more use, to clear up the contro-
verted points, than either looking over many
books in a well furnished library, or than a dis-
pute, if I were qualified for it; the inconvenien-
cies of passion being this way best avoided.) And
am not without hopes that you will yet oblige
me so far, as to consider that letter, and if I err,
to let me see it by scripture, &;c.
Yours, almost the whole of it, is concerning
the narrative I sent to you ; and you seem to in-
timate as if I were giving characters, reflections,
libels, &ic. concerning yourself and relations; all
which were as far from my thoughts, as ever
they w^ere in writing after either yourself, or any
other minister. In the front you declare your
apprehension to be, that the afflicted was under
a diabolical possession; and if so, 1 see not how
it should be occasioned by any witchcraft (unless
we ascribe that power to a witch, which is only
the prerogative of the Almighty, of sending or
commissionating the devils to afflict her.) But
64 LETTERS T(i
to your particular objections against the narra-
tive; and to the first. My intelligence not giv-
ing me any further, 1 could not insert that I knew
not And it seems improbable that a question
should be put, whether she knew wdio they were
that tormented her, and at the same time to
charge her, and that upon her life, not to tell;
and if you had done so, I see but little good you
could promise yourself or others by it, she b^ing
possest, as also having it inculcated so much
to her, of witchcraft. And as to the next ob-
jection, about company flocking, <kc. I profess
my ignorance, not knowing what you mean by it.
And, sir, that most of the questions did carry
with them a presupposing the things inquired
after, is evident, if there were such as those re-
lating to the hlach man and a book, and about
her hearing the prayer, &c. (related in the said
narrative, which 1 find no objection against.) As
to that which is said of mentioning yourself first
discoursing, and your hopes that your breeding
was better, (I doubt it not, nor do I doubt your
father might first apply himself to others) my
intelligence is, that you first spake to the afflict-
ed or possessed, for which you had the advan-
tage of a nearer approach. The next two ob-
jections are founded upon mistakes: I find not
in i\\e narrative any such question, as How ma-
ny witches sit upon you.^ nor, that her breast
was not covered, in which those material words,
with the bed clothes^ are wholly omitted. I am
not willing to retort here your own language up-
on you ; but can tell you, that your own discourse
of it publickly, at SirW.Ps table, has much more
MR. MATHER, kc. 66
contributed to, <kc. As to the reply, \i she could
she would not tell, whetlier either or both spake
it, it matters not much. Neither does the nar-
rative say, you felt the live thing on her belly;
though 1 omit now to say what further demon-
strations there are of it. As to that reply, That
is only her fancy, I find the word her added.
Aad as to your father's feeling for the live crea-
ture after you had ielt it, if it were on the bed it
was not so very far from her. And for the length
of his prayer, possibly your witnesses might
keep a more exact account of the time than
those others, and I stand not for a few minutes.
For the rest of the objections, I suppose them of
less moment, if less can be; however, shall be
ready to receive them. Those matters of great-
est concern 1 find no objections against. These
being all that yet appear, it may be thought
that if the narrative be not fully exact, it was as
near as memory could bear away ; but should
be glad to see one more perfect (which yet is
nut to be expected, seeing none wrote at the
same time.) You mention the appendix, by
which I understand the second visit ; and if you
be by the possessed belied (as being half an
hour with her alone, excludino^ her own mother,
and as telling her you had prayed lor her nine
times that day, and that now was her lauohino-
tune, she must laugh now) 1 can sec no wonder
in It: Wiiat can be expected less from the fa-
ther of lies, by wnom, you judge, she was pos-
ses t ?
And besides the ab ne letter, you were pleas-
ed to send me anoiher paper, containing several
6*
66 LETTERS TO
testimonies of the possessed being lifted up, and
held a space of several minutes to the garret
floor, (fee. but they omit giving the account,
^vhether after she was down they bound her
down, or kept holding her ; and relate not how
many were to pull her down, which hinders the
knovtledge what number they must be, to be
stronger than an invisible force. Upon tPie
whole, I suppose you expect 1 should believe
it; and if so, the only advantage gained is, that
what has been so long controverted between
protestants and papists, whether miracles are
ceast, will hereby seem to be decided for the
latter; it being, for ought I can see, if so, as
true a miracle as for iron to swim; aiul the de*
vil can work such miracles.
But, sir, to leave these little disputable things,
I do again pray that you would let me have the
happiness of your approbation or confutation of
that letter before referred to.
And now, sir, that the God of all grace may
enable us zealously to own his truths, and to
follow those things that tend to peace, and that
yourself may be as an useful instrument in his
hand, effectually to ruin the remainder of hea-
thenish and popish superstitions, is the earnest
desire and prayer of yours to command in what
I may, R. C.
Postscript. — Sir, I here send you tlio copy of a paper
that lately came to my hands ; which, though it contains
ao wonders, yet is remarkable, and runs thus :
.^71 account ofza^hat an Indian told Capt. Hill at Saco Fort.
The Indian told him, that the French ministers were
better than the English ; for before the French came
/among them there were a great many witches among the
Mil. MATHER, kt. (,7
Indians; but now there were none; and there were
witches among the English ministers, as Burroughs, who
was hang'd tor it.
Were I disposed to make reflections upon it, I suppose
you will ju(!ge the tield large enough ; but I Ibrbear.
As above, R, C.
Boston, Feb. 19, 1694.
Mr. Cotton Mather,
Reverend Sir^
I have received as yet no answer to mine of
November the 24th, except an offer to peruse
books, (fee. relating to the doctrinal* therein
contained; nor to my last, of January the 18t!i,
in which 1 again prayed that if I erred I mioht
be shewed it by scripture, viz. in believing that
the devil's bounds are set, which he cannot pass
— that the devils are so full of malice, that it
can't be added to by mankind — that where he
hath power, he neither can nor will omit exe-
cuting it — that it is only the Almighty that sets
bounds to his rage, and who only can commis-
sion him to hurt or destroy any ; and conse-
quently to detest, as erroneous and dangerous,
the belief that a witch can commission devils to
afflict mortals — that he can at his or the witch's
pleasure assume any shape — that the hanging
or drowning of witches can lessen his power
of afflicting, and restore those that were at a
distance tormented by him; — and whether
witchcraft ought to be understood, now in this
age, to be the same that it was when the divine
oracles were given forth, particularly those quo-
ted by mr. Gaule, in that cited head. Wonders
of the Invisible World (mr. Gaule's fourth head)
to discover witches, which do so plainly shew ^
C8 LETTERS TO
witch, in scripture sense, to be one that maligns^
&:c. and that pretends to give a sign in order to
seduce, &c. For I have never understood, in
my time, any sucli have suffered as witches,
though sufficiently known; but the only witch
now inquired after is one that is said to become
so by making an exphcit covenant with the de-
vil, i. e. the devil appearing to them, and mak-
ing a compact, mutually promising each to other ;
testified by their signing his book, a material
book, which he is said to keep; and that there-
by they are intituled to a power, not only to af-
flict others, but such as is truly exorbitant, ii'not
highly intrenching upon the prerogative of hina
who is the Sovereign Being : For v*'ho is he that
saith, and it cometh to pass, when the Lord
commandeth it not ?
Such explicit covenant being, as is said, in this
age, reckoned essential to complete a witch;
yet I finding nothing of such covenant (or pow-
er thereby obtamed) in scripture, and jet a
witch therein so fully described, do pray that if
there be any such scriptures I may be directed
to them ; for as to the many legends in this
case, I make no account of them: I read indeed
of a covenant with de.jth and with hel). but sup-
pose that to be in the heart (or menhd) only,
and see not what use such an explicit one can
be of between spirits, any further than as 'tis a
copy of that mental which is in the heart. The
dire effects and consequences of such notion may
be f" und written in indelible Roman characters
of blood, in all countries where they have pre-
vailed. And what less can be expected, when
MR. MATHER, L^. ^9
men are indicted lor that, which it is iinpossiblc
to jirove, so as for any to clear himself of, viz.
such exphcit covenant with the devil ; and then,
for want of better evidence, must take up with
such as the nature of such secret covenant can
bear, as mr. Gaule hath it, i. e. distracted sto-
ries, and strange and foreign events, &:c. thereby
endeavouring to find it, though by its but suppo-
sed effects. By the same rule that one is put
to purge himself of such compact, by the same
may all mankind.
This then being so important a case, it con-
cerns all to know what foundations in scripture
are laid for such a sti-ucture ; for if they are
deficient of tiiat warrant, the more eminent the
architects are, the more dangerous are they
thereby rendered^ <fec. These are such consi-
derations as I think will vindicate me, in the
esteem of all lovers of humanity, in my endea-
vours to get them cleared ; and, to that end, do
once more pray, that you would so far oblige
me as to give your approbation or coni'utation
of the above doctrinals ; but if you think silence
a virtue in this case, I shall (I suppose) so far
comply with it as not to lose you any more time
to look over my papers. And if any others will
so far oblige me, t shall not be ungrateful to
them. Praying God to guide and prosj^er you,
I am, sir, yours to my power, R. C.
(He that doth truth cometh to the lii(ht,)
70 LETTERS T0>
Boston, April the IQth, 1694
Mr. Cotton Mather,
Reverend Sir,
Having as yet received no answer to my last,
touching the doctrinals therein referred to,
though at the dehvery of it you were pleased
to promise the gentleman that presented it that
I should have it, and after that you acquainted
the same gentleman you were about it; the
length of time since those promises makes me
suppose you are preparing something for the
press (for I w^ould not question your veracity ;)
and I think it may not be amiss, when you do
any thing of that nature for the public view, that
you also explain some passages of some late
books of yours and your relations, which are
hard to be understood ; to instance in a few of
many; Wonders of the Invisible World, page 17,
" Plagues are some of those woes with which
the devil causes our trouble." Page 18, " Hence
come such plagues as that besom of destruction
which within our memory swept away such a
throng of people from one English city, in one
visitation. Wars are some of those woes with
which the devil causes our trouble." Page 16,
*' Hence 'tis that the devil, like a dragon keep-
ing a guard upon such fruits as would refresh a
languishing world, has hindered mankind lor ma»
ny ages from hitting upon those useful inventions.
The benighted world must jog on, for thousands
of years, without the knowledge of the I -ad-
stone, printing, and spectacles." Page 10, ^' It
is not likely that every devil does know every
language. 'Tis possible the experience, or, if {
MR. M\THER, &c. 71
mny call it so, the ediiCatlon, of all devils is not
alike." Cases ( J' Conscience^ P^g^ ^^^ " '^^^^ devil
has inflicted on many the disease called the ly-
canthropia." Memorable Providences relating to
Witchcraft Disc, page 24, "I am also apt to
think that the devils are seldom able to hurt us
in any of our exterior concerns, without a com-
mission from some of our fellow worms. When
foul mouth'd men shall wish harm to their neigh-
bours, they give a commission to the devil to
perform what they desire ; and if God should
not mercifully prevent, they would go through
with it. Hear this, you that in wild passion will
give every thing to the devil; hear it, you that
bespeak a rot, a pox, or a plague, on all that
shall provoke you; 1 here indict you as guilty
of hellish witchcraft in the sight of God." Jlore
Wonders of the Invisible Worlds p. 49, " They
each of them have their spectres or devils com-
missioned by them, and representing them."
Page 14, " But such a permission from God ibr
the devil to come down and break in upon man-
kind, must often times be accompanied with a
commission from some of mankind itself" AV
chantments encountered., '' Tliese witches have
driven a trade of commissioning their conlede-
rate spirits to do all sorts of mischiefs to their
neighbours." Page 50, ^^They have bewitched
some, even so far as to make them self-destroy-
ers." Page 144, '* As; I am abundantly satisfied,
th;t many of the self-murders, committed here,
have been the effects ( f a cruel and bloody witch-
craft, letting fly daemons upon the miserable Se-
necas." Page 51, " We have seen some of their
72 LETTERS TO
children dedicated to the devil, that in their in-
fancy the imps have sucked them." Cases of
Consience^ P^g^ ^"^5 " ^^^^^y bequeath their dae-
mons to the children as a legacy, by whom they
are often assisted to see and do things beyond
the power of nature." Page 21, ''There is in
Spain a sort of people railed Zahurs, that can
see into the bowels of the earth." On Tues-
days and Fridays, and to add that in page 49 ;
the words are, ^' For the law of God allows of
no revelation from any other spirit but himself,
Isa. viii. 19. It is a sin ao^ainst God to make
use of the devil's help, to know that which can-
not be otherways known ; and I testify against
it as a great transgression, which may justly pro-
voke that Holy One of Israel to let loose devils
on the whole land. Although the devil's accu-
sation may be so far regarded, as to cause an in-
quiry into the truth of things, (Job i. J 1, 12, and
ii. 5, 6) yet not so as to be an evidence or ground
of conviction; for the devil's testimony ought
not to be taken in whole nor in part." It is a
known truth, that some unwary expressions of
the primitive fathers were afterwards impro-
ved for the introducing and establishing of er-
ror, as their calling the Virgin Mary the mother
of God, &:c. Hence occasion and advantage
were taken to propagate the idoli2;ing of her.
The like might be said of the eucharist. These
assertions, above reliearsed, being apparently
liable to a like mal-construction, and no less dan-
gerous, are therefore, as I said, highly needful
to be explained, and that in a most public man-
ner. For were they to be understood literally.
MR. MATHEa, &c. 73
and as they are spoken, it must seem as it' the
authors were introducing among christians very
dangerous doctrines, such as, were they asserted
by the best of men, yet ought to be rejected by
all, &c. viz. That 'tis the devil that brings the
most of evils upon mankind, by way of infliction,
that do befal them ; and that the witch can
commission him to the performance of these ;
with many other as dangerous doctrines, and
such as seem in their tendency to look favoura-
bly upon the antient pagan doctrines of this
country, who believed that God did hurt to none,
but good to all, but that the devil must be pleas-
ed by worshiping, &c. from whom came all their
miseries, as they believed. For what were all
this, but to rob God of his glory in the highest
manner, and give it to a devil and a witch ? Is
it not he that hath said. Shall there be evil in a
city, and the Lord hath not done it ? But if any
are fond of their own notions, because some
eminent men before now have asserted them,
they may do well to compare them with that
excellent saying ( Wonders of the Invisible Worlds
p. 7) '^ About this devil there are many things,
whereof we may reasonably and profitably be
inquisitive ; such things I mean as are in our bi-
bles revealed to us 5 according to which if we
do not speak on so dark a subject, but according
to our own uncertain and perhaps humoursome
conjectures, there is no light in us." Or that
other, p. 75, " At every other weapon the de-
vil will be too hard for us." For 'lis most cer-
tain that other notions, weapons and praclicea
U^ve been taken up with, and that the event
7
74 LIFTERS TO
]ias been answerable : the devil has been too
hard for such as have so done. I shall forbear
to instance from the dogmatical part, and shall
mention some practices that as much need ex-
plaining ; JMem. Provid. RcL to Witchc pages 29,
30, 31 ; where account is given that it was pray-
ed for that the afflicted might be able to declare,
whom she apprehended herself affljcted by, to-
gether with the immediate answer of such
prayer. To this you once replied, when it was
mentioned to you, that you did not then under-
stand the wiles of satan.
To which I have nothing to object, but it
might be a good acknowledgment. But consid-
ering that tlie book is gone forth into all the
world, I cannot but think the salve ought to be
proportioned to the sore, and the notice of the
devil's wiles as universal as the means recom-
mending them. Another practice is, (pages 20,
21,) "There was one singular passion that fre-
quently attended her ; an invisible chain would
be clapt about her, and she in much pain and fear
cry out when they began to put it on: once I
did with my own hand knock it off as it began
to be fastened about her." If this were done
by the power or virtue of any ordinance of di-
vine instruction, it is well ; but would have been
much better if the institution had been demon-
strated; or was there any physical virtue in that
particular hand ? But supposing that neither of
these will be asserted by the author, I think it
very requisite, that the world may be acquaint-
ed with the operation, and to what ait or craft
to refer their power of knocking off invisible
MR. MATHER, &c. 75
chains. And thus, sir, I have faltlifuliy dis-
charged what in this I took to be my duty, and
am so far from doing it to gain applause, or from
a spirit of contradiction, that I expect to pro-
cure me many enemies thereby ; but (as in case
of a fire) where the glory of God and the good
and welfare of mankind are so nearly concerned,
I thought it my duty to be no longer an idle
spectator; and can and do say, to the glory of
God, in this whole affair, I have endeavoured to
keep a conscience void of offence, both tow^ards
God and towards man ; and therein at the least
have the advantage of such as are very jealous
they have done so much herein, as to sin in what
they have done, viz. in sheltering the accused;
such have been the cowardice and fearl'ulness,
into which a regard to the dissatisfaction of oth-
er people have precipitated them; which by
by the way must needs acquaint all, that for the
future other measures are resolved upon (by
such) which, how bloody they may prove when
opportunity shall offer, is with him v/ho orders
all things according to the counsel of his own
will.. And now, that the song of angels may be
the emulation of men, is the earnest desire and
prayer of, sir, yours to command in what I may,
R C.
Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace, and
good will towards men.
Tvf T> Boston, March the 1st, 1694.
Mr. B , '
Worthy Sir,
After more than a year's waiting for the per-
formance of a reiterated promise from one un-
76 LETTERS TO
der singular obligations^ and a multitude of ad*
vantages to have done it sooner^ the utmost com-
pliance I have met with is (by your hands) the
srght of four sheets of rescinded papers. But I
must first be obliged to return them in a fort-
night, and not copied, which I have now com-
plied with : and having read them, am not at all
surprised at the author's caution, not t6 admit of
such crude matter and impertinent absurdities,
as are to be found in it. He seems concerned
that 5 take no notice of his several books, where-
in, as he safth, he has unanswerably proved
things. To this I might reply, that 1 have sent
him letters of quotations out of those books, to
know how much of them he will abide by ; for
I thought it hard to affix their natural consequent.
ces, till he had opportunity to explain them.
And saith, that he hath sent me mr. Baxter's
World of Spirits^ an ungainsayable book, &c.
(though I know no ungainsayable book but the
bible ;) which book, I think, no man that has
read it will give such a title to but the author.
He speaks of my reproaching his public sermons;
of which I am not conscious to myself, unless it
be about his interpretation of a thunder storm
(that broke into his house) which savoured so
much of enthusiasm.
As to those papers, I have (as I read them)
lioted in the margin wliere, in a hasty reading, I
thouo-ht it needful ; of which it were unreasona-
ble for him to complain, seeing 1 might not take a
copy, thereby to have been enabled more at lei-
sure to digest what were needful to be said on so
manv heads: and as I have not flattered him,
MR. MATHER, &c. 77
so, for telling what was so needfu], with the
hazard of making so many enemies by it, I have
approved myself one of his best friends. And
besides his own sense of the weakness of his an-
swer, testified by the prohibition above, he has
wholly declined answering to most of those
things that 1 had his promise for; and what he
pretends to speak to, after mentioning, without
the needful answer or proof, drops it.
His first main work, after his definition of a
witch, which he never proves (without saying
any thing to mr. Gaule's scriptural description,
though so often urged to it, and though himself
has in his book recommended and quoted it) ig
to m.ignify thedeviPs power, and that as I think
beyond and against the scripture ; this takes hina
up about 1 1 pages ; and yet in page 22d he
again returns to it, and, as /understand it, takes
part with the pharisees against our Saviour in
the argument ; for they charge him that he
cast out devils through Beelzebub : our Saviour's
answer is, (Matt. xii. 25) Every kingdom divided
against itself is brought to desolation ; and every
city or house divided against itself shall not stand ;
and if sat an cast out satan, he is divided against
himself; how shall then his kingdom stand ?
Arid yet, notwithstanding this answer, together
with what follows, for further illustration our
author is it seems resolved to assert, that our
Saviour did not in this answer deny that many
did so, viz. cast out devils by Beelzebub; and,
page 23, grants that the devils have a miracu-
lous power, but yet it must not be called mira-
culous, and yet can be distinguished, as he inti-
76 LETTERS TO
mates, only by the conscience or light within, to
the no small scandal of the christian religion :
though our Saviour and his apostles account this
the chief or principal proof of his godhead, (John
XX. 30, 31. John x. 37, 38. John v. 30. ^^Jark xvi.
17, 18. j^cts]u22, and iv. 30. with many others)
and that miracles belong only to God, who also
governs the world, (Ps, cxxxvi. 4. Jer, xiv. 22.
Isa, xxxviii. 8. Ps, Ixii. 11. Lam, iii. 37. Amos iii,
6.) But, to forbear quoting that which the scrip-
ture is most full in, do only say, that he that-
dares assert the devil to have such a miraculous
power, had need have other scriptures than
ever I have seen.
In page 12, our author proceeds, and states a
question to this effect: If the devH has such
powers, and cannot exert them without permis-
sion from God, what can the witch contribute
thereunto? Instead of an answer to this vreighty
objection, our author first concedes, that the
devils do ordinarily exert their powers, without
the witches contributing to it; but yet, that, to
the end to increase their guilt, he may cheat a
witch, by making her believe herself the author
of them. His next is, If witchcraft be, as I sup-
pose it is, the skill of applying the plastic spirit
of the world, <S*c. then the consent of the witch
doth naturally contribute to that mischief that
the devil does. And his last answer runs to this
effect : Is it not the ordination of God, that
where the devil can get the consent of a witch
for the hurting of others, the hurt shall as cer-
tainly be as if they had set mastiff dogs upon
them, ©r had given them poison into their bow*
MR. MATHER, kc. 79
els? and God's providence must be as great in
delivering i'rom one as Iroin the other. And this
it seems is not only his belief, but the most or-
thodox and the most learned answer that our
author could pitch upon: If* witchcralt be, as I
suppose it is, &c. and is it not the ordination of
God, that, (fec^ What is all this but precarious,
and begging the question, and a plain dropping
the argument he cannot manage? Howevei*, to
amuse the ignorant, and to confound the learned,
he hooks in a cramp word, if not a nonentity, viz.
plastic spirit of the world; for who is it either
knows that there is a plastic spirit, or what it is,
or how this can any way serve his purpose?
He then proceeds to scripture instances of
witches, &c. and where I thought it needful, I
have, as I said, shewed my dissent from his judg-
ment. He accounts it unreasonable to be held
to the proof of his definition of a witch, which
he makes to consist in a covenant with the devil ;
and chooses rather a tedious process about a pis-
tol to defend him from it, which indeed is one
particular way whereby murder has been com-
mitted, and so the doer becomes culpable. But
his definition of a witch, which, as I said, still
remains to be proved, is to this effect : that a
"witch is one that covenants with and commissions
devils to do mischiefs; that she is one in cove-
nant, or that by virtue of such covenant she can
commission him to kill. The not bringing scri|>
ture to prove these two is a sufficient demonstra-
tion there is none ; and so our author leaves off
just where he began, viz. in a bare assertion, to-
gether with his own bigoted experiences, hinting'
30 • LETTERS TO
also at multitudes of histories to confirm him in
the belief of his definition. Here being all that
I take notice of to be considerable.
And now, sir, if you think fit, improve your
friendship with tiie author, for the glory of Gud,
the sovereign being, the good and welfare of
mankind, and for his real and true interest. As
you see it convenient, put him in mind, that the
glory of God is the end why mankind was made,
and^vhy he hath so many advantages to it : tliat
the flames we have seen, threatening the utter
extirpation of the country, must owe their origi-
nal to these dangerous errors (if not heresies)
which, if they remain unextinguished, may and
most hkely will be acted over again: that it is
more honour to own an error in time, than tena-
ciously after full conviction to retain it. But if
our author will again vindicate such matters,
please to acquaint him, that 1 shall not any mure
receive his papers, if I may not copy and use
them; and that when he does, instead of such
abstruse matters, 1 still pray his determination
in those things I have his promise for. And
thus begging pardon for thus long detaining you,
I am, sir, yours to command, R. C
Boston, March IB, 1694.
To the Ministers^ whether English, French or
Dutch,
I, havins: had not only occasion, but renewed
provocation, to take a view ot the mysterious
doctrines which have of late been so much con-
tested among us, could not meet with any that
had spoken more, or more plainly, the sense
MR. MATHER, &c. H
of those doctrines (relating to witchcraft) than
the rev* inr. C. M. ; but how clearly and con-
sistent, either with himself or the trutli, 1
need not now saj, but cannot but suppose his
strenuous and zealous asserting his opinions
has been one cause of the dismal convul-
sions we have here lately fallen into* Suppo-
sing that his books of Memorable Providences
relating to Witchcraft^ as also his Wonders of
the Invisible World, did contain in them things
not warrantable, and very dangerous, I sent to
him a letter of quotations out of those books, &c.
that so, if it might have been, I might under-
stand what tolerable sense he would put upon
his own words ; which 1 took to be a better way
of proceeding, than to have affixed what I
thought to be their natural consequences ; and,
lest I might be judged a sceptic, I gave him a
full and free account of my belief relating to
those doctrines, together with the grounds there-
of; and prayed him, that if I erred I might be
shewed it by scripture ; and this I had his rei-
terated promise for. But after more than a
year's waiting for the performance thereof, all
that is done in compliance therewith is, that in
^February last he sent me four sheets of his wri-
ting, as his belief; but before I might receive it
I must engage to deliver- it back in a fortnight,
and not copied. A summary account of which
I shall give you, when I have first acquainted
you Avhat the doctrines were which I sent to
him for his concurrence with, or confutation of,
and to which 1 had his promise, as above.
These by way of question, viz. Whether that
8^ LETTERS Tl)
fourth head, cited and recommended by him-
self (in Wonders of the invisible World) ol" mr*
Gaule, ought to be behoved as a truth ; which
runs thus : " Among the most unhappy circum-
stances to convict a witch, one is a maligning
and oppugning the word, work and worship
of God, and seeking by an extraordinary sign
to seduce any from it. Dent xiii. 1, 2. Matt.
xxiv. 24. Jets xiii. 8, 10. 2 Tm. iii, 8, Do but
mark well the places ; and for this very pro-
perty of thus opposing and perverting, they are
all there concluded arrant and absolute witches."
And if in witchcraft the devil by means of a
witch does the mischief, how is it possible to
distinguish it from possession ? both being said
to be performed by the devil ; and yet, without
an infallible distinction, there can be no certain-
ty in judgment. And whether it can be proved
that the Jewish church, in any age before, or in
our Saviour's time, even in the time of their
greatest apostacy, did bcheve that a witch had
power to commission devils to do mischief?
So much to the questions. These were sent
as m} belief: That the devil's bounds are set,
that he cannot pass ; that the devils are so full
of malice, that it cannot be added to by mankind ;
that where he hath power, he neither can nor
will omit executing it ; that it is only the Al-
mighty that sets bounds to his rage, and that
only can commission him to hurt or destroy.
And now I shall give you the summary account
of his four sheets above mentioned, as near as
memory could recollect, in ten particulars.
1. That the devils have in their natures a
MR. MATHER, kc. H3
power to work wonders and miracles ; particu-
larly that the pharisces were not mistaken in
assertin«j that the devils might be cast out by
Beelzebub ; and that our Saviour's answer docs
not oppose that assertion ; and that he hath the
power of death; that he can make the most so-
lid things invisible, and can invisibly bring poison,
and force it down people's throats.
2. That to assert this natural, wonderful powd-
er of the devil, makes most for the glory of God,
in preserving man from its effects.
3. Yet this power is restrained by the Al-
mighty, as pleaseth him.
4. That a witch is one that makes a covenant
with the devil.
5. That by virtue of such a covenant, she ar-
rives at a power id commission him.
6. That God has ordained that when the de-
vil is called upon by the witch, though he w^ere
before restrained by the Almighty, the desired
mischiefs ordinarily shall as certainly be perform-
ed, as if the witch had lodged poison in the bow-
els of her neighbour, or had set mastiff dogs on
them.
8. That that God which restrained an Abi-
melech and a Laban from hurting, does also re-
strain the witch from calling upon or improving
the devil, when he will not have his power so
exerted.
9. That to have a familiar spirit, is to be able
to cause a devil to take bodily shapes, whereby
either to give responses, or to receive orders lor
doing mischief.
10. That this is the judgment of most of the
84 LETTERS TO
divines in the countri', whether Enghsh, Dutch,
or French.
This, as I said, I took to be the most materi-
al in the four sheets sent to me as his behef,
and is also all the performance he has yet made
of his several promises ; which ten articles being
done only by memory, lest through mistake or
want of the original I might have committed any
errors, I sent them to him, that, if there were
any, they might be rectified : but instead of such
an answer as might be expected from a minister
aiid a learned gentleman, one mr. W. shewed
me a letter writ by mr. C. M. to himself, which
I might read, but neither borrow nor copy, and
so, if 1 were minded, could give but a short ac-
count of it.
And passing over his hard lans^uage, which,
as I am conscious to myse'f I never deserved,
(relating to my writing in the margin of the four
sheets, and to these ten articles) so 1 hope I un-
derstand my di;ty better than to imitate him in
retorting the like. Among his many words in
his said letters, I meet with two small objections ;
one is against the word miracle in the first aiti-
tle; the word, I say, not the matter; for the
works he attributes to the devil arc the same,
in their being above or against the course of na-
ture and all natural causes; yet he will not ad-
mit of these to be called miracles; and hence
he reckons it the greatest difficulty lie meets
with in this whole affair, todistirguish the works
of the devil from miracles. And hence also he
concedes to tlie devil the power to make the
«iQSt solid things invisible^, and mvtsibly to bring
MR. MATHER, kc. 8i.
poison, and force it down people's throats, (fee.
Which I look upon to be as true miracles as
that 2 Kings, vi. IB ; and this is the sense I un-
derstand the word in ; and in this sense he him-
sell", in the tour sheets, admits it ; lor he has an
objection to this effect, viz. If the devils have
such power, &c. tiien miracles are not ceased ;
and where are we then? His answer is. Where !
Even just where we were before, say I : so that
it seems the only offence here is at my using
his words. His second objection (for weii^ht)
is against the whole ninth article, and wonders
how it is possible for one man so much to mis-
understand another ; yet, as I remember, he,
speaking of the witch of Endor, in the said four
sheets, says, she had a familiar spirit, and that a
spirit belonging to the invisible world, upon her
calling, appeared to Saul, &c. and if so, it is cer-
tain he gave responses. He also tells of Bala-
am, that it was known that he could set devils
on people to destroy them ; and therefore how
this objection should bear any force I see not.
The rest of the objections are of so small
weight, that once reading may be sufficient to
clear them up; and if this be not so, he can,
when he pleases, by making it publick, together
with the margins I writ, convince all people of
the truth of what he asserts. But here it is to
be noted, that the 2d, 3d, 4th and 5th articles
he concedes to, as having nothing to object
against them, but that they are his belief; and
that the 6th and 7th he puts for answer to an
objection which he thus frames, viz. If the de-
vil have such powers, but cannot exert them
8
86 LETTERS TO
but by permission from God, what can the witch
contribute thereto ?
And thus I have faithfully performed what I
undertook; and do solemnly declare, I have not
intentionally in the least wronged the gentleman
concerned, nor designed the least blemish to liis
reputation; but if it stands in competition with
the glory of God, the only almighty being, his
truths and his people's welfare, 1 suppose these
too valuable to be trampled on for his sake,
though in other things I am ready to my power
(though with denying some part of my own in-
terest) to serve him. Had this gentleman de-
clined or detracted his four sheets, I see not
but he might have done it, and wdiich I think
there was cause enough for him to have done;
but to own the four sheets, and at the same
time to disown the doctrine contained in them,
and this knowing that I have no copy, renders
the whole of the worse aspect.
And now I shall give you a further account
of my belief, when I have first premised, that
it is a prevailing belief in this country, and else-
where, that the scriptures are not full in the
description of, and in the way and means how
to detect, a witch, though positive in their pu-
nishment to be by death ; and that hence they
have thought themselves under a necessity of
taking up with the sentiments of such men or
places that are thought worthy to give rules to
detect them by; and have accordingly practis-
ed; viz. in searching for teats for the devil to
suck ; trying whether the suspected cnn say the
Lord's prayer ; and whether the aitiictt^d falls
MR. IMATHER, kc. 87
at the slglif, and rises at the touch, of tlie sup-
posed witch ; as also by the afflicted or posses-
sed giving account who is the witch.
Touching these, rnj behei* is, that 'tis highly
derogatory to the wisdom of the wise Lawgiv-
er, to assert, that he has given a hiw by Moses,
the penalty whereof is death, and yet no direc-
tion to his people, whereby to know and detect
the culpable, till our triumvirate, messrs. Per-
kins, Gaule and Bernard, had given us their re-
ceipts; and, that that fourth head of mr. Gaule,
being so well proved by sciipture, is a truth,
and contains a full and clear testmiony who are
Avitches culpable of death, and that plainly and
from scripture, yet not excluding any other
branch, when as well proved by that infallible
rule ; and, that the going to the afflicted or pos-
sessed, to have them divine who are witches by
their spectral sight, is a great wickedness, even
the sin of Saul (for which he also died) but with
this difference, the one did it for augury, or to
know future events ; the other, in order to take
away life ; and, that the searching for teats,
the experiment of their saying the Lord's pray-
er, the falling at the sight and rising at the
touch of the supposed criminal, being all of them
foreign from scripture, as well as reason, are
abominations to be abhorred and repented of;
and, that our Salem witchcraft, either respect-
ing the judges and juries, their tenderness of
life, or the multitude and pertinency of w^itness-
es, both afflicted and confessors, or the integrity
of the historians, is as authentic, and made as
certain, as any event of that kind in the world.
iid LETTERS TO
And yet who is it that now sees not through it,
and that these were the sentiments that have
procured the sorest affliction, and most lasting
infamy, that ever bel'el this country, and most
like so to do again, if the same notions be still
entertained? and, finally, that these are those
last times, of which the Spirit speaks expressly,
Tim, iv. 1 ?
And now, ye that are fathers in the church-
es, guides to the people, and the salt of
the earth, I beseech you consider these things;
and if you find the glory of God diminished by
ascribing such power to witches and devils ; his
truths opposed by these notions ; and his people
aspersed in their doctrines and reputations, and
endangered in their lives — I dare not dictate
you — you know your duty as watchmen — and
the Lord be with you.
But if you find my belief contrary to sound
doctrine, I entreat you to shew it me by the
scripture ; and in the mean time blame me not if
I cannot believe that there are several Almigh-
ties ; for to do all sorts of w^onders, beyond and
above the course of nature, is certainly the work
of Omnipotency. So also, he that shall com-
mission or empower to these, must also be al-
mighty ; and I think it not a sufficient salvo, to
say they may be restrained by the Most High ;
and hope you will not put any hard construction
on these my endeavours to get information (all
other ways failing) in things so needful to be
known. Praying the Almighty's guidance and
protection, 1 am
Yours to the utmost of my power,
R. C,
MR. MATHER, &c. 89
Boston, Sept. the 20th, 1695.
Mr. Samuel Willard,
Rcvci^end Sir,
My lormcr, of Marcli the 18th, directed to
tlie Ministers (and which was lodged with your-
self) containing several articles which I sent as
my behef, praying them if I erred to shew it me
by scripture, I have as yet had no answer to, ei-
ther by word or writing, which makes mc ga-
ther that they are approved of as orthodox, or
at least that they have such foundations as that
none are wilhng to manifest any opposition to
them ; and therefore, with submission, &c. I
think tiiat that late seasonable and well-design- '
ed dialogue, intituled, Sojne Miscellaneous Ob-
servations, &c. of which yourself is the supposed
author, and which was so serviceable in the
time of it, is yet liable to a mal-construction,
ev^en to the danger of reviving what it most op-
poses, and ol' bringing tiiose practices again on
foot, which in tlie day of them were so terrible
to this whole country. The words, which I
suppose so liable to Qjisconstruction, are, p. 14,
B. Who informed them.?- S. The spectre, B. Verif
good, and thafs the devil turned informer. How
an good men like to fare, against whom he hath
particular malice ? It is but a prssumption, and.
wise men will weigh presumptions against presump-
tions. There is to be no examination without
grounds of suspicion. Some perjons credit nothimr
to be accounted too good to be undermined so far
as to be suspected on so slight a ground ; and it is
an injury done them to bring them upoi examina-
tion, ivhich renders them openlq suspected. I will
9« LETTERS TO
tiot deny but for persons already suspected, and of'
ill fame, it may occasion their being examined*
In which, these words, ^tis hut a presumption, &;c.
and some persons credit, &c. and I ivill not deny
but for persons already suspected, &c. I take to
be waving the discussion oi" those points, the
speaking to which might at that tirne have hin-
dered the usefulness and success of that book,
rather than any declaring the sentiments of the
author. But notwithstanding, many persons will
be ready to undersf:ind this as if the author did
wholly leave it witli the justice, to jud,^e wlio
are ill persons, sucli as the devil's accusations
may fasten upon; and that tiie devil's accusation
of a person is a presumption against them of
their guilt ; and tliat, upon such presumptions,
they may be had to examinatic.n, if the justjce
counts them persons of ill fame; for the author
I suppose knows that the bare examuiation will
leave such a stain upon them (aiid it would be
well if their posterity escaped it!) as the length
of a holy and unblamable life will be found too
short to extirpate. And if the justice may go thus
far with the devil's evidence, then the addition
of a story or two of some cart cverset, or per-
sons taken sick after a quarrel, might as w ell be
thought sufficient for their commitment, in order
to tlieir trial, as 'tis called, (though this too of-
ten has been more like a stage play, or a tragi-
comic scene^ and so that other ways useful book
mav prove the greatest snare to revive the same
practices again.
These things being so liable, as I said, to such
nial-coiistruction, it were needful that men might
MR. MATHEK, kc. 91
he undeceived, and the matter more fully de-
monstrated, viz. That tlie devil's accusation is
not so much as any presumption against the life
or reputation of any person ; (for how are good
men like to fare, if his malicious accusations may-
be taken as a presumption of their guilt ?) and,
that his accusations, as they are no presumption
agamst persons of unspotted fame, so neither
are to be heard, or any ways regarded, against
persons though otherways of ill life, much less
for their having long since had their names abu-
sed by his outcries, or by the malice of ill neigh-
bours ; and, that justice knows no dilference of
persons ; that, if this evidence be sufficient to
bring one person, 'tis so to bring any otlier, to
examination, and consequently to the utmost ex-
tent of odium which such examination will cer-
tainly expose them to; for who can know any
other, but that as the one may be maliciously
accused by devils and a devilish report gone be-
fore it, so that another, who has not been so
much as accused before, being more cunning or
more seeming religious, might yet be more guil-
ty ; the whole depending upon invisible evi-
dence, of which iii visible stuuj though we have
iiad more than sudlclent, yet I find (among other
reverend persons) your name to a certain print-
ed paper, which runs thus ;
Certain Proposals^ made by the President and Fellows of
llarjard CoUege to the reverend Alinuttrs of the Gospel^
in the several churches of jYew- England.
Fir.'it. To observe aiui record the more illustrious
discoveries of the Divine Providence in tiie government
^fthe world, is a design so holy, so useful, so justly ajN
02 LETTERS TO
proved, that the too general neglect of it in the churches
of God is as justly to be lamented.
2. For the redress of that neglect, although all christi-
ans have a duty incunibent on them, yet it is in a peculiar
manner to be recommended unto the Ministers of the gos-
pel to improve the special advantages which are in their
hands, to obtain and preserve the knowledge of such no-
table occurrences as are sought out by all that have
pleasure in the great works of the Lord.
3. The things to be esteemed memorable, are specially
all unusual accidents in the heaven, or earth, or water;
ail wonderful deliverances of the distressed ; mercies to
the ^odly ; judgments on the wicked ; and more glorious
fulfilments of either the pi-omises or threatenings in the
scriptures of truth ; with apparitions, possessions, enchant-
ments, and all extraordmary things, where:n the existence
and agency of the Invisible World is more sensibly <lc-
monstrated.
4. It is therefore proposed, that the Ministers through-
out this land would manifest their pious regards unto the
works of the Lord, and the operation of his hands, by
reviving their cares to take written accounts of such Re-
markables ; but still well attested with credible and suf-
ficient witnesses.
5. It is desired that the accounts, thus taken, of these
remarkables, may be sent to the President or Fellows of
th. college, by whom they shall be carefully reserved for
such a use to be made of them, as may by some tit assem-
bly of Ministers be judged most conducing to the glory
of God, and the service of his people.
6. Though we doul^t not that love to the name of God
will be a sufficient motive to all good men lo contribute
what assistance they can unto this undertaking; yet, for
further encouragement, some singular marks of respect
shall be studied for sr.ch good men, as will actually assist
it, by takins* pains to communicate any important passa-
ges proper to be inserted in this collection.
Increase Mather, Pros,
James Allen^
Char. JMortGii^
Sam. Willard.,
Cotton Mather^
John Lever die^
Will Brattle,
Keh. Walter,
Fe!lo',vs.
-enmbrldge, ^larch 5, 1694.
MR. MATHER, &i^. 93
Here being an encouragement to all good
men to send in such remarkables as are tlierein
expressed, I have sent in the following ; not
that I think them a more sensible demonstra-
tion of the being of a future state (with rewards
and punishments) or of angels good and bad, &c.
than the scriptures of truth hold forth, &c. ; or
than any of those other demonstrations God hath
given us ; for this were treacherously and per-
fidiously to quit the post to the enemy. The
sadducee, deist and atheist would hereby be
put in a condition so triumphantly to deny the
existence and agency thereof, as that a few sto-
ries told (which at best must be owned to be
fallible and liable to misrepresentations) could
not be thought infallibly sufficient to demonstrate
the truth against them. I have heard that in lo-
gick a false argument is reckoned much worse than
none; yet, supposing that a collection of instan-
ces may be many ways usei'ul, not only to the
present but succeeding ages, I have sent you the
following remarkables, which have lately occur-
red, the certainty of which, if any scruple it, will
be found no hard matter to get satisfaction there-
in. But here, not to insist on those less occur-
rences, as the sudden death of one of our late
justices; and a like mortality that fell upon the
two sons of another of them; with the fall of a
man that was making provision to raise the new
northern bell, which, when it was up, the first
person, whose death it was to signify, was said
to be a child of him, who, by printing and speak-
ing, had had as great a hand in procuring the
late actions as any, if not the greatest; and the
94 LETTERS TO
spllltino^ the gun at Salem, \vhere that furious
marshal, and his lather, &c. were rent to pieces,
&:c. As to all these, it m<ist be owned, that no
man knows love or hatred by all that is before
him, much less can thej be more sensible de-
monstrations of the existence and agency of the
invisible world, than the scriptures of truth afford,
&c. though the rich man in the parable might
think otherwise, &c. who was seeking to send
some more sensible demonstrations thereof to
his brethren, &c. In that tremendous judgment
cf God upon this country, by the late amazing
prosecution of the people here, under the no-
tion of witches; whereby twenty suffered as
evil doers, (besides those that died in prison)
about ten more condemned, and a hundred im-
prisoned, and about two hundred more accused,
and the country generally in fears when it would
come to their turn to be accused ; and the pros-
ecution and manner of trial such, that most
w^ould have chosen to have fallen into the hands
of the barbarous enemy, rather than (under
that notion) into the hands of their brethren in
church fellowship; and, in short, was such an
affliction as far exceeded all that ever this coun-
try hath laboured under —
Yet .in this mount God is seen. When it was
thus bad with this distressed people, a full and
a sudden stop is put, not only without, but
against, the inclination of many; for out of the
eater came forth meat : those very accusers,
which had been improved as witnesses against
so many, by the providence of the Most High,
and perhaps blinded with malice, are left to ae-
MR. MATTFR, &c. 95
cuse those in most high esteem, both macjis-
trates and ministers, as guilty ol* witchcrait ;
which shewed our rulers, that necessity lay up-
on them to conl'ound that v\ hicii had so long con-
founded the countiy, as being themselves unwil-
ling to run the same risk : this, that wns in the
event of it, to this country, as life from the dead,
is most easy w ith Hnn, in whose hands are the
hearts of all men, and was a very signal delive-
rance to this whole country. No less observa-
ble was it, tliat though at the time when the
devil's testimony, by the afflicted, was first laid
aside, there were great numbers of (real or pre-
tended) afflicted ; yet w hen this was once not judg-
ed of validity enough to be any longer brought
into the court against tlie accused as ca ideixe,
the affliction generally ceased, and only some
remainders of it in such places, where more en-
couragement was given to the actors, God seem-
ing thereby plainly to decipher that sin of go-
ing to the devil, &c. as the rise and foundation
of those punishments.
And thus, reverend, 1 have, as I understand if,
performed my duty herein, for the glory of
God, and the well-being of men. And for my
freedom used in this and former writinp^s, rela-
ting to the actors in this tragedy, I shall not
apologize, but give you the words oi" one to
whom some can aiford the title of venerable
(when he is arguing for that which they have
undertaken to assert, thougli at other times more
diminutive epithets must serve) ; it is the rever-
end mr. R. Baxter, in hjs book, the Cure of
Church Divisions, pages 257, 258. "But [I
96 LETTERS TO
pray you mark it] the way of God is to shame
the sinner, how good soever in other respects,
that the sin may have the greater shame, and
rehgion may not be ashamed, as if it allowed
men to sin: nor God, the author of rehgion, be
dislionoured ; nor others be without the warning :
but the way of the devil is, to hide or justiiy the
sin, as if it were for fear of disparaging the
goodness of the persons that committed it ; that
so he may hereby dishonour rehgion and godh-
ness itself, and make men believe it is but a
cover for any wickedness, and as consistent with
it as a looser life is, and that he may keep the
sinner from repenting, and blot out the memo-
ry of that warning which should have preserved
after ages from the like falls. Scripture sham-
eth the professors (though a David, a Solomon,
Peter, JVoah^ or Lot) that the religion profest
may not be ashamed, but vindicated. Satan
would preserve the honour of professors, that
the religion professed may bear the shame ; and
so it may fall on God himself."
And now that all that have had a hand in
any horrid and bloody practices may be brought
to give glory to God, and take the due shame
to themselves; and that our watchmen may no
longer seek to palliate, (much less give thanks
for such, d:c. thereby making them their own)
and that the people may no longer perish for
want of knowledge in the midst of such means
of light, nor God be any longer dishonoured by
false sentiments in these matters, is the earnest
desire and prayer of, sir. yours to my power,
MR. MATHER, &c .^7
Mr. Cotton Mather,
Reverend Sir^
Having long since sent you some doctrinals
as to my belief, together with my request to
you, that if I erred you Avould be pleased to
shew it me by scripture, viz. That the devil's
bounds are set, which he cannot pass; that the
devils are so full of malice that it cannot be ad-
ded to by mankind ; that where he hath poAver
he neither can nor will omit executing it; that
'tis only the Almighty that sets bounds to his
rage, and that only can commission him to hurt
and destroy, &;c. But instead of such an an-
swer as was promised and justly expected, you
were pleased to send me a book, which you
since called an ungainsayable one; which book,
till lately I have not had opportunity so fully to
consider. And to the end you may see 1 have
now done it, I have sent to you some of the re-
markables contained in the said book, intituled,
" The Certainty of the World of Spirits^'* written
by Mr, R. B. London^ printed 1691. It is
tlierein conceded (preface) that to see devils
and spirits ordinarily would not be enough to
convince atheists. Page 88, Atheists are not
to be convinced by stories; their own senses are
not enough to convince them any more than
sense will convince a papist from transubstantia-
tion. (Z). Laderd.) P. 4, No spirit can do any
thing but by God's will and permission. Pre-
face, 'Tis the free will of man that gives the
devils their hurting power; and without our
own consent they cannot hurt us. It is asserted,
p. 222, 223, That it is a perverse opposition of
9
93 LETTERS TO
poperj which causes many protcstants not Co
regard the benefits we receive by angels. And
ministers are faulty, that do not pray and give
thanks to God lor their ministry ; and that ne-
glect to teach believers, v,hat love and what
thanks thej- owe to angels. P. 225, Most good
people look so much to God and to ministers^
that they take little notice of angels, which are
God's great ministers. P. 234, The author
dares not, as some have done, judge the catho-
lic church to become antichristian idolaters, as
soon ^s they gave too mucli worship to saints
and angels. P. 7, The blessed souls shall be like
the angels, therefore may appear here. P. 3, 4,
'Tis hard to know whether it be a devil or a
human soul that appears, or whether the soul of
a good or a bad person; p, 61, or the soul of
some dead fiiend tliat suifers, and yet retains
love, kc. P. 222, No doubt the souls of the
Avicked carry with them their former inclina-
tions of covetousness, revenge, &c. P. 7, When
revengeful things are done, as on murderers,
de fraud ers, &c. it seems to be from the revenge-
ful wrath of some bad soul ; if it be about money
or lands, then from a worldly-minded one; some
significations of God's mercy to wicked souls
after this life. P. 4, 'Tis a doubt whether, be-
sides the angels (good and bad) and the souls of
men, there is not a third sort, called fairies and
goblins. It is unsearchable to us liow far God
leaves spirits to free will in small things, suspend-
ing his predetermining motion. P. 246, The
devils have a marvellous power, if but a silly
wretched witch consent. P. 10, 202, TItc sto-
MR. MATIIKR, &c. 99
ties of witches and spirits arc many ways useful,
particularly to convince atheists, and confirm
believers, and to prove the operation of spirits.
P. 232, To help men to understand tliat devils
make no small number of laws, and rulers in the
world, and are authors of most of the wars, and
of many sermons, and of books that adorn the
libraries of learned men. P. 6, 102, The devil's
lying with the witch is not to be denied, and is
more to exercise the lust of the witch than
of the devil, who can also bring in anothei*
witch without opening the door, and so perform
it by one witch with another. P. 105, Witches
can raise storms, sell winds, &c. as is commonly
affirmed. P. 107, In America it is a common
thing to see spirits, day and night. P. 95,
96, 97, 110, Stories of a child that could not
be cured of witchcraft, because the ember-
weeks were past ; vomited a knife a span long,
cart nails, &c. and neither eat nor drank, fifteen
days and nights together; a long piece of wood,
four knives, and two sharp pieces of iron, everv
one above a span long, taken out of the sto-
mach, ike. hair, stones, bones, vomited, <kc. a
thousand pounds of blood lost by one person in
a year's time. P. 250, A story that makes the
author think it possible that such great things,
as he mentions, should be gotten down and up peo-
ple's throats. P. I6i, Partial credibility spoils
many a good story. R 125, The devil's sub-
stance enters into the possessed. P. 174, Dis-
tracted are possessed. P. 149, A sick woman,
while she lay in bed, went to see her children.
P. 15:^, A dog appeared like a fly or a fleas
aOO LETTERS TG
P. 165, Some knowing agents direct thunder
storms, though the author knows not who ; and
that they so often fall on churches, he knows
not why. P. 2, 80, Mr. I. M. and mr. C. M.
recommended, together with Bodin, ^^c. P. 237,
A.crispian, if through ignorance he beheves not
what he saith, may be a christian.
In this, sir, I suppose that if 1 have not wrong-
ed the sense of the author in the places quoted
(which I trust you shall not find I have done) I
cannot be thought accountable for the errors or
contradictions to himself or to the truth, if any
such be found, particularly what he grants in the
Ere face, of the free will of man giving the devil
is hurting power ; this being not only more
than those called witch-advocates would desire
to be conceded to them, but is a palpable and
manifest overturning the author's design in all
his witch stories ; (for who would consent to
have the devil afflict himself?) as also his con-
cession, that no spirit can do any thing but by
God's will and permission; I cannot persuade
myself but you must be sensible of their appa-
rent contradictoriness to the rest. Others there
are of a very ill aspect ; as, p. 234, the catho-
licks are much encouraged in their adoration
of angels and saints, if that were so innocent as
not to render them antichristian Idolaters; and
that, p. 4, if admitted, will seem to lay an un-
gainsayable foundation for the pagan, Indian
and diabollst's faith, by telling us it is beyond
our search to know how far God leaves the de-
vils to free will, to do what they please, in this
world, with a suspension of God's predetermina-
MR. MATHER, &,c. 101
tion ; which if it were a truth, what were more
rational than to obhge him that has such power
over us ? The atheists also would take encou-
ragement if it were granted that we cannot know
how far God suspends his predetermining mo-
tion : they would thence affirm, we as little know
that there is a predetermining; motion, and con-
sequently whether there be a God, and p. 165
would abundantly strengthen them, when such
a learned, experienced and Iiighly-esteemed
christian shall own that he knows not who it is
that governs the thunder-storms : for it might
as well discover ignorance, who it is that dispo-
ses of earthquakes, gun-shot, and afflictions that
befal any, with the rest of mundane events.
I design not to remark all that in the book is re-
markable, such as the departed souls wandering
again hither to put men upon revenge, &;c. sa-
vouring so much of Pythagoras's transmigration
of souls, and the separation of the soul from the
body without death, as in the case of her that
went to see her children, while yet she did not
stir out of her bed, which seems to be a new
speculation ; unless it determines in favour of
transubstantiation, that a body may be at the
same time in several places. Upon the Avhole,
it is un^ainsavable, that that book, thouirh so
higiily extolled, may be justly expected to occa-
sion the staggering of the weak, and th^ har-
dening of unbelievers in their infidelity. And it
seems amazing, that you should not only give it
such a recommendation, but that you should send
it to me, in order (as I take it) to pervert me
from the belief of these fundamental doctrinals
9#
102 LETTERS TO
(above recited) though I account ihem tiiore
firm than heaven and earth. But that which is
yet more strange to me, is, that mr. B's friends
did not advise him better, than in his decHned
age to emit such crude matter to the pubhck.
As to the sometime reverend author, let his
works praise the remembrance of him ; but for
such as are either erroneous and foisted upon
him, or the effect of an aged imbecihtj, let them
be detected, that thej may proceed no further*
I am not ignorant that the manner of educa-
tion of youth, in, I think, almost all christian
schools, hath a natural tdndency to propagate
those doctrines of devils heretofore solely prc-
fest among ethnicks, and particularly in matters
of witchcraft, &c. For, notwithstanding the
council of Carthage, taking notice that the
christian doctors did converse much with the
writings of the heathens for the gaining of elo-
quence, forbad the reading of the books of the
gentiles ; yet it seems this was only a bill with-
out a penalty, which their successors did not
look upon to be binding. He that should In this
age take a view of the schools, might be induced
to believe that the ages since have thought,
that w^ithout such heathen learning a man can-
not be so accomplished, as to have any pretence
to academick literature ; and that the vulgar
might not be without the benetit of such iearPi-
ing, some of their disciples have taught them to
speak english, w^hich has given me the opportu-
nity to send you these following verse?.
Virg. Bucolicks — Ed. 13.
Sure love k not the cause their bones appear j.
Some eyes bewitch mv teodfr Jamb?!. I fear
MR. MATHER, kc. 103
Ed. 8.
For me these herbs in Pontu^, Maeris chose ,*
There evVy powerful drug in plenty grows;.
Transformed to a wolf 1 often MaRris saw,
Then into shady woods himself withdraw :
Olt he from deepest sepulchres would charm
Departed souls ; and from another's farm,
Into his own ground, corn yet standing take.
Now from the town my charms bring Daphnis back.
V'anquish'd with charms, from heaven the moon descends,
Circe with charms transform''d Ulysses' friends;
Charms in the tield will burst a poisonous snake.
Now from the town, &c.
OviWs Metam. Lib. 7.
Her arms thrice turns about, thrice wets her crown
With gather'd dew, thrice yawns, and kneeling down;.
Oh night ! thou friend to secrets! you, clear tires,
That with the moon succeed when day retires ;
Great Hecate thou know'st, and aid imparts,
To our design, your charms and magick arts :
And thou, oh earth, that to magicians yields
Thy powerful simples ; air, winds, mountains, fields,
Soft murmuring springs, still lakes, and rivers clear.
Ye gods of woods, ye gods of night, appear ;
By you, at will, I make swift streams retire
To their first fountam, while their banks admire ;
Seas rough make smooth ; clear skies with clouds deform ;
Storms turn to calms, and make a calm a storm.
With spells and charms, 1 break the viper's jaw,
Cleave solid rock*;, oaks from their fissures draw ;
Whole woods remove, the airy mountains shake;
Earth force to groan, and ghosts from graves awake..
Lib. 14.
her journey takes
To Rhegium, opposite to Zante's shore,
And treads the troubled waves, that loudly roar;
Running with unwet feet on that profound,
As if sh' had trod upon the solid ground.
This with portentous poison she pollutes.
Besprinkled with the juice of wicked roots ;
In words dark and perplexed, nine times thrice.
Enchantments utters with her wicked voice. Stc.
104 LETTERS TO
These fables of the heathens (though in
themselves of no more validity than the idle
tales of an indian, or the discourses of a known
romancer) are become the school-learning, not
to say the faith, of christians, and are the scrip-
tures brought (instead of that most sure word)
if not to prove doctrine, yet as illustrations
thereof. Cases of Conscience concerning Witchc,
page 25 ; Remarkable Providences^ page 250.
This perhaps might be the cause that in Eng-
land, a people othf rwise sober and religious, have
for some ages in a manner wholly refused admit-
ting those not so educated to the work of the
ministry. Such education and practice have so
far prevailed, that it has been a means of cor-
rupting the christian world, almost to that de-
gree as to be ungainsayable ; for though there
is reason to hope that these diabolical principles
have not so prevailed (with multitudes of chris-
tians) as that they ascribe to a witch and a devil
the attributes peculiar to the Almighty ; yet
how few are willing to be found opposing such
a torrent, as knowing that in so doing they shall
be sure to meet with opposition to the utmost,
from the many, both of magistrates, ministers
and people ; and the name of sadducee, atlieist,
and perhaps witch too, cast upon them most li-
berally, by men of the highest profession in god«
liness; and if not so learned as some of them-
selves, then accounted only fit to be trampled
on, and their arguments (though both rational
and scriptural) as fit only for contempt. But
though this be the deplorable dilemma, yet
some have dared I'rcm time to time (for the glo-
MR. MATHER, &g. 105
ry of God, and the ^ood and safety of men's
lives, &c.) to run all these risks. And that God
who has said. My glory I will not give to another^
is able to protect those that are found doing
their duty herein against ail opposers ; and,
however otherways contemptible, can make
them useful in his own hand, who has sometimes
chosen the weakest instruments, that his power
may be the more illustrious.
And now, reverend sir, if you are conscious
to yourself, that you have, in your principles or
practices, been abetting to such grand errors, I
cannot see how it can consist with sincerity, to
be so convinced in matters so nearly relating to
the glory of God, and lives of innocents, and at
the same time so much to fear disparagement
among men, as to trifle with conscience, and dis-
semble an approving of former sentiments. You
know that word. He that honoureth me I will ho-
nour^ and he that despiseth me shall be lightly
esteemed. But if you think that in these matters
you have done your duty, and taught the peo-
ple theirs ; and that the doctrines cited from
the above mentioned book are ungainsayable ;
I shall conclude in almost his words, He that
teaches such doctrine, if through ignorance he
believes not wiiat he saith, may be a christian ;
but if he believes them, he is in the broad path
to heatlienism, devilism, popery, or atheism. It
is a solemn caution, (Gal. i. 8) But though ive^ or
an angel fiom heaven^ preach any other gospel un-
to you than that which we have preached unto you,
let him be accursed. I hope you will not miscon-
strue my intentions herein, who am, reverend
sir, yours to command in what I may, K, C,
i06 LETTERS TO
To the Ministers in and near Boston.
Jan. 12, 1696.
Christianity had been but a short time in the
world, when there was raised against it, not on-
ly open profest enemies, but secret and inbred
underminers, who sought thereby to effect that
which open force had been so often baffled in.
And notwithstanding that primitive purity and
sincerity, which in some good measure was still
retained, yet the cunning deceivers and apostate
hereticks found opportunity to beguile the un-
wary, and this in fundamentals.
Among others which then sprung up, with
but too much advantage, in the third century,
the maniche did spread his pestiferous senti-
ments, and taught the existence of two beings, or
causes of all things, viz. a good and a bad: but
these were soon silenced by the more orthodox
doctors, and anathematized by general councils.
And at this day the american indians, another
sort of maniche, entertaining (thus far) the same
belief, hold it their prudence and interest to
please that evil being, as well by perpetrating
other murders, as by their bloody sacrifices, that
so he may not harm them. The iron teeth of
time have now almost devoured the name of
the former; and as to the latter, it is to be ho-
ped that as Christianity prevails among them,
they WAX abhor such abominable belief
And as those primitive times were not privil-
eged against the spreading of dangerous heresy,
so neither can any now pretend to any such im-
munity, though professing the enjoyment of a
primitive purity.
MR. MATHER, kc. 107
Might a judgment be made from the books of
the modem learned divines, or from the [practice
of courts, or from the faith of many who call
tliemselves cliristians, it might be modestly,
though sadly, concluded, that the doctrine of the
maniche, at least great part of it, is so far from
being forgotten, that it is almost cvcrv where
prolest. We in these ends of the earth need
not seek far for instances in each respect to de-
monstrate this. The books here printed and
recommended, not only by the respective au-
thors, but by many of their brethren, do set forth
that the devil inflicts plagues,^ wars,t diseases,^
tempests,§ and can render the most solid things
invisible, II and can do things above and against
the course of nature, and all natural causes.
Are tliese the expressions of orthodox believ-
ers ? or are they not rather expressions becoming
a maniche, or a heathen, as agreeing far better
with these than with the sacred oracles, our
only rulf}? the whole current whereof is so dia-
metrically opposite thereto, that it were almost
endless to mention all the divine cautions against
such abominable belief; he that runs may read,
Ps, Ixii. 11, andcxxxvi. 4. Lam. ill. 37. .^?nos ill, 6.
Jer, iv. 22. Ps. Ixxvlii. 26, and clxviil. 6, 8. Job
xxxviii. 22 to 34.
These places, with a multitude more, do abun-
dantly testily, that the asserters of such power
to be in the evil being, do speak in a dialect
different from the scriptures, (laying a firm
* Wonders of the Invisible World p. 17, 18. tp. IS.
J Cases of Conscience, p. G3. § Remarkable Provi-
dences, p. 124. j] Wonders of the Invisible World, p.
141.
108 LETTERS TO
foundation for the Indians' adorations, which^
aojrees well with what A. Ross sets forth, in his
Mistag. Poetic, p. 116, that their ancients did
worship the furies and their god Averinci^ that
they might forbear to hurt them.)
And have not the courts in some parts of the
world, by their practices, testified their concur-
rence w^ith such belief; prosecuting to death
many people upon that notion, of their improv-
ing such power of the evil one, to the raising of
storms ; afflicting and killing of others, though
at great distance from them; doing things in
their own persons above human strength ; des-
troy i.'g cattle, flying in the air, turning themselves
into cats, dugs, <kc. ? which by the way must needs
imply something of goodness to be in that evil
being, who, though he has such power, would
nor exert it, were it not for this people, or else
that the\ can some way add to this mighty
power.
And are the people a whit behind in their
belief? Is there any thing above mentioned,
their strong faith looks upon to be too hard for
this evil being to etiect?
Here it will be answered, God permits it
Which answ^er is so I'ar an owning the doctrine,
that the devil lias in his nature a power to do
ail these things, and can exert this powxr, except
when he is restrained, that it is in effect to say
that God has made nature to fight against itself;
that he has made a creature, who has it in the
power of his nature to overthrow nature, and to
act above and against it. Which he that can
believe may as vvell believe the greatest contra-
MR. MATHER, kc. 109
diction. That being which can do this in the
smallest thing, can do it in the greatest. Il Mo-
ses, with a bare permission, might stretch fortli
his rod, yet he was not able to bring plagues
upon the Egyptians, or to divide the waters,
without a commission from the Most High ; so
neither can that evil being perfjiin any of this
without a commission from tlie same power.
The scripture recites more miracles wrought
by men than by angels good and bad. Though
this doctrine be so dishonourable to tlie only
Almighty Being, as to ascribe such attributes to
the evil one, as are the incommunicable [)rero-
gative oihim, who is the alone Sovereign Being,
yet here is not all ; but, as he that steers by a
false compass, the further he sails the more he
is out of his way; so, though there is in some
things a variation from, there is in others a fur-
ther progression in, or building upon, the said
doctrine of the maniche.
Men in this age are not content barely to be-
lieve such an exorbitant power to be in the na-
ture of this evil being; but have imagined that
he prevails with many to sign a book, or make
a contract with him, whereby they are enabled
to perform all the tilings above mentioned.
Another account is given hereof, viz. That by
virtue of such a covenant they attain power to
commission him. And though the two parties
are not agreed which to put it upon, whether
the devil empowers the witch, or the witch
commissions him; yet both parties ^re agreed
in this, that one way or other the mischief is ef-
fected, and so the criminal becomes culpable of
10
110 LETTERS TO
death. In the search after such a sort of cri-
minals, how many countries have fallen into
such convulsions, that neither the devastations
made by a conquering enemy, nor the plague
itself, have been so f )nnidable.
That not only good persons have thus been
blemished in their reputations, but much inno-
cent blood hath been shed, is testified even by
those very books.: Cases of Conscience, p. 33.
Remarkable Frovicl. p. 179. Memor, Provid,
p. 28.
And (to add) what less can be expected,
when men, having taken up such a belief, of co-
venanting, afflicting and killing witches, aud,
comparing it with the scripture, finding no foot-
steps therein of such a sort of wntch, have
thereupon desperately concluded, that though
the scripture is full in it, that a witch should not
live, yet that it has not at all described ihe
crime, nor means whereby the culpable might
be detected }
And hence they are fallen so far as to reckon
it necessary to make use of those diabolical and
bloody ways, always heretofore practised, for
their discovery ; as finding that the rules, given
to detect other crimes, are w4iolly useless for
the discovery of such.
This is that which has produced that deluge
of blood mentioned, and must certainly do so
again, the same belief remaining.
And wdio can wonder, if christians that are
so easily prevailed with to lay aside their
swords as useless, and so have lost their
strength, are (with vSamson) led blindfold in-
MR. MATllETl, kc. Ill
to an idol tcrn[)lc, to make sport for enemies
and inlidels, and to do abominable actions, not
only not christian, but ao;ainst even tlie light
ol" nature and reason ? And now, reverend la-
thers, you who are appointed as guides to the
people, and whose li[js should preserve know-
ledge ; who are set as shepherds, and as watch-
men ; this matter appertains to you. I wrote
to you formerly under this head, and acquainted
you with my sentiments, requesting that if 1 er-
red, you would be pleased to shew it me by
scripture ; but from your silence I gather that
you approve thereof. For I may reasonably
presume, that you would have seen it your duty
to have informed me better, if you had been
sensible of any error. But if in this matter you
have acquitted yourselves beconaing the titles
you are dignified with, you have cause of re-
joicing in the midst of calamities that afflict a
sinning w^orld.
Particularly, if you have taught the people
to fear God, and trust in him, and not to fear a
witch or a devil — That the devil has no power
to afflict any with diseases, or loss of cattle, &;c.
without a commission from the Most High —
That he is so filled with malice, that whatever
commission he may have against any, he will
not fail to execute it — That no mortal ever was,
or can be, able to commission him, or to length-
en his chain in the least, and that he who only
can commission him is God ; and that the scrip-
tures of truth not only assign the punishment of
a witch, but give suihcient rules to detect them
by ^ and that, according to mr. Gaule's fourth
Hi; LETTERS TO
head, a witch is one that hates and opposes the
word, work and worship of God, and seeks by
a sign to seduce therefrom — That they who are
gu iky according to that head, are guiUy of witch-
craft, and by the law given to Moses were to be
put to death :— If you have taught the people
the necessity of charity, and the evil of enter-
taining so much as a jealousy against their neigh-
bours for such crimes, upon the devil's sugges-
tions to a person pretending to a spectral or di-
abolical sight ; who utter their oracles from
malice, frenzy, or a satanical delusion— That to be
inquisitive of such, whose spectres they see, or
who it is that afflicts, in order to put the accu-
sed's life in question, is a v/ickedness beyond
what Saul was guilty of in going to the wntch —
That to consult with the dead, by the help of
such as pretend to this spectral sight, and so to
get information against the life of any person, is
the worst sort of necromancy — That the pre-
tending to drive away spectres, i. e. devils, with
the hand, or by strikmg these to wound a per-
son at a distance, cannot be without witchcraft,
as pretending to a sign in order to deceive in
matters of so high a nature — That 'tis ridicu-
lous to think, by making laws against feeding,
employing or rewarding of evil spirits, thereby
to get rid of them — That their nature requires
no sucking to support it — That it is a horrid in-
jury and barbarity to search those parts, which
even nature itself commands the concealing of,
to find some excrescence to be called a teat for
these to suck ; which yet is said sometimes to
appear as a fleabite: — Finally, if you have
MR. MATHIiR, &c. ilj
taught the people what to beheve and practise,
as to the probation of the accused, by their
saying or not saying the Lord's prayer, and as
to praying that the afflicted may be able to ac-
cuse, and have not shunned in these matters to
declare the whole mind of God ; you have then
well acquitted yourselves (in time of genera! de-
fection) as faithful watchmen. But if, instead
of this, you have, some by word and writing
propagated, and others recommended, such doc-
trines, and abetted the false notions, which are so
prevalent in this apostate age, it is high time to
consider it. If when authority found them-
selves almost nonplust in such prosecutions,
and sent to you for your advice what they
ought to do,*" and you have then thanked them
for what they had already done (and thereby
encouraged them to proceed in those very by-
paths already fallen into) it so much the more
nearly concerns you. Ezek. xxiii. 2 to 8.
To conclude : This whole people are invited
and commanded to humble their souls before
God, as for other causes, ibr the errors that
may have been fallen into in these prosecutions
on either hand, and to pray that God would
teach us what we know not, and help us where-
in we have done amiss, that we may do so no
more.t
This more Immediately concerns yourselves;
for 'tis not supposed to be intended, that God
w^ould shew us these things by inspiration ; but
that such who are called to it should shew th©
* Cases of Conscience, vlt. t Vide the proolanaatioD
for a fast, to be the 1 1th in^t, as set forth by authority.
10*
114 LETTERS TO
mind of God in these things on both hands, i. e..
whether there has been anj error in excess or
deficiency, or neither in the one nor the other.
And If you do not thus far serve the publick,you
need not complain of great sufferings and un-
righteous discouragements, if people do not ap-
plaud your conduct, as you might otherways
have expected.^ But if you altogether hold
vour peace at such a time as this is, your silence,
at least seemujgly, will speak this language ;
that you are not concerned, though men ascribe
the power and providence of the Almighty to
the worst of his creatures — that if other ages
or countries improve the doctrine and examples
given them, either to the taking away of the
life or reputations of innocents, you are well sa-
tisfied. Which, that there may be no shadow of
a reason to believe but that your conduct herein
may remove all such jealousies, and that God
■would be with you in declaring his whole mind
to the people, is the earnest desire and prayer
ef, reverend sirs, vours to my utmost,
R. C.
Mr. Benjamin^ Wads worth,
Reverend Sii\
After that dreadful and severe persecution of
such a multitude of people, under the notion of
Avitches, which, in the day thereoi', was the
sorest trial and ailliction that ever befel this
country : and after many of i\\e principal actors
^ The declaration, as drawn by the Deputies with thf-
assistance of the Ministers ; but received a nonconcor-
rence.
MR. MATHER, ^c. iio
had declared tlicir i'cars and jealousies, that
they had greatly erred in those prosecutions ;
and after a solemn day of fastinaj had been kept,
with prayers that God would shew us what we
knew not, viz. what errors might therein have
been fcilleninto,&c.; and after most people were
convinced of the evil of some, if not of most, of
those actions ; at such a time as this, it might
have been justly expected that the ministers
would make it their work to explain the scrip-
tures to the people ; and from thence to have
shown them the evil and danger of those false
notions, which not only gave some occasion, but
in a blind zeal hurried tliem into those unwar-
rantable practices, so to prevent a falling into
the like for the I'uture.
But instead of this, for a minister of the gos-
pel (pastor of the old meeting) to abet such no-
tions, and to stir up the magistrates to such pro-
secutions, and this without any cautions given,
is what is truly amazing, and of most dangerous
consequence.
It is a truth, witchcraft is, in the text then
insisted on, reckoned up as a manifest work of
the flesh, viz. Gal. v. 19. But it is as true, that
in recounting those other works (which are in-
deed manifest fleshly works) the magistrate was
not stirred up against those others ; as if the
rest were either not to be taken notice of by
jiim, or as if all zeal against murder, adulteries,
<fec. was swallowed up and overshadowed by
this against witchcraft.
The description that was then given, was,
that thoy were such as made a covenant with
116 LETTERS TO
the devil, and sold themselves to the evil angels.
It seems faulty, when such minister is inquir-
ed of, and requested to give the reasons, or
grounds in scripture, of such descrijDtion, for such
minister to assert that it is the inquirer's work
to disprove it. And his saying further, in an-
swer, that there are many things true, that are
not asserted in scripture, seems to speak this
language, viz. that the law of God is imperfect,
in not describing this crime of witchcraft, though
it be therein made capital.
These perfect oracles inform us, concerning
AJiab, that he sold himself to work wickedness;
which may signify to us, that great height of
wickedness he had arrived at; which yet might
be, without his being properly, or justly, account-
ed a witch; any more than those that are said
to have made a covenant with death, and with
hell, &c. Can it be thought that all those, or
such as are there spoken of, are witches, and
ought to suffer as witches ?
As the servants and people of God have made
a solemn, explicit covenant with him, (^Josh.xx'iv.
25. JVehem* ix 38, &c.) so no doubt a covenant
has been made by heathen indian nations, to
serve and adore the devil; yet even for this, it
were very hard to affix the character of a witch
upon each of those heathen that so do, and ac-
cordingly to execute them as such. It is also
possible, that some that have been called chris-
tians have sealed a writing, signed with their
own blood, or other ways, thereby covenanting
to be the devil's servants, Sic. but from far other
grounds, or inducements, than what s\Yays with
MR. MATHER, &c. 117
the indians ; these heathen hoping to please
him, that so he may not liarm them. But these
having heen educated and confirmed in tlie be-
hef, that by virtue of such covenant tliey shall
have a knowledge and power more than hu-
man assisting them ; this may have prevailed
with some to so horrible a wickedness ; for
none can seek evil for evil's sake ; but as the
serpent, in his first tempting man, made use of
the knowledge of good and evil, so to teacli
men that such effects do i!sually follow such co-
venant is properly the work of the serpent ;
for, without this, what inducement, or tempta-
tion, could they have to make such a covenant?
These, having thus chosen a false god, may
well be accounted the worst sort of idolaters.
Yet it does not hence follow, that, in a scripture
sense, they are thereby become witches, till
they have, or rather till they pretend to have,
assistances answerable : and do thereby endea-
vour to deceive others ; which endeavours to
deceive, by a sign, may be without any previ-
ous covenant.
But supposing none of all those several sorts
of covenants was intended, it remains that the
covenant, that was understood to be intended, in
that discourse at the old meeting, is agreeable
to the late dan^rerous notion that has so much
prevailed, viz. That the devil appears to the
persons ; that they and the devil make mutual
engagments each to other, confirmed' by signing
to the devil's book ; and are I'rom hence ena-
bled, not only to know futurities, and things
done at a distance, but are also thereby empow-
118 LETTERS TO
ered to do harm to their neighbours, to raise
storms, and do thinors above and a^jainst the
course of nature. This being the notion that has
occasioned the shedding so much blood in the
world, it may be thought to need explaining.
For as reason knows nothing of an afflicting,
covenanting witch, so it seems as foreign from
scripture in general, as it is from the text then in-
sisted on; which speaks of such wickednesses
as are manifestly the works of the fiesh : but
such communication with spirits, the flesh doth
manifestly dread even as death itself. There-
fore the usual salutation of the holy angels to
the best of men was, fear not; and experience
shews, that the most wicked are most affrighted
at the apprehensions of the appearances of dev-
ils; therefore such an explicit covenanting can-
not be a manifest work of the flesh.
Yet this is manifest, that the belief of the
witches power to do the things above mentioned,
is an ancient belief of the heathen; and that
from them it was received by the papists, as a
part of their faith, who have since improved
upon it and brought in the notion of a covenant.
But it seems yet a further improvement, lately
made by protestants, that such witches can
commission devils to do those mischiefs, thereby
setting the witch in the place of God; for
though few^ of the papists are known to be thus
absurd, yet when such doctrines have beeji
preached 'and printed in New-England, they
have met with none to oppose, but many to
encourage them. Other considerable additions,
^r new improvements, have been made here ;
m\. MATHER, kc. 119
as the art to knock oHT invisible chains with the
hand, to drive away spectres (i. e. devils) by
brushing, and spelNng words to the aillicted, <kc.
What has fohowed u[)on these notions, and upon
such improvements, is necdioss liere to repeat ;
it were unaccountable to recount that eiiusion
of blood that has been hereby occasioned ; such
remaining scars, and such yet bleeding wounds,
as are to be found; which none can wholly pre-
tend Ignorance of.
And ii' blood shall be required of that watch*
man that seeth the swokI coming, and gives not
the neediul warning, how much more of such as
join with the enemy, to bring in the sword to
destroy them, over whom he w as placed a watch-
man !
And if the law of God l)e perfect, and exceed-
ing broad, as being given forth by the Omniscient
Lawgiver, it is exceeding high presumption and
arrogance, and highly destnxtive to the lives of
innocents, for any to pretend to give another,
and a pretended better, description of a crime
made thereby capital, with new rules to try such
oftenders by.
Reverend sir, the matter, being of such high
concern, requires (and it is again prayed) that
you would be pleased to consider, and give the
grounds from scripture, or reason, of such defi-
nition ; or else that you would explode it, as in-
consistent with both. From, reverend sir, yours
to my utmost, R. C
TPART III.
ACCOUiNTOF THE DIFFERENCES
IN
SALEM VILLAGE.
Grounds of Complaint against Mr, Parrisj 8rc^
J. HE reasons why we withdraw from com-
munion with the church of Salem Village, both
as to hearing the word preached, and from par-
taking with them at the Lord's table, are as
follow :
Why we attend not on publick prayer, and
preaching the word, there are,
1. The distracting and disturbing tumults, and
noises, made by the persons under diabolical
power and delusions ; preventing sometimes our
hearing, understanding, and profiting by, the
"Word preached. We, having after many trials
and experiences found no redress in this matter,
accounted ourselves under a necessity to go
where we might hear the word in quiet.
2. The apprehension of danger of ourselves
being accused as the devil's instruments to afflict
11
|2« DIFFERENCES IN
the persons complaining, we seeing those, that
we have reason to esteem better than ourselves,
thus accused, blemished, and of their lives be-
reaved : for seeing this, thought it our prudence
to withdraw.
3. We found so frequent and positive preach-
ing up some principles and practices by mr.
Parris, referring to the dark and dismal mystery
of iniquity working among us, was not profitable,
but offensive.
4. Neither could we in conscience join with
mr. Parris, in many of the requests which he
made in prayer, referring to the trouble then
among us and upon us : therefore thought it
our most safe and peaceable way to withdraw.
The reasons why we hold not communion
with them at the Lord's table, are, because we
find ourselves justly aggrieved and offended with
the officer who does administer, for the reasons
following :
1. From his declared and published princi-
ples, referring to our molestations from the in-
visible world : differing from the opinion of the
generality of the orthodox ministers oi' the
country.
2. His easy and strong faith and belief of the
fore-mentioned accusations, made by those called
the afflicted.
3. His laying aside that grace (which above
all we are to put on) viz. charity towards his
neighbours, and especially tii ^^e of iiis chuich,
when there is no apparent reason but for the
cpntrary.
4. His approving and practising unwarrant-
SALEM VILLAGE. 123
able and ungrounded methods, for discovering
what he was desirous to know relerring to the
bewitched or possessed persons, as in bringing
some to others, and by them pretending to in-
form himseh' and others, who were the devil's
instruments to afflict the sick and maimed.
5. His unsafe, unaccountable oath, given by
him against sundry of the accused.
6. His not rendering to the world so fair (if
so true) account of what lie wrote on examina-
tion of the afflicted.
7. Sundry unsafe, if sound, points of doctrine,
delivered in his preaching, which we find not
warrantable (if christian.)
8. His persisting in these principles, and jus-
tifying his practice; not rendering any satisfac^
tion to us, when regularly desired, but rather of-
fending and dissatisfying ourselves.
We, whose names are under written, heard this paper
read to our pastor, Mr. Samuel Parris, the 21st of Aprilj
1693.
JVathaniel Jigarson^
Edward Putman^
Aaron Way^
William Way^
Peter Cloyce^ senior^
Samuel J\'urse^
John Tarboll^
Thomas Wilkins.
Mr. P arrises Jlcknowlcdgment.
For as much as it is the undoubted duty oi
all christians to pursue peace, Psal. xxxiv. 14,
even te a reaching of it, if it be possible ; {Jlmos
xii. 18, 19) and whereas, through the righteous,
sovereign and awful providence of God, the grand
enemy to all christian peace has been of late
tremendously let loose in divers places hereabout,
and more especially among our sinful selves, not
iU DfFFERENCES m
only to interrupt that partial peace which we
sometimes enjoyed, but also, through his wiles
•and temptations, and our weakness and corrup-
tions, to make wider breaches, and raise more
bitter animosities between too many of us; io
which dark and difficult dispensations, we have
been all or most of us of one mind for a time,
and afterwards of diifering apprehensions; and
at last we are but in the dark, upon serious
thoughts of all ; and after many prayers, I have
been moved to present to you (my beloved tlock)
the following particulars, in way of contribution
towards a regaining of christian concord, if so be
we be not altogether unappeaseable, irreconcile-
able, and so destitute of that good spirit, which
is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, and easy to
be entreated, James m. 17. viz.
1. In that the Lord ordered the late horrid
calamity (which afterward plague-like spread in
many other places) to break out first in my fami-
ly, I cannot but look upon as a very sore rebuke*
and humbling providence, both to myself and
mine, and desire so we may improve it.
2. In that also in my family were some of
both parties, viz. accusers and accused, I look
also upon as an aggravation of that rebuke, as
an addition of wormwood to the gall.
3. In the means which were used in my fam-
ily, though totally unknown to me or mine (ex-
cept servants) till afterwards, to raise spirits
and apparitions in no better than a diabolical
way, I do also look upon as a further rebuke of
Divine Providence. And by all, 1 do humbly
<>wn this day, before the Lord and his people
SALEM VILLAGE. 12^
that God has been righteously spitting in my
lace, JVumb. xii. 14. And I desire to lie lovv
under all this reproach, and to lay my hand on
my mouth.
4. As to the management of these mysteries,
as far as concerns myself, I am very desirous
upon further light to own any errors 1 have
therein fallen into, and can come to a discerning
of; in the mean while I do acknowledge, upon
after-considerations, that were the same trou-
bles again, (which the Lord of his rich mercy
forever prevent) 1 should not agree with my
former apprehensions in all points. As for in-,
stance,
1. I question not but God sometimes suffers
the devil, as of late, to afflict in shape of not
only innocent, but pious persons ; or so to de-
lude the senses of the afflicted, that they
strongly conceit their hurt is from such persons^
when indeed it is not.
2. The improving of one afflicted, to inquire
by who afflicts the other, I fear may be, and
has been, unlawfully used to satan's great ad-
vantage.
3. As to my writing, it was put upon me by
authority, and therein 1 have been very careful
to avoid the wronging of any.
4. As to my oath, I never meant it, nor do I
know how it can be otherwise construed, than
as vulgarly, and every one understood, yea, and
upon inquiry it may be found so worded also.
5. As to any passage in preaching, or praying,
in the soi'e hour of distress and darkness, 1 al-
•ways intended but due justice on each hand, and
11*
126 DIFFERENCES 11^
that not according to men, but God, who knovvt'
all things most perfectly; hoAvever, through
weakness or sore exercise, 1 might sometimes,
yea, and possibly sundry times, unadvisedly ex-
press myself.
6. As to several that have confessed against
themselves, they being wholly strangers to me,
but yet of good account with better men than
myseU, to whom also they are well known, I
do not pass so much as a secret condemnation
upon them; but rather, seeing God hath so
amazingly lengthened out satan's chain, in this
most formidable outrage, I much more incline to
side with the opinion of those that have grounds
to hope better of them.
7. As to all that have unduly suffered in these
matters, either in their persons or relations,
through the clouds of human weakness, and Sa-
tan's wiles and sophistry, 1 do truly sympathize
with them; taking it for granted, that such as
know themselves clear of this great transgres-
sion, or that have sufficient grounds so to look
upon their dear friends, have hereby been un-
der those sore trials and temptations, that not
an ordinary measure of true grace would be suf-
ficient to prevent a bewraying of remaining cor-
ruption.
8. I am very much in the mind, and abund-
antly persuaded, that God, for holy ends, though
for what in particular is best known to himself,
has suffered the evil angels to delude us on both
hands; but how far on the one side, or the
other, is much above me to Sxiy ; and if we cai>
jiot reconcile till we come to a full discerning oi
c^ALEM VILLAGi:. H^
these things, I fear we sliall never come to an
agreement, or at soonest not in this world.
9. Therefore, in fine, the matter being so
dark and perplexed, as that there is no present
appearance that aU God's servants should be al-
together of one mind in all circumstances, toucli-
ing the same, I do most heartily, fervently and
humbly beseech pardon of the mcrcil'ul God,
through the blood of Chrisrt, for all my mistakes
and trespasses in so weighty a matter; and also
all your forgiveness of every ollencc, in this or
other affairs, wherein you see or conceive that
I have erred and otlended ; professing, in the
presence of the Ahnighty God, that what 1
have done has been, as ibr substance, as 1 ap*
prehended was duty, however through weak-
ness, ignorance, (fee. I may have been mistaken-
1 also through grace promising eacli of you the
like of me, so again I beg, entreat and beseech
you, that satan, the devil, the roaring lion, the
old dragon, the enemy of all righteousness, may
no longer be served by us, by our envy and
strifes, where every evil work prevails whilst
these bear sway, (James iii. 14, 15, 16) but that
all from this day lor ward may be covered with
tiie mantle of love, and we may on all hands
forgive eacii other heartily, sincerely and thor-
oughly, as we do hope and pray that God for
Christ's sake would forgive each of ourselves^
(AlatU xviii. 21, to the end.) Coloss. iii. 12, 13,
Put on therpfore {as the elect of God, holy and be-
loved) bowels of mercies, kindness, hninbleness of
nnind, meekness, long-sffffering : forbearing one
-einolher, and' forgiving one another^ if any man
128 DIFFERENCES IN
have a quarrel against any ; even as Christ for^
gave you^ so also do ye. Eplu iv. 31, 32, Let
all bitterness, and anger , and clamour, and evil"
speaking, be put away from you, with all malice.
And be ye kind one to another, tender-hearted, for-
mvins one another even as God for Chrisfs sake
hath forgiven you. Amen. Amen.
Samuel Parris*
Given to the dissenting brethren, for their considera-
tion, at their request. JS^ov ember 2i), 1694.
The Elders and Messengers of the churches met
at Salem Village, April 3, 1695, to consider
and determine what is to be done, for the com-^
posure of the present unhappy differences in that
place ; after solemri invocation of God in Christ
for his direction, do unanimously declare, as
followeth, viz.
1. We judge that although in the late and
dark time of the confusions, wherein satan had
obtained a more than ordinary Hberty, to sift this
plantation, there were sundry unwarrantable
and uncomfortable steps taken by rnr. Samuel
Parris, the pastor of the church in Salem Vil-
lage, then under the hurrying distractions of
amazing afflictions; yet the said Mr. Parris, by
the good hand of God brought unto a better
sense of things, hath so fully exprest it, that a
christian charity may and should receive satis-
faction therewith.
2. Inasmuch as divers christian brethren, in
the church of Salem Village, have been offend-
ed at mr. Parris, for his conduct in the time of
their dlfiiculties, which have distressed them-;
9ALEM VILLAGE: 129
we now advise tliem charltiihly to accept tiie
satisl'action whicli lie hatli tendered in his chris-
tian acknowledgment ol the errors theiein cum-
mitted; yea, to endeavoui-, as far as it is possi-
ble, the i'ullest reconciliation ol' tlieir minds unto
communion with him, in the \vhol(> exercise of
his ministry, and with the rest ol" the churcli.
Matt. vi. 12, 14. Luke xviii. 3. James v. 16.
3. Considering the extreme trials and trou-
bles, which the disaffected brethren in the
churcii of Salem Village have undergone, in the
day of sore temptation which hath been upon
them; we cannot but advise the church to treat
them with bowels of much compassion, instead
of more critical or rigorous proceedings against
them for the infirmities discovered by them, in
such an heart-breaking day ; and if, after a pa-
tient waiting for it, the said brethren cannot so
far overcome the uneasiness of their spirits, in
the remembrance of the disasters that have
happened, as to sit under his ministry, we ad-
vise the church with all tenderness to grant
them admission to any other society of the faith-
ful, w hereunto they may be desirous to be dis-
missed. GaL vi. 1,2. Psal, ciii. 13, 14. Job xix. 21.
4. Mr. Parris having, as we understand, with
much fidelity and integrity acquitted himself, in
the main course of his ministry, since he hath
been pastor of the church of Salem Village;
about his first call whereunto, we look upon all
contests now to be both unreasonable and un-
seasonable ; and our Lord having made him a
blessing to the souls of not a few, both old and
young, in this place, we advise that he be af-
13a DIFFERENCES IN
cordingly respected, honoured and supported,
with all the regards that are due to a painful mi*
nister of the gospel. 1 Thess, v. 12, 13. 1 Tirr^.
V. 17.
5. Having observed that there is in Saleim
Village a spirit full of contention and animosity,
too sadly verifying the blemish which hath
heretofore lain upon them; and that some corn-
plaints against mr. Parris have been either
causeless or groundless, or unduly aggravated;
we do, in the name and fear of the Lord, so-
lemnly warn them to consider whether, if they
continue to devour one another, it will not be
bitterness in the latter end; and beware lest
the Lord be provoked thereby utterly to de-
prive them of those which they should count
their precious and pleasant things, and abandon
them to all the desolations of a people that sin
aAvay the mercies of the gospel. James iii. 16.
Gal V. 15. 2 Sam, ii. 26. ha. v. 45. MatL xxi.
43.
6. If the distempers in Salem Village should
be (which God forbid) so incurable, that mr.
Parris, after all, find that he cannot with any
comfort and service continue in his present sta-
tion, his removal from thence will not expose
him to any hard character with us ; nor, we
hope, witfi mQ res- of the people ofGod, amorg
whom we live. Matt, x. 14. Acts\i^\\, 18. All
which advice we follow with our prayers, that
th*^ G;>d of peace would bruise Satan under our
i^eX. Now the Lord of peace himself give you
peace always by all means.
Jos. Bridghain^f I Jer. Dummer^
Samuel Chickley^ \ Aeh. Jewitt^
James AUen^
SALEM VILLAGE. 15*1
William Tory^
Jos. Boynton^
R. Middlecult^
John Walley^
Ephr. Ifunt^
A'. Williams^
Incr.^lalher^
S. r/tillips,
S. rVillard,
E. Fmyson^
C. Mather,
To the Reverend Elders of the three churches of
Christ at Boston^ icith others the Elders and
Brethren of other churches, late of* a Council cU
Salem Village,
We whose names are hereunto subscribed,
are bold once more to trouble you with our
hunrble proposals : — That whereas there have
been long and uncomfortable dilferences among
us, chiefly relating to mr. Pariis ; and we having,
as we appreliend, attended all probable means
for a composure of our troubles : and whereas
we had hopes of an happy issue, by your en-
deavours among us, but now are utterly I'rust rat-
ed in our expectations, and that instead of unit-
ing, our rent is made worse, and our breach
made wider:
We humbly query, whether yourselves, being
straightened of time, might not omit such satis-
factory liberty of debating the whole of our
controversy; whereby yourselves had not so
large an opportunity of understanding the ca?e,
nor the onended so much reason to be satisfied
in your advice: We therefore humbly propose,
imd give full liberty of proving and defending of
what may be charged on either hand, leaving it
to yourselves to appoint both time and plajce,
1- That if yourselves please to take the troir-
ble, with patience once more to hear the whole
case.
2* Or (hat you will more plainly advise mF.-
132 DIFFERENCES m
Parris (the case being so circumstanced tliat he
cannot, with comfort or profit to himself or
others, abide in the work of the ministry among
us) to cease his labours, and seek to dispose him-
self elsewhere, as God in his providence may di-
rect; and that yourselves would please to help
us in advising to such a choice, wherein we may
be more unanimous; which we hope would tend
much to a composure of our diiferences.
3. Or that we may without any offence take
the liberty of calling some other proved minister
of the gospel, to preach the word of God to us
and ours; and that we may not be denied our
proportionable privilege, in our public disburse-
ments in the place.
So leaving the whole case with the Lord and
yourselves, we subscribe our names.
Signed by 16 yciing men, from 16 upwards; and 52
householders, and 18 church members. This was deli-
vered to the mmisters, May 3, 1695.
The copy of a paper that icas handed about^ touch-
ing!; those differences.
As to the contest between mr. Parris and his
hearers, (kc. it may be composed by a satisfac-
tory answer to Lcvit. xx. 6, "And the soul that
turneth after such as have familiar spirits, and
■after wizards, to go a whoring after them, I
will set my face against that soul, and will cut
him off from among his people." 1 Chron, x. 13,
14, " So Saul died for his trangression, which he
committed against the Lord, even against the
word of the Lord, which he kept not; and also
for asking counsel of one that had a familiar spi-
SALEM VILLAGE i»h
rlt, to inquire of it ; and inquired not of the Lord;
therefore he slew hiui."" cSic.
Some part of the detcrminntion of the Elders and
Messengers of the churches^ wet at Salem Vil-
lage^ Jfpril'd', 1695, relating to the differences
there.
If the distemper in Salem Village should be
(which God forbid) so incurable that mr. Parris,
after all, find that he cannot with any comfort
and service continue in his present station, his
removal from thence will not ex|X)se him to any
hard character with us, nor, we hope, with the
rest of the people of God, among whom we live.
Matt. X. 14, Jlnd whosoever shall not receive you^
nor hear your words ; when you depart out of that
house, or city, shake off the dust of your feet, cSt.
Acts xxii. 18. All which advice we follow with
our prayers, that the God of peace would bruise
satan under our ^gqU Now^ the Lord of peace
give you peace alv^ays, by all means, &:c.
Quest. Whether Mr. Parris's going to Abi-
gail Williams and others, whom he supposed to
have a spectral sight, to be informed who were
witches and who afflicted those pretended suf-
ferers by witchcraft, in order to their being
questioned upon their lives upon it, were not a
turning after such as had familiar spirits; and a
greater wickedness than Saul was guilty of, in
that he did not intend thereby bodily hurt to
any others?
And whether, in a crime of such a high na-
ture, the making a slender and general confcs-
12
134 DIFFERENCES IN
sion, Without any proposals of reparations, or
due time for probation, ought so far to be ac-
counted sufficient, from such a pastor to his peo-
ple?
And whether such as were accused, or the
'Surviving friends and relations of those that
were any ways sufferers by accusations so by
him proved, are in duty and conscience bound to
continue their respect, honour and support to
him, in the ministry, after such known depar-
tures from the rule of God's word, and after
such dire effects as followed thereupon, under
the penalty of the dust shaken from his feet ^ tes-
tifying against them, even so as to render them
in a worse case than those of Sodom and Go-
morrah ?
To the Honourable Wait JVinthrop, EUsha Cook
and Samuel Seicall^ Esquires^ arbitrators^ indif
fcrently chosen, between Mr, Samuel P arris and
the inhabitants of Salem Village,
The remonstrances of several aggrieved per-
sons in the said village, with further reasons why
they conceive they ought not to hear mr. Parris,
nor to own him as a minister of the gospel, nor
to contribute any support to him as such, for
several years past; humbly offered as fit for
consideration.
We humbly conceive that having, in April,
1693, given our reasons why we could not join
with mr. Panis in prayer, preaching, or sacra-
ments; if these reasons are Ibund sufficient for
our withdra vying, (and we cannot yet find but
they are) then we conceive ourselves virtually
SALEM VILLAGE. 13^
dischatfijed, not only in conscience, but also in
law; which requires maintenance to be given to
such as are orthodox, and blameless; the said
mr. Parris having been teaching such dangerous
errors, and preached such scandalous immorali-
ties, as ought to discharge any (though ever so
gifted otherways) from the work of the ministry.
Particularly in his oath against the lives of
several, wherein he swears that the prisoners
with their looks knock down those pretended
suiFerers. We humbly conceive, that he that
swears to more than he is certain of, is equally
guilty of perjury with him that swears to what
is false. And though they did fall at such a
time, yet it could not be known that they did it,
much less could they be certain of it ; yet did
swear positively against the lives of such, as he
could not have any knowledge but they might
be innocent.
His believing the devil's accusations, and rea-
dily departing from all charity to persons, though
of blameless and godly lives, upon such sugges-
tions; his promoting such accusations; as also
his partiality therein, in stifling the accusations
of some, and at the same time vigilantly promo-
ting others, as we conceive, are just causes for
our refusal, &:c.
That mr. Parris's going to Mary Walcut, or
Abigail Williams, and directing others to them,
to know who afflicted the people in their ill-
nesses— we understand this to be a dealing with
them that have a familiar spirit, and an impli-
cit denying the providence of God, who alone,
as we believe, can send afflictions, or cause d^-
136 DIFFERENCES IN
yils to afflict any ; tills we also conceive suffi-
cient to justify such refusal.
That mr. rarris, by these practices and prin-
ciples, has been the beginner and procurer of
the sorest afflictions, not to this Village only,
but to this whole country, that did ever befal
them.
We, the subscribers, in behalf of ourselves,
and of several others of the same mind with us,
(touching these things) having some of us had
our relations by these practices taken oif by an
wntimely death ; others have been imprisoned,
and suffered in our persons, reputations and es-
tates; submit the whole to your honours deci-
sion, to determine whether we are or ought to
be any ways obliged to honour, respect and sup-
port such an instrument of our miseries; pray-
ing God to guide your honours to act herein as
may be for his glory, and the future settlement
l^f our village in amity and unity.
John Tarholl^ \
Samuel Nurse^ f Attorneys for the people
Jos. Putman^ ? of the village.
Dan, Andrew^ j
Boston, July 21, 1697.
According to the order of the aforesaid arbi^
trators, the said mr. Parris had some of his ar-
rears paid him, as also a sum of money for his
repairs of the ministerial house of the said vil-
lage, and is dismissed therefrom.
PART IV.
LETTERS
OF A GENTLEMAN UNINTEREvSTED,
ENDEAVOURING TO PROVE THE RECEIVED OPINIONS
ABOUT WITCHCRAFT TO BE ORTHODOX,
Sir,
I TOLD you I had some thoughts concern-
ing witchcraft, and an intention of conferring with
the gentleman who has published several trea-
tises about witchcraft, and persons afflicted by
them, lately here in New-England; but since
you have put those three books into my hands,
1 find myself engaged in a very hard province,
to give you my opinion of them. I plainly fore-
see, that should this scribbling of mine come to
public view, it would displease all parties, but
that is the least. Moreover it is so far out of my
road to set my thoughts to consider a matter on
every side, which in itself is so abstruse, and
every step I advance therein, ii' I miss truth
(which is a narrow and undivided line) I must
tumble down headlong into iiie (;u]ph of dange-
rous error. Yet. notwithstanding, I have forced
jnyseU to senti these few lines, if so be 1 may
12*
13a LETTERS OF
clear to you a truth you now seem to be offend-
ed at, because of the ill consequences which (you
think) lately have and again may be drawn from
it, by the ill condui:t oi* some men. I am not
ignorant that the pious frauds of the ancient, and
the inbred fire (I do not call it pride) of many
of our modern, divines, have precipitated them
to propagate and maintain truth as well as false-
hoods, in such an unfair manner, as has givea
advantage to the enemy to suspect the whole
doctrine, these men have profest, to be nothing
but a mere trick. But it is certain, that as no
lover of truth will justify an illegitimate corol-
lary, though drawn from a true proposition; so
neither will he reject a truth, because some or
many men take unfair means to prove it, or draw
false consequences from it. The many heresies
among christians must not give a mortal wound
to the essence of the christian religion; neither
must any one christian doctrine be exterminated,
because evil men make use of it as a cloak to
cover their own self-ends ; particularly, because
=!ome men, perhaps among all sorts of christians,
have, under pretence of witchcraft, coloured
their own malice, pride and popularity, we must
not therefoi'e conclude (1.) that there are no
witches; (2.)^or that witches cannot be convict-
ed by such clear and undeniable proof, as the
law of God requires in the case of death : (3.) or
that a witch so convicted ought not to be put to
death.
1. Thai there are witches, is manifest from
ihe precept of Moses, Thou shalt not svffer a
r^ltcli to live. Exod. xxii. 13. For it is certain
A GENTLEMAN, .vc. ijj
God would not have given a vain and unintelli-
gible law, as this uiust be, of putting witches to
death, it* there are no witches. But you object,
that this doth not answer our case, for we have
formed another idea of witches than what can
be gathered from the scriptures; you quote
four places, viz. Dent. xiii. Matt. xxiv. Jlcts xlii,
2 Tim. iii. from all which you infer, that witch-
craft is a maligning and oppugning the word,
works and worship of God, and by an extraor-
dinary sign seeking to seduce any from it; and
this you readily graiit. But then you say, What
is this to witches now a days, who are said to
have made an explicit covenant with the devil,
and to be empowered by him to the doing of
thinfijs strange in themselves, and besides their
natural course? This you say does not follow;
and herein indeed consists the whole controver-
sy; therefore it is necessary, that first of all we
clear this point, hiying aside those prejudices we
may have from the fatal application of this doc-
trine to some who were (in your judgment) re-
ally, at least in law, and before men, innocent.
In a word, we are seeking after truth, and truth
shall and will be truth, in spite of men and devils.
I do not repeat this caution to forestall you to
believe^the doctrine of witchcraft, as it is above
defined, without inquiring into the reason and
'truth of it; only I desire you to inquire into it,
as a thing doubtful. For no man can be certain
of a negative, unless either the affirmative ira|)ly
a contradiction, or he can prove it by certain
testimony; to neither of which you pretend;
only you alledge it cannot be proved by scrip-
140 lETTERS OF
ture, i. e. you cannot prove it, nor have seen it
proved by any other you have read on that sub-
ject. I am not so vain as to think I can do bet-
ter than the learned authors you have consuUecJ
with (though I know not what they have done,
for I had no other book but the bible, to make
use of on this occasion ;) but because I am satis-
fied myself, and am willing to communicate my
reasons, which I divide into three heads, 1. The
appearance of angels. 2. The nature of pos-
session; and, 3d, The scripture notion of witch-
craft.
1. Good angels did appear to Abraham, and
did eat, Gen. xv. It seems he washed their ie^i ;
it is certain he saw and heard them; therefore
there is no impossibility in angels being conver-
sant with men. God is true, and whatever
is contained in sacred writ is true ; if we poor
shallow mortals do not comprehend the manner
how, that argues only our weakness and igno-
rance in this dark prison of flesh, wherein we
are enclosed during our abode in this vale of
misery, but doth not in the least infringe the
verity of scripture ; it is sufficient that we ui>
doubtedly know they have appeared unto men
in bodily shape, and done their errand they
were sent on from God. Now if good angels
have appeared, why may not bad .^ Surely the
devils, because fallen and evil, have not there-
fore lost the nature of angels; neither is there
any contradiction in their appearing in a bodily
sha])e, now after, any more than before, their fall.
But you will say you must allow of the appear-
ances of good angels, because of the scripture
A GENTLEMAN, i.c. 141
testimony; but not oi' bad, seeing there is no
place ol' scripture tliat clearly proves it. Afati.
IV, The words in the gos[)el do as plainly signil'y
the devil's outward appearance to our Saviour,
when he was tempted, as can be expressM;
J^nd when the tempter came to him he said — hut
he answered. The same form St. Luke useth
to signify the appearance of" Moses and Elias,
in the transfiguration : ^nd behold there talked
with him two men; for what lollows, ver. 3],
who appeared^ is used to signify (not their ap-
pearance, but) the manner of their appearance
in great glory. But you will urge, that it is very
easy to be understood, that Moses and r has
did appear, because they had human bodies; but
that it is unintelligible to you, how the devil, be-
ing a spirit, can appear, a spirit being a substance
void of all dimensions; therefore the words in
the history must not be taken in a literal sense.
Do not mistake : though some philosophers are
of opinion (which whether true or false is all one
to our present argument) that a spint^'s sub-
stance is extended, and hath, besides length,
breadth and depth, a i'ourth dimension, viz. es-
sential spissitude ; yet the same do not say, that
pure substance is perceptible by our bodily
senses; on the contrary, they tell us, that spirits
are clothed with vehicles, «. e. they are united
to certain portions of matter, which they inform,
move and actuate. Now this we must not re-
ject as impossible, because we cannot compre-
hend the formal reason, how a spirit acts upon
matter: for who can give the reason, that, upon
the volition of the human soul, tlio hand should
142 LETTERS OP
be lifted up, or any ways moved? for to say the
contraction of the muscles is the mechanic cause
of voluntary motion, is not to solve the question,
which recurs, Why, upon volition, should that
contraction ensue which causes that motion?
All that I know the wisest man ever said upon
this head is, that it is the will of the Creator,
who has ordered such a species of thinking crea-
tures, by a catholic law, to be united to such por-
tions of matter, so and so disposed ; or, if you will,
in the vulgar phrase, to organized bodies ; and
that there should be between them and the se-
veral bodies they are united to a mutual reaction
and passion. Now you see how little we know of
the reason of that which is most near to us, and
most certain, viz. the soul's informing the body^
yet you would think it a bad argument, if one
should, as some have done, conclude, from this
our ignorance, that there was nothing in us but
matter; it is no otherways than to deny a spirit's
acting a veliicle. The plainest and most certain
things when denied are hardest to be proved;
therefore the axiom saith well, contra principia,
Src, There are some certain truths, which are
rather to be explained to young br^ginners than
proved, upon which all science is built; as eve-
ry whole is more tlian its part ; and of this sort
1 take these two following: 1. That there are
two substances, corpus and mew^, body and spirit,
altogether different, for the ideas we have of
them are quite distinct. 2. That a spirit can
actuate, animate or inform a certain portion of
matter, and be united to it; from whence it is
very evident, that the devil, united to a portion
A GENTLEMAN, &c. 143
of matter rwlilch hercal'ter I'll call a vehicle)
may lall unuer the cognizance of our senses, and
be conversant with us in a bodil) sfiape. Where
then is the reason or need to run to a metapho-
rical and forced interpretation, wIilii tiie words
arc so plain, and the literal sense iinplieth no
contradiction, nor any greater dilTiculty than (as
has been said) what ariseth from the union of
the soul and body, which is most certain? Now
after all to say, God will not permit the devil so
to appear, is to beg the question, without saying
any thing to the preceding argument; and it is
against the sense of almost all mankind; for in
all ages, and all places, there have been many
witnesses of the appearances of daemons, all of
whom, that taught any thing contrary to the
right worship of the true God, were certainly
evil ones : and it were most presumptuous, bare-
ly to assert that all these witnesses were always
deceived, and it is impossible they could all agree
to deceive.
2. We come to consider the nature of pos-
session. The man possest (^Luke viii. 27) had
a power more than natural, for he brake the
bands, which he could not have done with his
own strength. Now from whom had he this
power? 1 he scripture saith, he had devils a
long time, and oftentimes it had caught him, 6cc.
he was kept bound with chains and in fetters,
and he br.ike the bands, and was driven of the
devil into tlie wilderness. This power then was
immediately from the devil, and whatsoever a
possessed person doe-, or suifers, beyond his na-
tural power, he is euabied by the daemon so to
144 LETTERS OF
do; or, to speak more properly, it is the dasmon
who acteth the same, as is plain from St. Mark's
relation of this passage, y, 2v, A man with an
unclean spirit. 3 v. And no man could bind him^
no, not with chains, 6 %\ But when he saw Jesus
ajar o^, he came and worshiped him; and the
same /le, 7 v, said, / adjure thee by God that thou
torment me not ; and 9 v. My name is Legion, for
we are many. 10 v. And he besought him much^,
that he would not send them away out of the coun-
try. It is manifest from hence, that it was not
the poor man who was possest, but the devils
who possessed him, by whom the chains had
been plucked asunder, and the fetters broken in
pieces. Now here is divine testimony, that the
devils have actuated a human body to the doing
of things beyond the natural strength of that
body, as it was simply united to its human soul :
how much more then can the devil actuate any
other portion of simple matter, earth, air, fire
or water, and make it a fit organ for himself to
act in!
But enough of this already: let us rather in-
quire how tile devil enters into the body of the
possest, to move it at his pleasure. This I think
he cannot do as a mere spirit, or by any never
so strict union with the human soul ; for in that
case he is only a tempter or seducer, and no-
thing above human strength can be done: but
here there being something performed (the
bonds broken) by a force which could not pro-
ceed from human strength, it necessarily follow^s
that the devils entered into t\ie possest, other-
ways qualified them as a mere spirit ; he did
A GENTLEMAN, kc. U5
not enter without some portion of matter, to
which he was united, by the intermedium
whereof lie acted U})on and actuated the human
body. Again, it' it is said that the devil entered
as a mere spirit, and immediately acted upon
and moved that body, it follows, the devil hath
a vehicle, a certain portion oi' matter (that bo-
dy) to actuate and dispose of at will; whicli is
absurd: 1, Because it asserts what it seems to
deny, viz. the deviPs having a vehicle to act im-
mediately upon; and to be united to a portion
of matter (is has been said before) is the same
thing. 2, It fights against the catholic law of the
union of soul and body, by which the Omnipo-
tent hath ordained the voluntary motion of a hu-
man body to depend upon the will of its human
soul, and those that are not voluntary to proceed
either from its own mechanism or material
force; hence we may certainly conclude, that it
is by the intervening of the devil's vehicle, that
he enters into the body of the possest. But
what if you and I cannot agree about this no-
tion of possession, must we therefore reject the
truth itself, and run to a far-fetched and intoler-
able sense of the words .^ No, our opinions do
not alter the nature of things; it is certain there
were persons possest, and it is as certain that
the devil entered into them, either with or with-
out a vehicle; it is all one which part of the
contradiction you take, the consequence is the
same, viz. That the devil doth act immedi-
ately upon matter.
There is another acceptation of the word,
possession in scripture, {./lets xvi. 17) where one
13
146 , LETTERvS OF
is said to be possest with a spirit of divination,
the word commonly used to the priestess oY
Aoollo, who gave responses; and it seems this
damsel was such an one, for she brought her
masters much money, or gain, by soothsaying, till
they Avere full of the god. Now if the history
«f them be true, that they were demented, and
knew not themselves what they uttered, (as
they word it) their case is not ditferent, but the
same with the foregoing; but if they understood
what they spoke, then had they familiar spirits,
whereof there is frequent mention made in the
old testament, and one good king is commended
for having cut off them that had such ; thercibre
I think the meaning of the word was very ob-
vious in his time ; neitlier was it ever contro-
verted being joined with any other name than
spirit, familiar, one of our own family; that is,
oft, every day, conversant with us, and almost
ever ready upon call to attend us. But the
consideration of them, who have familiar spirits,
falleth under the head of witchcraft, which we
are to consider in the third place.
3. Witchcraft, to inquire into the scripture
notion of it, and compare whether it be the
same with that above defmed. The cabalistick
Jiearning would be of great use in this search,
and afford us much light; there is little doubt
but that there arn nrany great truths not com-
monlj known. And our Saviour expressly cau-
tions his disciples that tliey do not throw their
pearls before swino : therefore it is no wonder
that s*>m? do t'ii;e-. tliougi imquestionably true^
are not so lully described, because the authors
A GENTLEMAN, Sicr UJ
who treat of them are afraid, lest evIF men
should be the more depraved by being inform-
ed: but I am in no such fear; nor can I give
you any other thoughts but what are obvious to
any man, from the plain sense of the scripture.
Our detinition we'll divide into two propositions,
and handle them severally. 1 Proposition.
The witch is empowered by the devil to do
things strange in themselves, and beside their
natural course. 2 Prop. The manner how
the witch is empowered to do those strange
things, is by explicit compact, or covenant, with
the devil. For clearing of the first, we will
consider the four places above cited, wherein a
witch is called a false prophet, a false Christ, a
sorcerer, a resistor of the truth, and is said to
shew signs to seduce the people to seek after
other gods: whence let us note three things
1. That those terms, witch, false Christ, false
prophet and sorcerer, are all synonimous, i. e.
signify the same thing. 2. That a witch doth
do things strange in themselves, and beyond
their natural course : for it were most ridicu-
lous to alledge that our blessed Saviour, when
he said, there shall arise false Christs, and shall
shew great signs and wonders^ in so much that {if
it were possible) they shoidd deceive the very elect,
meant that cunning cheats should arise, and
shew legerdemain tricks; the words will in no
wise bear it, and I believe you are far from thus
interpreting them ; so it is manifest they signify
not a feigned, but a real, doing of things, beyond
their natural course ; therefore the sorceries of
Elymas and Simon were not simple delusions.
148 LETTERS OF
but real effects, that could not have been pro-
duced by physical causes in the ordinary course
of nature. 3. That the end of the witches*
shewing these signs, is to seduce the people to
seek after other gods; from which premises I
infer, that the witches have the power of doing
those wonders, or strange things, immediately
from the devil : they are without the reach of
nature, and therefore above human power, and
no mere man can etfect them; the witch then
who does them must have the power of doing
them from another; but who is the other?
God will not give his testimony to a He; and to
say God did at any time empower a witch to
work wonders, to gain belief to the doctrine of
devils, were Avith one breath to destroy root
and branch of all revealed religion; no, it can-
not be, it is only God's permission, who proveth
his people, whether they love him with all their
heart, and with all their soul. Therefore the
witch has a power of doing wonders, or strange
things, immediately from the devil. 2 Propo-
sition, w^e will subdivide into these two.
1. That there is an express covenant between
the witch and the devil. 2. That it is not rea-
sonable to suppose this covenant to be trans-
acted mentally. 1. The devil cannot communi-
cate this power, by never so strict a union with
the soul of the witch; for in that case he is only
a tempter, and nothing above human power can
be done, as has been already proved ; therefore
the devil, who improves the witch to do things
above human power, must either appear in an
external shape, and instruct him how, and upon
A GENTLEMAN, &c. 149
what terms, he will enable him to do those won-
ders ; or else he must enter iiito the body of
tfie witch, and possess it. The demoniacs in
the gospel are such whom the devils invade by
main force, tlieir soul having no further com-
mand of their bodies, which are subjected to the
Avill of the devils ; whose end is to wound and
torment those miserable creatures, to throw
them into the fire, and into the water : but the
witch, who likewise is possessed, is not treated
in such an outrstgeous manner; his daemon is
tame and familiar unto him, and suffers liim for
a time to live quietly, without any further mo-
lestation, than prompting him to do his utmost
endeavour to withdraw men from God ; he is
not bereaved of his senses as the poor lunatic,
but is conscious of all he does, and willeth all
his crimes : he receiveth power from the devil
to do wonders, and doth them to serve the de-
vil's turn. Therefore there must be a cove-
nant, an express covenant, between the devil and
him, viz. that he shall obey the devil and serve
him, and that the devil shall both enable him
so to do, and also reward him for so doing;
for if there is no contract between them, how
comes the witch to know he has a supernatural
power ? or how can he so peremptorily pretend
to do that which is so much above his natural
power, not knowing he has a supernatural one
enabling him to do the same ? There can be
no doubt but there was a very intimate com-
merce between satan and him who is called by
St. Paul tliou child of the devil, not as other un-
holy men, but in an especial manner, as being
13*
150 LETTERS OF
the enemy of all righteousness, who would not
cease to pervert the right w^ays of the Lord. It
is not to be supposed that he entered into this
so near a relation with satan, with which he is
stigmatized, that others may beware of him,
without his own knowledge and consent. And
is not this a covenant, an express covenant, on
his part, to serve the devil incessantly; and on.
the devil's, to empower him to act his sorceries
•wherewith he bewitched the people ? Now I
think I have from scripture fully satisfied you of
the truth of what 1 offered in a discourse at
. But, since, you have told me an explicit
covenant with the devil signifies the devil's
appearing in a bodily shape to the witch, and
their signifying an express covenant, which you
say cannot be proved from scripture. It were
most unreasonable to imagine that the ceremo-
nies of this hellish mystery are particularly set
down in the word of God; therefore we must
gather by analogy and reason the matter how
this express covenant is transacted ; and to that
end I will set down these following considera-
tions.
1. Under the law God did ordain his people
in all their matters to have recourse immedi-
ately to himself, and depend upon him for coun-
sel, which they were ready to obey, with full
assurance of aid and protection from him against
their enemies. This the devil imitateth by set-
ting up of oracles among the heathen, to which
all the kings, nations and mighty conquerors up*
on earth, did come, and paid their humblest ado-
ration to the god (as the devil blasphemously
A GKNTLEMAN, iic. 151
called himself) of the temple, in which they
were imploring his direction and assistance in
their doubtliil and |)rosj>erous allairs. Again,
God instituted sacriliccs to put men in mind of
their duty to the Creator, to whom they owe
all things, eyen themselves ; but the devil is not
contented with the bare imitation hereof; the
acknowledgment and worship he receiveth
from the deluded world is not enough, though
they oiFer up unto him innumerable hecatombs,
unless they cause their children to pass through
the fire unto him, to whom no sacrifice is so
Avell pleasing as that of human blood. And
there is no reason to think, that now, under the
economy of the gospel, the devil hath left olF to
vie with God, and thereby to ensnare men.
No, it is rather to be feared that his kingdom
doth now more prevail; for by how much the
light is greater, so much greater is their con-
demnation who do not receive it : it is reasona-
ble to su[)pose that (seeing the Son of God,
when he came to transact with men the wond-
erful covenant of their redemption, took upon
him their nature, and was perfect man) the de-
vil likewise doth counterfeit the same, in up-
pearing in an human shape to them who receive
him, and confederate themselves with him, and
become his vassals.
2. Consider, it is not probable that those false
apostles mentioned, 2 Cor. xi. 13, erred only in
ceremonies or circumstances, or that their er-
rors, though great, did proceed rather from
their ignorance than I'rom the perverseness of
their minds. ] Cor. iii. 15. For, for such we
152 LETTERS OF
may have charity and hope, that God will be
merciful unto them, if they sincerely do the best
they know, though they dissent in some, nay
many things, from the practices and belief of
the christian church; but those St. Paul threat-
ens with a heavy curse, that their end shall be
according to their works ; therefore it seems
they immediately struck at the very root and
being of the christian religion, and were the
same with them spoken of^ 2 Tim. iii. 6, but
with this difference, that they did not resist,
but, beholding the miracles and signs which
were done by the true apostle of our Lord,
wondered, and believed also, and were baptized;
yet, being sorcerers, they were unwilling to lose
that great esteem they had obtained ; as it is
related of Simon, who had bewitched the people
of Samaria, giving out that he himself was some
great one, to whom they all gave heed, from
the least to the greatest, saying, this man is the
great power of God ; therefore he could not
brook that Peter or John should have a great-
er power than himself; but offered them money,
that on whomsoever he laid hands, he (that
person) should receive the Holy Ghost ; which
shews him, who thus designed to make merchan-
dise of the Spirit, though baptized, to have been
no true believer, but still a sorcerer, in the gall
of bitterness, and in the bond of iniquity. Such
were those deceitful workers, who, not being
able barefaced to resist, did put on Christianity
as a mask, that they might undermine the truth,
and introduce the doctrines of devils. Samaria
and Paphos were not the only two places
A GENTLEMAN, &c. 15S
where the devil had sucli agents ; there was no
part of the earth where his kingdom was not es-
tabhshcd, and wliere he had not his emissaries
before the preaching of the gospel; and since
the text telleth us lie hath his ministers, who
imitate their master, by being transformed into
the apostles of Christ, as he himself is transform-
ed into an angel of light: whose design, in b(Mng
thus transformed, cannot be to impose upon the
Almigiity; for whatever shape he appears in,
he cannot hide his ugliness from the eyes of him
who is omniscient; therefore he appeareth thus
in the shape of an angel of light, either to ternpt
and seduce the blessed spirits to rebel against
God, or to ensnare wicked men, who by their
heinous crimes (being lovers of themselves, cove-
tous, boasters, proud, blasphemers) were before
disposed to be tit instruments to serve him, and
to enter into league with him. Surely I, who
am ignorant of the laws by which the intel-
lectual woild is governed, dare not afhrm that
it is impossible for satan so to appear, as to hide
his deformities from the good angels, and under
that vail to tempt them: but certain I am that
it is more consonant to reason, to think that the
aposde's intention here was to teach that the
devil appeared as a glorified angel unto men, to
gain ministers, whom he might imbue with the
poison of his black art, and (when he had got-
ten full possession of them) instruct theni by his
own example to transform themselves into the
apostles of Christ, that under that vizard they
might with the greater advantage promote his
ends, and join with him in doing the utmost des-
pite to the spirit of grace.
154 LETTERS OF
3d Consideration: It is against the nature of
this covenant, that it should he C(;nsuniinated by
a mental colloquy between the devil and the
witch. I know not how many articles it con-
sists of; but it is certain, from what has been
already proved, that the renouncing of Christ to
be the Son of God, and owning the devil to be,
and worshiping him as God, are the two chiefs,
to which our Saviour, who weis accused of cast-
ing out devils by Beelzebub, i. e. of being con-
federated with Beelzebub, was tempted to con-
sent : If thou be the Son of God^ command that
these stones be made bread : and again, throw thy-
self down from hence ; for it is written^ he will give
his angels charge over thee ; and again, all these
things will I give thee^ if thou wilt fall down and
ivorship me. Whence it is evident that here
the devil laboured to insinuate into our Lord,
either to do things rash and unwarrantable, or
to suspect his sonship, revolt from God his fa-
ther, and worship satan, that he might obtain
the glory of the world. Now it has been al-
ready said, that when Jesus was tempted, the
devil appeared unto him in a bodily shape;
therefore it is agreeable to reason, that he doth
appear in the same manner to all them, whom
he also tempteth to worship him: moreover,
the form of renouncing a covenant ought to bear
resemblance to the form of entering into the
same covenant; therefTe men who are receiv-
ed into the mystic.il body of Christ by God's
minister, who in God's stead expressly cove-
nanteth with and tlien administerelh the sacra-
ment of baptism unto them, must in the like
A GENTLEMAN, kc. 155
manner ^o out of, or renounce, the said cove-
nant ; at)cl olthein there are two sorts, one who,
through tlie perversenoss of their own hearts,
the lucre of the world, the fear of men more
than of God, abjure their Saviour, turn apos-
tates, turks, or pagans. The other sort is of
them who contract with the devil to be his sub-
jects, in the initiation of whom it is not to be
supposed that the devil will omit any material
circumstance which tends both to bring them in-
to and conhrm them in his service. To etiisct
vs^hich, his outward appearance, when he re-
ceives his catechumens, is of greater force than
any mental contract ; for many wicked men^,
who have denied God and Christ, not only in
their practice, but also bl;jsphemously in pro-
fession, yet have repented, and at last obtamed
some hope of mercy. I dare not say it is im-
possible for a witch to repent, ar:d find mercy;
the secrets of the Almighty are too high for
me ; but it is certain that these wretches are
strangely hardened, by what passes between
them and the devil, in a bodily shape, particu-
larly their worshiping Irim, which necessarily
implies his outward appearance unto them ; for
no man can love evil as evil, because the law of
self-preservation, deeply rooted in all men, de-
tertnineth their will to pursue that which seems
good, and dy from that which seems evil to
tliem; but the inbred notion that every man
has of the devil, is, that he is an rnemv and de-
stroy(!r of mankik.d, tlierefore every man hath
a natural aversion fr- m him, aiid consequently
<jannot formally wouh:j: him as such, because
156 LETTERS OF
the object of worship must be esteemed to be
propitious and placable by the worshipers; oth-
erwise, if fear alone be the adequate cause of
adoration, it follows tliat the devils and damned
in hell do worship God, which is contrary to
scripture, which saith they blasphemed, because
of their pains ; whence it follows, that they
who worship the devil must have changed the
innate idea that they had of him, viz, that he is an
implacable worrier of men, and take him to be
benign at least to his own ; but this change can-
not be wrought by any suggestion of satan into
the minds ot men, whom indeed he mentally
tempteth to lust, pride and malice ; but it is
his greatest artifice to cause his insinuations to
arise in the hearts of men, as their own natural
thouojhts; and if conscience discovers their au-
thor, and opposes them, then he varnishes them
over with the specious colours of pleasure, hon-_
our and glory ; and so represents them as
really good, to be willed and desired by the
soul, which judgeth of all things without agree-
ing to the ideas she hath of them ; but because
most objects have two, and some many, faces^
and she not always attends, therefore she often
errs in her choice ; nevertheless it is impossible
for her to love an object, whose simple idea is
evil ; but the idea we have of the devil is such,
for w'e cannot represent him in our minds any
otherwise than the great destroyer of men,
therefore no mental temptation can make us be-
lieve this our grand efiemy to be ever exorablo
by, or in any measure favourable to us ; whence
it evidently follows, that the devil, to work thi;&
A GENTLEMAN, &c. 151
change of opinion his worshipers have of him,
must appear unto them in a bodily shape, and
impose upon them, whom, because of their great
corruption and sinfuh)ess, God hath wholly left,
and given up to strong delusions, that they should
believe a he, and the father of lies ; who, now
appearing in a human shape, telleth them that
he is not such a monster as he has been repre-
sented to them by his enemy, who calls himself
God, which title of right belongs to him; and
that he (if they contract to be his servants) will
both amply reward them, by giving them power
to do many things very suitable to their abomina-
ble depraved nature, that the christians, what-
ever opinion they may pretend to have of their
God, cannot so much as pretend to, and also that
he will protect and defend them against him,
whom heretofore they have mistaken for the
Almighty, and his pretended Son Christ, whom
they must abjure before they can be received
by or expect any benefit from him. Upon no
other consideration is it possible for any man to
worship the devil ; for the atheists, who deny
the being of a God, do likewise deny the exis-
tence of any spirit good or bad ; therefore their
drinking the devil's health, even upon their
knees (though a most horrid crime) cannot be
construed any part of worship paid to him,
whom they assert to be a chimera, a mere fig-
ment of statesmen to keep the vulgar in awe.
Now I have evinced to you that there arc
witches; that the witch receiveth power from
the devil to do strange things; that there is an
express covenant between the devil and (he
11
158 LETTERS OF
witch; that this covenant cannot be transacted
mentally, but that the devil must appear in a
bodily shape to the witch; therefore I con-
clude, that a witch in the scripture is such, who
has made an explicit covenant with the devil,
and is empowered by him to do things strange in
themselves, and beside their natural course.
II. I persuade myseli'you do not expect from
me any essay concerning the methods how witch-
es may or ought to be convicted; I wish those
gentlemen, whose eminent station both enables
them to perform it, and likew'ise makes it their
duty so to do, may take this province upon them,
and handle it so fully as to satisfy you herein.
I once intended to have provided some materials
for this work, by defining four principal things
relating to witchcraft, viz. 1. Witch-fits. 2. The
imps that are said to attend on the witch. 3. The
transportation ol' the witch through the air.
4. Lastly, the invisibihty of the witch. But up-
on second thought, that it v/as foreign from my
purpose, who am not concerned to compose a
just treatise of witchcraft, which would require
more vacant time than my present circumstan-
ces will allow ; only I proposed to give you my
opinion privately; therefore I Will venture to
make use of an argument, which sheweth neither
art nor learning in the author; and it is this,
That seeing there are witches, and that the law^
of God doth command them to be put to death,
therefore there must be means to convict them,
by clear and certain proof, otherwise the law
were in vain; for no man can be justly condemn-
ed, who ib not fairly convicted bv full and certain
evidence*
A GKNTLEMAN, Lc. 159
III. In the last place we arc to iiifjulre,
nvlietlier a witch ought to be put to death or no?
You answer in tiic negative; because you say
that that law, Thou siialt not sulier a witch to
live, is judicial, and extcndeth only to the peo-
ple of the Jews; but our Saviour, or his apos-
tles, have not delivered any where any such
command, therei'ore they ought to be suH'ered
to live. This indeed seems somewhat plausi-
ble at first view, but upon thorough examina-
tion hath no weight in it at all, lor these rea-
sons, 1. All penal laws receive their sanction
from him or them who have the sovereign
power in any state; as. Thou shalt not commit
■ adultery, is a moral law, and obligatory over the
consciences of men in all places and ages; but
that the adulterers shall be put to death, is a
judicial law, and in force only in that state,
where it is enacted by the sovereign. 2. The
government of the Jews was a theocracy, and
God himself condescended to be their King, not
only as he is King of kings; for in that sense ho
is, always was, and ever will be, supreme Lord
and Governor of all his creatures; but in an es-
pecial manner to give them laws lor the gov-
ernment of their state, and to protect them
against their enemies; in one word, to be im-
mediately their Sovereign. 3. Our Saviour's
kingdom was not of this world; he was no judge
to divide so much as an inheritance between two
brethren ; nay, he himself submitted patiently
to the unjust sentence of the governor of the
country in which he lived; therefore both the
rewards and punishments annexed to his laws
im LETTERS OF
are spiritual, and then shall have their full ac-
complishment, when the Son of Man at the last
day shall pronounce, come unto me ye blessed^ and
depart ye cursed into everlasting fire, 4. That
sovereigns, who have received the gospel of our
Lord, have not therefore lost their power of
enacting laws for the ruling and preserving their
people, and punishing malefactors even with
death; so that the criminal is as justly con-
demned to die by our municipal, as he was here-
tofore by the judicial law among the Jews*
How much more then ought our law to advert
against the highest of all criminals, those exe-
crable men and women, who, though yet alive,
have listed themselves under satan's banner, and
explicitly sworn allegiance to him, to fight
.against God and Christ ! indeed all unholy men
afford great matter to the devils of blasphem-
ing; but these wretches have confederated
themselves Vv^ith the devils, to blaspheme and
destroy all they can. And do you think that
these common enemies of God and mankind
ought to be suffered to live in a christian com-
monwealth ? especially considering that we have
a precedent of putting them to death from God
himself, when he acted as King over his own pe-
culiar people. But methinks I hear you saying,
All this doth not satisfy me, for 1 am sure noth-
ing can be added to the devil's malice ; and if
he could, he certainly would, appear, and fright-
en all men out of their wits. I answer, 1. We
must not reject a truth, because we cannot re-
solve all the questions that may be proposed
about it: otherwise all our science must be
A GENTLEMAN, &c. 161
turned Into scepticism, for we have not a com-
prehensive knowledge of any one thing. —
2. When you say, that if the devil could, he
would appear and frighten all men — the lawful
consequence is, not that he cannot appear at all,
for we have undoubtedly proved the contrary,
but that we are ignorant of the bounds that the
Almighty hath set to him, whose malice in-
deed, if he were not restrained, is so great as to
destroy all men ; but the goodness of our God is
greater, who hath given us means to escape his
fury, if we will give earnest heed to the gospel
of our Saviour, which only is able to comfort us
against the sad and miserable condition of our
present state ; for not only the devils, but llke-
>vise all do conspire against us to work our ruin.
The deluge came and swept away all the race
(save eight persons) of mankind : the fire will
in time devour what the water has left; and all
this Cometh to pass because of sin: but we, who
have received the Lord Jesus, look for new
heavens, and a new earth, wherein dwelleth
righteousness. Therefore he, if we purity our-
selves as he is pure, will save us (for when he
appears we shall be made like unto him, to whom
be glory forever. Amen) from the great de-
struction that must come upon all the world,
and inhabitants thereof. Farewell.
March 8, 1693.
Worthy Sir, ^^^^^^' -^^^^^ 20, 1693.
The great pains you have taken for my infor-
mation and satisfaction in those controverted
14*
I€2 LETTERS OF
points relating to witchcraft, whether it attai«
the end or not, cannot require less than suitable
acknowledgments and gratitude ; especially con-
sidering you had no particular obligation of of-
fice to it, and when others, whose proper pro-
vince it was, had declineci it. It is a great truth,
that the many heresies among the christians
(not the lying miracles, or witchcrafts, used by
some to induce to the worship of images, &;c.)
must not give a mortal wound to Christianity or
truth ; but the great question in these contro-
verted points still is. What is truth? And in
this search, being agreed in the judge or rule,
there is great hopes of the issue. That there
are witches, is plain from that rule of truth, the
scriptures, which commands their punishment
by death. But what that witchcraft is, or
"wherein it does consist, is the whole difficulty.
That head cited from mr. Gaule, and so well
proved thereby (not denied by any) makes the
work yet shorter; so that it is agreed to consist
in a maligning, Sic, and seeking by a sign to se-
duce, *&;c. not excluding any other sorts or
branches, when as well proved by that infallible
rule. That good angels have appeared, is cer-
tain; though that instance of those to Abraham
may admit of a various construction; some di-
vines supposing them to be the Trinity; others,
that they were men-messengers, as Judges ii. 1 ;
and others, that they were angels. But though
this, as I said, might admit of a debate, yet 1
see no question of the angel Gabriel's appear-
ance, particularly to the blessed virgin; for
though the angels are spirits, and so not per*
A GENTLEMAN, &c. icn
ceptible by our bodily eyes without the appoint-
ment of the Most itJioh, yet lie, who made all
things by his word in the creation, can with a
word speak tilings into being. And whether the
angels did assume matter (or a vehicle) and by
that appear to the bodily eye; or whether by
the same word there were an idea framed in
the mind, which needed no vehicle to represent
them to the intellects, is with the All-wise, and
not lor me to dispute. If we poor shallow mor-
tals do not comprehend the manner hc-w, that
argues only our weakness. Two other times
did this glorious angel appear. Dan. viii. 16.
Dan, ix. 21. The fust of these times was in vi-
sion, as by the text and context will appear.
The second was the same as the first; which,
being considered as it will, ascertains that angels
have appeared, so that it is at the will of the
sender how they shall appear, whether to the
bodily eye, or intellect only. MatL i. 20. The
appearance of the angel to Joseph was in a
dream, and yet a real appearance; so was there
a real appearance to the apostle, but whether
in the body or out of the body he could not
tell; and that tliey are sent, and come not of
their own motion. Luke i. 26, ^nd in the sixth
month the an^rcl Gabriel was sent from God, Dan.
ix. 23, Jit the beginning of thy supplication the
comniandnient cameforth^ and I am come. v. 21,
Being caused to fly swifly^ iyc. But Irom these
places may be set down, as undoubted truths or
conclusions,
1. That the glorious angels have their mis-
sion and commission Irom the Most High.
164 - LETTERS OF
2. That without this they cannot appear to
mankind. And from these two will necessarily
flow a third :
3. That if the glorious angels have not that
power to go till commissioned, or to appear to
mortals, then not the fallen angels; who are
held in chains of darkness to the judgment of
the great day. Therefore to argue, that be-
cause the good angels have appeared, the evii
may or can, is to me as if, because the dead
have been raised to life by holy prophets,
therefore men, wicked men, can raise the dead.
As the sufferings, so the temptations, of our Sa-
viour were (in degree) beyond those common
to man. He being the second Adam, or public
head, the strongest assaults were now improved ;
and we read that he was tempted, that he
might be able to succour them that are tempt-
ed; as also that he was led of the Spirit into
the wilderness, that he might be tempted, &c.
But how the tempter appeared to him who was
God Omniscient; whetlier to the bodily eye, or
to the intellect, is as far beyond my cognizance^
a§ for a blind man to judge of colours. But
from the whole set down this fourth conclusion :
4. That when the Almighty Free Agent has
a work to bring about for his own glory, or
man's good, he can employ not only blessed an-
gels, but the evil ones, in it, as 2 Cor, xii. 7, ^.^nd
lest I should he exalted above iwas^ire, there was
given to me a thorn in the flf'sh^ the messenger of
sat an to buffet me. 1 Sam. xvi. 14, 15 k, 23, ^n
evil spirit from the Lord troubled him^ &:c. It is a
,great truih, that we understand little, very lit*
A GENTLEMAN, kc. 166
tie, and that in common things; liow much less
then in spirituals, such as are above human cog-
nizance! But though upon the strictest scruti-
ny in some natural things we can only discover
our ignorance, yet we must not hence deny
what we do know, or suiFer a rape to be com-
mitted upon our reason and senses in the dark.
And to say that the devil by his ordinary power
can act a vehicle, i. e. some matter distinct Irom
himseir, who is wholly a spirit, and yet this mat-
ter not to be I'elt nor heard, and at the same,
time to be seen; or may be felt, and not heard,
nor seen, &;c. seems to me to be a ciiimera, in-
vented at firsi to puzzle the belief of reasonable
creatures, and since calculated to a roman lati-
tude, to uphold the doctrine of transubstantia-
tion; who teacli, that under the accidents of
bread is contained the body of our Saviour, his
human body, as long, and as broad, &c. for here
the power of the Almighty must not be con-
fined to be less than the devil's, and it is he that
has said, hoc est meum corpus. As to the con-
sent of almost all ages, I meddle not now with
it, but come to the fifth conclusion:
5. That when the Divine Being v/ill employ
the agency of evil spirits for any service, it is
with him to determine how they shall exhibit
themselves, whether to the bodily eye, or intel-
lect only; and whether it shall be more or less
formidable. To deny these three last, were to
n^ake the devil an independent power, and con-
sequently a God. As to the nature of posses-
sions by evil spirits, for the better understanding
of it, it may be needful to compare it with its
156 LETTERS OF
contraries ; and to instance in Samson, of vvhon^
it was foretold, that he should begin to deliver
Israel. And how was he enabled to this work?
Judges xiii. S5, The spirit of the Lord began
to move him at times in the camp^ Szc. Chap. xv.
13, 14. V, Add they bound him with two new
cords^ and brought him up from the rock; and
when they came to Lehi, the Phifistines shouted
against him. ; and the spirit of the Lord came
might il if upon hini^ and the cords that were upon
his arms became as flax, that icas burnt with fire,
and his bands loosed frtfnt his hands^ &c. I might
instance further; but this may suffice to show
that he had more than a natural strength, as al-
so wiience his strength was, viz. he Avas empow-
ered by the spirit from God. And now will any
say, that it was not Samson, but the spirit, that
did these things; or, that these being things
done, bonds broken, &:c. by a force that could
not proceed from human strength, that there-
fore the spirit entered into him otherwise
qualified than as a mere spirit; or, that the spi-
rit entered not without some portion of matter,
and by the intermediation thereof acted Sam-
son's body? If any say this and more too, this
doth not alter the truth, which remains, viz.
that the spirit of God did enable Samson to the
doing of things beyond his natural strength. And
now what remains but, upon parity of reason, to
apply this to the case of possession ? which may
be summed up in this sixth conclusion:
6. That God, for wise ends, only known to
himself, may and has empowered deviis to pos-
sess and strangely to actuate human bodies, even
A GENTLEMAN-, kc. 167
to the doliitT; of things beyond the natural
strength ol' that body. And lor any to tell ola
vehicle, or matter used in it, I must observe that
general rule, Coloss. ii. u, *' Beware lest any
spoil you through philosophy, and vain deceit,
alter the tradition of men, alter the rudiments
of the world, and not after Christ." To come
next to that of witciicraft, and here taking that
cited head of mr. Gauleto be uncontroverted,
set it as a seventh conclusion:
7. That witchcraft consists in a maligning and
opposing the word, wp^*]fc and worship of God,
and seeking by any extraordinary sign to seduce
any from it. Dent. xiii. 12. Matt, \\\v. 24.
Acts xiii. 8, 10. 2 Tinu iii. 8. Do but mark well
the places; and for tliis very property of thus
opposing and perverting, they are all there con-
cluded afrant and absolute witches; and it will
be easily granted, that tiie same that is called
witch, is called a false Christ, a false prophet,
and a sorcerer, and that the terms are synoni-
mous ; and that what the witches aim at is, to
seduce the people to seek after other gods.
But here the question will be, whether the
witch really do things strange in themselves,
and beyond their natural course, and all this by
a power immediately from the devil. In this
inquiry, as we have nothing to do with unwrit-
ten verities, so but little with cabalistic learning,
which might perhaps but lead us more astray;
as in the instance of their charging our Saviour
with casting out devils by Beelzebub; his an-
swer is, if satan be divicled against himselli \m
kingdom hath an end. But seeing «Il are agreed,
.sei this eighth conclusion :
168 LETTERS OF
8. That God will not give his testimony to a
lie. To say that God did at any time empower
a witch to work wonders, to gain behef to the
doctrine of devils, were w^ith one breath to de-
stroy the root and branch of all revealed reli-
gion. And hence it is clear the witch has no
such wonder-working power from God. And
must we then conclude she has such a miracu-
lous power from the devil? If so, then it follows,
that either God gives the devil leave to empow-
er the witch to make use of this seal, in order
to deceive, or else that the devil has this power
independent of himself. To assert the first of
these were in etfect to say, that though God
will not give his testimony to a lie, yet that he
may empower the devil to set to it God's own
seal, in order to deceive. And what were this
but to overthrow all revealed religion? The
last, if asserted, must be to own the devil to be
an unconquered enemy, and consequently a sov-
ereign deity, and deserving much thanks, that
he exerts his power no more. Therefore in
this dilemaia it is wisdom for shallow mortals to
have recourse to their only guide, and impar-
tially to inquire, whether the witches really
have such a miraculous or wonder-working
power. And it is remarkable that the apostle,
GaL V. 20, reckons up witchcraft among the
works of the flesh; which were it indeed a
wonder-working power, received immediately
from the devil, and wholly beyond the power
of nature, it were very improper to place it
with drunkenness, murthers, adulteries, &c. all
manifest fleshly works. 'Tis also remarkable^
A GKNTLKMAN, &c. 169
that witchcrai't Is generally in scrinfurc joined
with spiiitual whurcdoin, i. e. idolatry. This
thence will plainly appear to be the same; only
pretending to a sign, in order to deceive, seems
to be yet a I'lirther degree ; and in this sense
Manasseh and Jezebel, 2 Chroiu xxxiii. 6 ;
2 Kin<rs ix. 22, used witchcraft and whcredcms.
JVahiim iii. 4, the idolatrous city is called mis-
tress of witchcrafts. But to instance in one
place instead of many, 2 Thcss. ii. 3 to 12, par-
ticularly 9 and 10 v. Even him^ ivhose coming is
after the ivorking of satan, ivitli all power and
signs, and lying wonders, and with all deceivable-
ness. And for this cause God shall send them
strong delusions that they should believe a lie, that
they all might be damned, who believed not the
truth, (St. This that then was spoken in the
prophecy of that man of sin, that was to appear,
how abundantly does history testify the iuUil-
ment of it, particularly to seduce to the worship
of images! Have not the images been made to
move, to smile, &c. ? Too tedious were it to
mention the hundredth part of what undoubted
history doth abundantly testify. And hence do
set down this ninth conclusion:
9. That the man of sin, or seducer, &c. makes
use of lying wonders to the end to deceive, and
that God in righteous judgment may send strong
delusions that they should believe a lie, that they
might be damned, who believe not the truth, &c.
'Tis certain that the devil is a proud being,
and would be thought to have a power equal to
the Almighty; and it cannot but be very grate-
ful to him to see mortals charpiriir one anotlier
170 LETTERS OF
with doing such works by the devil's power, as
in truth is the proper prerogative of the Almigh-
ty, Omnipotent Being. The next head should
have been about an explicit covenant between
the witch and the devil, <fcc. But in this, the
v/holc of it, I cannot persuade myself but you
must be sensible of an apparent leaning to edu-
cation (or tradition) the scriptures being wholly
silent on it; and supposing this to fall in as a de-
pendent on what went, be fore, I shall say the
less to it; for if the devil has no such power to
communicate upon such compact, then the whole
is a fiction; though I cannot but acknowledge
you have said so much to uphold that doctrine,
that I know not how any could have done more.
However, as I said, I iind not myself engaged
(unless scripture proof were cifered) to meddle
with it : for as you have in such cases your rea-
son for your guide, so I must be allowed to use
that little that I have, and do only say, that as
God is a spirit, so he must be worshiped in spi-
rit and in trutlj ; so also that the devil is a spirit,
and that his rule is in the hearts of the children
of disobedience, and that an explicit covenant of
one nature or another can have little force, any
further than as the heart is engaged in it. And
so I pass to the last, viz. whether a •.vlich ought
to be put to death; and without accumulation
of the offence do judge, that where the law of
any country is to punish by death such as seduce
and tempt to the worship of strange gods (or
idols, or statues) by as good authority may they,
no doubt, punish these as capital offenders, who
are distinguished by that one remove, viz. to
OENTLEMAY, kc. 171
tlieir seducing Is added a sign, i. c. they pretend
to a sign in order to seduce. And thus, worthy
sir, I have i'reely given you my thoughts uj)on
yours, which you so much obhged me with the
sight oi"; and upon the whole, though I cannot
in tlic general but commend your caution in not
asserting many things contended for by others,
yet must say, that in my esteem there is retain-
ed so mucli as will secure all the rest : (to in-
stance) if a spirit has a vehicle, i. e. some j)ortion
of matter which it acts. Sic. hence as necessarily
may be inferred that doctrine of incubus and sue-
cubus, and why not that also of procreation by
spirits both good and bad? Thus was Alexan-
der the Great, the British Merlin, and Martin
Luther, and many others, said to be begotten.
Again, if the witch had such a wonder-working
power, why not to aflllct ? Will not the devil
thus far gratify her? And have none this mi-
raculous power, but the covenanting witch?
Then the offence lies in the covenant; then it is
not only hard, but impossible, to find a witch by
such evidence as the law of God requires; for it
will not be supposed that they call witness to
this covenant; therefore it will here be neces-
sary to admit of such as the nature of such co-
venant will bear (as Mr. Gaule hath it in his
(ifth head, i. e.) the testimony of the afflicted,
with their s|)ectral sight, to tell who afflicts
themselves or others; the experiment of saying
the Lord's prayer, falling at the sight, and rising
at the touch, searching for teats, (i. e. excrescen-
ces of nature) strange and foreign stories of the
death of some cattle, or oversetting some carf.
172 LETTERS OF
And what can juries have better to guide them
to find out this covenant by?
It is matter of lamentation, and let it be for
a lamentation, to consider how these things have
opened the floodgates of malice, revenge, un-
charitableness and bloodshed, and what multi-
tudes have bsen swept away by this torrent.
In Germany^ countries depopulated; in Scot-
land^ no less than 4000 are said to have suf-
fered by fire and halter at one heat.
Thus we may say with the prophet, Isa, lix.
10, We grope for the wall like the blind, and ive
grope as if we had no eyes : ice stumble at noon-
day as in the night, ice are in desolate places as
dead men: and this by seeking to be wise above
what is written, in framing to ourselves such
crimes and such ordeals (or ways of trial) as are
wholly foreign from the direction of our only
guide, which should be a light to our hei, and
a lanthorn to our paths ; but instead of this, if
we have not followed the direction, we have
followed the example, of pagan and papal Rome,
thereby rendering us contemptible and base be-
fore all people, according as we have not kept
his ways, but have been partial in his lawc
And now, that we may, in all our sentiments
and ways, have regard to his testimonies, and give
to the Almighty the glory due to his name, is the
earnest desire and prayer of, sir, yours to com-
mand, R. C.
Sir,
Since your design of giving copies of our pa-
pers, if not to the public, at least out of your
A GENTLEMAN, 6ic. 17o
hands, I find myself obliged to make a reply to
your answer, lest silence should be construed an
assent to the positions whereby, 1 think, truth
^vould be scandalized.
I remember that some have taught that it is
not certain there is any such thing really in be-
ing as matter ; because the ideas which w^e
have of our own and all other bodies may be
caused to arise in us by God, without the real
existence of the objects they represent. But
this opinion is not only absurd and false, but
hkewise atheistical, destroying the veracity of
the Almighty, Avhom it asserts to have determ-
ined us by a fatal necessity to believe things to
be, which are not; and 1 wonder that you
should allude unto it, because that angels have
appeared in a dream, in a vision; for we dream
also of trees, birds, kc. Are there therefore
no such things in naiure, because we sometimes
dream to see and hear them, when we are
asleep? St. Paul in his vision was so far from
believing the objects that were represented to
hmi to come by the intermedium of his senses,
that he declares, he does not know whether he
was in the body or out of the body; therefore
the instance is in no wise })roper. For Abra-
ham and the Blessed Virgin did see and hear;
and if there were not such things really, as were
represented to them by their senses, they were
deluded, by being made to believe they saw and
heard what was not. There is none who deni-
eth God causeth thoughts to arise in men's
minds; but thence to infer he maketh objects
which are not, by forming their ideas in cm*'
15*
174 LETTERS OF
minds, to appear to us through the ministry of^
our senses as though they were, is a piece not
only of vain, but very dangerous, philosophy.
It is true, the good angels will not appear
without the appointment of God ; they will not
do any one action, but according to the laws he
has prescribed to them. But you say they can-
not, (which does not follow from your premises)
supposing their not appearing to proceed from
the defect of their power, and not the rectitude
of their will ; which fallacy has deceived you in-
to a third conclusion: for the fallen angels are
not so held under chains of darkness, but that
they can, and do, go to and fro on the earth,
seeking whom they may devour. Before their
fall they could have appeared if sent, and would
not then do any thing without a divine command ;
but now they have rebelled against God, and do
all they can to despite him; therefore then' not
appearing now (if it were true they never did,
they never shall, appear) must proceed from a
restraint they are under, which is accidental,
not essential to their nature; so that the true
conclusion is, the fallen angels, while they are
under forcible restraint from God to the contra-
ry, cannot appear. But what thi^ (being clear-
ed from the ambiguity you express it in) maketh
to the purpose, I know not, unless God had
promised for a determinate lime to detain them
under this restraint.
I do not understand what you intend by the
dead being raised by holy men; the most natu-
ral inference is, that, in imitation of them, wick-
<!*d raen^ by their enchantments calling on a da?-
A GENTLEMAN, .^e. 175
iiion to appear In the shape of the dead, will
|Heteiid that they also can raise tlic dead.
The Romanists are much obhged to you for
making transubstantiation (so much contended
for by them) to be of as old a date as the ap-
pearance of devils, and that the one implieth no
more contradiction than tlie other : if so, we do
well to think seriously whether we are not guil-
ty of great sin in separating from them; for
certainly whatever private men's notions in this
age may be, yet it is matter of great moment,
that all antiquity (the sadducees, the elder
brethren of our Hobbists, excepted) liath be-
lieved the appearance of evil spirits and their
delusions.
I should be too officious if I offered to explain
how matter, real matter, may fall under the cog-
nisance of one of our senses, and not the rest. It
is for you to shew the impossibility thereof, if you
will build any thing upon your assertion; to
prove which, your first argument is (it seems to
me) a chimera; which is not enough, when
there are many to whom it seems to be a truth.
Your second is very dangerous, and highly de-
rogatory of the honour of God, between whom
and the devil you make comparison more than
once, as the power of the Almighty must not be
considered to be less than the devil's. And again,
to deny these three last were to make the de-
vil an independent powei'. and consequently a
God. These expressions (which cannot but be
very pleasing to the devil, who vainly boasts
himself to be a being without dependence) arc
altogether groundless, and very unmeet to pro-
176 LETTERS OF
ceed from a christian. Consider what you are
doino- ; to estabhsh a doctrine (the contrary
Avhereot'the greatest part of mankind does be-
lieve) you run upon such precipices, as, if you
are mistaken, (and that is not impossible) must
totally destroy all religion, natural and revealed ;
for suppose it were generally believed, accord-
ino- to you, that the devil cannot appear, because
if he could he must be a God, independent, an
unconquered enemy, and he doth appear to us
as we hear he hath to multitudes, both of the
past and present ages ; in such a case what re-
mains for us to do, but to fall down and worship
him?
Upon the head of possession, you have re-
course to that instance of Samson, who was em-
powered by God to the doing of things beyond
the natural strength of common men; and thence
you say, we may at least learn the nature of
possession by evil spirits. This comparison is
indeed very odious, and I had rather think you
have fallen into it unawares; for what greater
blasphemy, than that God and the devil do act
the bodies, which the one and tiie other do pos-
sess, in the same manner? If the hypothesis I
laid down had not pleased you, yet you ought
not (for fear of being deceived by vain philoso-
phy) to have run to so horrible an extreme, as
to assimilate God's manner of working to the
devil's, which necessarily implies, that either
their powers are equal, or at least that they do
not dilier in kind, but in degree only ; than which
nothing c^^n be more impious or absurd: i'or the
most possible perfect creature is infinitely distant
A GENTLEMAN, &c
from the Creator, and there can be no compar-
ison between them.
On the head of witchcraft, you acknowledge
the witch has not his wonder-working power
from G.)d; but then you say, the devil has no
such power to give; for if he had, lie must be
. This way of reasoning, as I noted belbre,
is very dangerous, and I think ought not to be
used ; besides, there is a great fallacy in your
dilemma ; which, because I perceive you lay the
whole weight of the matter upon it, 1 will evince
unto you. The devil, though superlatively arro-
gant and proud, nevertheless depends on the
First Cause for his being, and all his powers,
without whose influx he or any other creature
cannot subsist a moment, but must either return
to their primitive nothing, or be continually
preserved by the same power, by the whicii
they were at first produced; therefore the being
and powers of all creatures (because they imme-
diately flow from God) are good, and conse-
quently the simple actions, as they proceed
from those powers, are in their own nature like-
wise good, the evil proceeding only from the
rebellious will of the creature; wherefore it is
no paradox, but a certain tiuth, that the same
action in respect of the first cause is good, but
in respect of the second is evil; for instance, the
act of copulation is in itself good, instituted by
God, and may be explicitly willed and df sired
by the soul, which sinneth not lor exerting the
simple act, but for exerting it contrary to
the laws prescribed by God : as in wedlock
and adultery there is the same special natii^
173 LETTERS OF
ral action, which, considered simply, as Agw
ing from a power given to man by God, h
certainly good; but considered with relation to
the rebellious will of the adulterer (who iieth
with his neighbour's wife, whom he is for-
bid to touch) is a very great evil. Wc may
say the same of all human actions; the execu-
tioner and the murtherer do the same natural
act of striking and killing: the diiference con-
sists in the rectitude of the one's, and deprava-
tion of the other's, will. These things premised,
what more reason have we to conclude tliat the
devil (because he shews signs and wonders to
gain belief to lies, which is very contrary to the
Avill of God) must be therefore an independent-
power, than that the adulterer, the murtherer,
or any other sinner (because their actions being
evil, of which God cannot be the cause) must be
independent beings? The deceit of the last is
very palpable, and I doubt not but you will rea-
dily acknov^'ledge it; for it is obvious from what
has been said, to the meanest capacity, to dis-
tinguish between the action itself, which is good,
and flows I'rom God, and the circumstances of
the action, the choice w^hereof proceeds from
the iniquity of the will, wherein doth solely con-
sist the sin; the parallel is so exact, that I can-
not see the least shadow ol' reason, why we
ouffht not in like manner todistino^uish whatever
effect is produced by the devil; to whom (as to
man) God, havmg given powers, and a will to
rule those powers, is truly and properly the
cause of all the actions (in a natural, but not
moral sense) that flow from the powers he has
A GENTLEMAN. «.( J7S
given. Tlicrcfore the wonder-working power
of the devil, and the edects thereof, considered
as acts of one of God's creatures, are not evil
but good ; the using that power (wliich pro-
ceeds froQi tide rebelhon of satan) to bear testi-
mony to a he, is that one, which constitutes
the evil theicoi".
And now 1 have done with your argument,
wherein you have indeed shewn great skill and
dexterity in turning to your advantage what, be-
ing fairly stated, makes against you, as the ap-
pearance of angels, <S:c. observing nicely the
rules of pirt, and particularly that grand one of
concealing, nay dissembling, the sauie art; as
Avhen you quote that scripture coucerning vain
philosophy (of which, though altogether foreign
i'rom the matter in iiand, yet) you intend to
serve yourself with the unthinking, who mea-
sure the sense of words by their jingle, not
knowing how to weigli the things they signify;
and truly herein your end is very artificial : for
you intend both to throw dirt at them that dif-
fer from you, and at the same time to cover
yourself with such a subtle web, through which
you may see, and not be seen. What Ibllon s is
rather a rhetorical lecture, such as the patriots
of sects (who commonly ex})l'ain the holy scrip-
tures according to their own dogmas, and so ob-
trude human invention for the pure word of
God) use with their auditors, to recommend any
principle they have a mind to establish, than an
impartial and thorough disquisition of a contro-
verted point ; wherefore 1 do not tliink mysell'
obliged to take aijy inrthcr notice of it :. espc-
180 LETTERS OF
cially seeing truth, which for the most part is
little regarded in such florid discourses, and not
anj prejudice of education, interest or parly, did
set me about this subject. I have never been
used to coinpHment in points of controversy,
therefore 1 hope you will not be angry because
1 have given you my thoughts naked and plain.
1 have not the least motion in my mind of accus-
ing you of any formal design to injure religion:
I only observe unto you, that your over eager
contention to maintain your principle has hurried
you to assert many things of much greater dan-
ger, both in themselves and their consequences,
than those you would seem to avoid; which do
amount to no more than that men, being (in the
ordinary course of providence) the depositories
of both divine and human laws, may (instead of
using them to preserve) pervert them to de-
stroy; which indeed is very lamentable. But
it is the inevitable consequent of our depraved
nature, and cannot be wholly remedied, till sin,
and the grand author of sin, the devil, be entire-
ly conquered, and God be all in all; to whom,
with the Son, and Holy Ghost, be glory for ever,
Amen.
Sir, your affectionate friend to serve you.
Boston, July 2b, 1694.
jrr 7 o- Boston. Jlumist 17, 1694.
Worthy Sir, ' * '
Yours of July 25 being in some sort surpris-
ing to me, I could do no less than say somewhat,
as well to vindicate myself I'rom those many re-
flections, mistakes and hard censures therein, as
A GENTLEMAN, &c. 181
also to vindicate what I conceive to be impor-
tant truth ; and to that end find it needful to re-
peat some part ol' mine, viz. conclusion
1. That the glorious angels have their mis-
sion and commission from the Most Hlo^h.
2. That without this they cannot appear to
mankind.
3. That if the glorious angels have not that
power to go till commissioned, or to appear to
mortals, then not the fallen angels, who are held
in chains of darkness to the judgment of the
great day.
4. That when the Almighty Free Agent has
a work to briiig about for his own glory, or man's
good, he can employ not only the blessed angels,
but evil ones, in it.
5. That when the Divine Being will employ
the agency of evil spirits for any service, it is
with him the manner how they shall exhibit
themselves, whether to the bodily eye, or intel-
lect only, or whether it shall be more or less
formidable.
To deny these three last, were to make the
devil an independent power, and consequently a
God.
The bare recital of these Is sufficient to vin-
dicate me I'rom that reiterated charge, of deny-
ing all appearances oi* angels or devils.
That the good angels cannot appear without
mission and commission from the Most High, is,
you say, more than follows from the premises;
but if you like not such negative deduction,
though so natural, it concerns you (if you will
assert this power to be in their natures, and tiieir
16
182 LETTERS OF
non-appearance only to proceed from the recti-
tude of their wills, and that without such com-
mission they have a power to appear to mortals,
and upon this to build so prodigious a structure,
&c.) very clearly to prove it H^ scripture; for
christians have good reason to taKe the apostle's
warning (if some philosophers have taught that
man is nothing but matter, and others that 'tis
not certain there is any matter at all) to take heed
lest theij should be spoiled through vain philosO'
phv^ &c. but that this should be alluded to such
as never heard of either notion, or that it was
asserted that those real appearances to Joseph,
and to the apostle, were through the ministry of
the senses, is as vam as such philosophy. As to
the dead being raised, had I used art or rheto-
rick enough (o explain my meaning to you, I
needed not now to rejoin, — that 'tis as good an
argument to say, that because holy prophets
have raised the dead, therefore wicked men have
a power to raise the dead, as 'tis to say, because
good angels have appeared, therefore the evil
have a power to appear; for who can doubt,
but if the Almighty shall commission a wicked
man to it, he also shall raise the dead ? as is in-
timated. Matt. vii. 22, ^nd in thy name done ma-
mj wonderful vorks. As to comi^jarisons being
odious, particularly that concerning Samson, I
think it neecli'ul here to add rhese scriptures fur-
ther to cotifirm the fourth conclusion. 2 Sam.
xxiv. 1, compared with 1 Chron. xxi. 1. In one
'tis God movcd^ &c. and in tlie other Satan pro-
voked David to number the people. 2 Chron.
xviii. 21, Jind the Lord said, thou shall entice him^
A GENTLEMAN, &c. 13^
and thou shah also prevail ; go out anil do even so ;
all wliich, with many more that mi^ht be pro-
duced, will shew the truth ol' the conclu-
sion; so that 'tis no odious comparison to say,
that as the Almighty can make use of good, so
also ot" evil spirits, tor the accomplishing ol' his
own wise ends, and can empower either with-
out the help of a vehicle: for possessions must
be numbered among God's afflictive dispensa-
tions, who also orders all the circumstances
thereoil But if any object, God is not the au-
thor of evil, &;c. you have furnished me with a
very learned answer, by distinguishing between
the act, and the evil of the act, and to which
'tis adapt, but will no wise suit where it is pla-
ced, till it be fu'st proved that the devil hath of
himself such power not only ol' appearing at
pleasure, but of working miracles, and to the
Almighty reserved only the power of restrain-
ing; iov, till this be proved, the dilemma must
remain stable. He that asserts, that because
good angels have appeared, tlierefore the fallen
angels have a power of themselves to appear
to mortals, and that they cannot be employed
by the Almighty, nor that he does not order the
manner and circumstances of such appearance,
what doth he less than make the devil an inde-
pendent power, and consequently a God ? So
he that asserts that the devil hath a power of
himself, and independent, to work wonders, and
miracles, and to empower witches to do like in
order to deceive, &ic. what doth he less than
own him to be an unconquered enemy, and conse-
quently a sovereign deity ? and who is he that
184 LETTERS OF
is culpable ? he that ascribes such attributes to
the evil one, or he that asserts that the so doing
gives him (or ascribes to him) such power as is
the prerogative of him only who is almighty?
And here, sir, it highly concerns you to consider
your foundations, what proof from scripture is
to be found for your assertions, and who it is
you are contending for: for hitherto nothing
like a proof hath been offered from scripture,
which abounds so with the contrary, that he
that runs may read ; as. Shall there he evil in the
city, and the Lord hath not done it ? Who is he
that saith, and it cometh to pass, when the Lord
comniandeth not ? Who among the gods of the hea-
then (of which the devil is one) can give rain ? &;c.
But I shall not be tedious in multiplying proofs,
to that which all seem to own. For as to that
stale plea of universality, do say that I have
read of one, if not several, general councils, that
have not only disapproved, but anathematised
them that have ascribed such powers to the de-
vils. And several national protestant churches
at this day, in their exhortations before the sa^
crament (among other enormous crimes) admo-
nish all that believe any such power in the
witch, &c. to withdraw, as unmeet to partake
at the Lord's table.
And I believe christians in general, if they
were asked, would own that what powers the
devil may at any time have to appear, to afflict,
destroy, or cause tempests, (fee must be by pow-
er or commission from the Sovereign Being;
and that, having such a commission, not only
hail, but frogs, lice, or fleas, shall be empower-
A GENTLEMAN, &c. 105
ed to plague a great king and kingdom. And if
so, this sandy structure of the devil's appearance,
and working wonders, at pleasure, and of em-
powering witches to afflict, &:c. (for to this nar-
row crisis is that whole doctrine reduced) the
whole disappears at the first shaking.
Thus, worthy sir, I have given you my senti-
ments, and the grounds thereof, as plainly and
as concise as 1 was able; though 'tis indeed a
subject that calls for the ablest pens to discuss,
acknowledging myself to be insufficient for these
things. However, I think I have done but my
duty, for the glory of God, the sovereign being;
and have purposely avoided such a reply as
some parts of yours required; and pray that
not only you and I, but all mankind, may give
to the Almighty the glory due unto his nam^.
From, sir, yours to command, R. C.
Witchcraft is manijeatly a tvork ofthejlesh.
16*
189
PART V.
AN IMPARTIAL ACCOUNT
OF THE MOST MEMORABLE
MATTERS OF FACT,
TOUCHING THE SUPrOSED WITCHCRAFT IN KEVV-ENGLAND.
J-tXR. PARRIS had been some years a mi-
nister in Salem Village, when this sad calamity,
as a deluge, overflowed them, spreading itself
far and near. He was a gentleman of liberal
education; and, not meeting with any great en-
couragement, or advantage, in merchandising,
to which for some time he applred himself, be-
took himself to the w^ork of the ministry; this
Village being then vacant, hq met with so much
encouragement, as to settle in that capacity
amons: them.
After he had been there about two years, he
obtained a grant from a part of the town, that
the house and land he occupied, and which had
been allotted by the whole people to the min-
istry, should be and remain to him, (fee. as his
own estate in fee simple. This occasioned great
divisions both between the inhabitants them-
MATTERS
selves, and between a considerable part of them
and their said minister; which divisions were
but as a beginning, or prelude, to what immedi*
ately followed.
It was the latter end o{' February, 1691, when
V divers young persons belonging to mr. Parris's
^ family, and one or more of the neiglibourhood,
began to act alter a strange and unusual manner,
viz. as by getting into holes, and creeping un-
der chairs and stools, and to use sundry odd pos-
tures and antick gestures, uttering foolish, ri-
diculous speeches, which neither they them-
selves nor any others could make sense of.
The physicians that were called could assign no
reason for this; but it seems one of them, hav-
ing recourse to the old shift, told them, he
was afraid they were bevvitched. Upon such
suggestions, they that were concerned applied
themselves to lasting and prayer, which w^as at-
tended not only in their own private families,
but with calling in the help of others. March
the ll/A, mr. Parris invited several neighbour-
ing ministers to join with him in keeping a so-
lenm day of prayer at his own house. The
time of the exercise, those persons were for the
most part silent; but after any one prayer was
ended, they would act and speak strangely and
ridiculously; yet were such as had been well
educated, and of good behaviour; the one, a girl
of 11 or 12 years old, would sometimes seem to
be in a convulsion fit, her limbs bong twisted
several ways, and very stiti", but presently her
fit would be over.
A few days before this solemn day of prayer.
OF FACT, kc. 189
mr. Parris's Indian man and woman made a
cake ol" rye meal, with tlie children's water, and
baked it in the ashes, and, as is said, gave it
to the dog; this was done as a means to disco-
ver witchcraft ; soon after which, those ill af-
fected or afflicted persons named several that
they said they saw, when in their fits, afflicting
them.
The first complained of was the said Indian
woman, named Tituba: she confessed that the
devil urged her to sign a book, which he pre*
sented to her, and also to work mischief to the
children, &:c. She was afterwards committed
to prison, and lay there till sold for her fees.
Tiie account she since gives of it is, that her
master did beat her, and otherways abuse her,
to make her confess and accuse (such as he
called) her sister-witches; and that whatsoever
she said by way of confessing, or accusing oth-
ers, was the elFect of such usage; her master
refused to pay her fees, unless she would stand
to what she had said.
The children complained likewise of two oth-
er women, to be the authors of their hurt, viz.
Sarah Good, who had long been counted a me-
Jancholy or distracted woman ; and one Osborn,
an old bed-ridden woman; which two were per-
sons so ill thought of, that the accusation was
the more readily believed; and, after examina-
tion before two Salem magistrates, were com-
mitted. March 9th, mr. Lowson (who had
been formerly a preacher at the said village)
came thither, and hath since set forth, in print,
an account of wjjat then passed; about which
190 MATTERS
time, as he saith, thej complained of goodwife
Corj, and goodwife Nurse, members of church-
es at the Village and at Salem, many others be-
ing by that time accused.
March 21. Goodwife Cory was examined be-
fore the magistrates of Salem, at the meeting
house in the Village, a throng of spectators being
present to see the novelty. Mr. Noyes, one of
\tiie miiiislGrs of Salem, began with prayer; after
which ihc prisoiier being called, in order to an-
swer to what should be alledged against her,
she desired that she might go to prayer; and
w-as answered by the magistrates, that they did
not come to hear her pray, but to examine her.
The number of the afflicted w^ere at that
time about ten, viz. mrs. Pope, mrs. Putman,
goodwife Bibber and goodwife Goodall, Mary
VVolcott, Mercy Lewes (at Thomas Putman's)
and Dr, Grigg's maid, and thvce girls, viz, Ehza-
beth Parris, daughter to the minister, Abigail
Williams, his niece, and Ann Putman; which
last three were not only the beginners, but were
also the chief, in these accusations. These ten
were most of them present at the examination,
and did vehemently accuse her of afflicting them,
by biting, pincliing, strangling, <kc. and they said
they did in their fits see her likeness coming to
them, and bringing a book for them to sign.
Mr. Hathorn, a magistrate of Salem, asked her
\Yhy she afflicted those children. She said, she
did not afflict them. He asked her who did
then. She said, 1 do not know, how should I
know? She said, they were poor distracted
creatures, and no heed ought to be given ta
OF FACT, kc. 191
what thej said. Mr. Ilalhs-n and nir. Noycs
replied that it was (he jiid^jjrnciit of" all that
were there present, tliat they were bewitched,
and only she (the accused) said they were dis-
tracted. Siie was accuse^I hy tliem, that the
black man wliispered to her in her ear now^
(while she was upon examination) and that she
had a yellow bird, that did use to suck between
lier finders, and that the said bird did suck now
in the assembly. Order being given to look in
that place to see il' there were any sign, the
girl that pretended to see it said, that it was too
late now, for she had removed a pin, and put it
on her head ; it was upon search found, that a
pin was there sticking upright. When the ac-
cused had any motion of their body, hands or
mouth, the accusers wx)uld cry out ; as when
she bit a lip, they would cry out of being bitten;
if she grasped one hand with the other, they
would cry out of being pinched by her, and
would produce marks; so of the other motions
of her body, as comj)laining of being prest, when
she leaned to the seat next her; if she stirred
her feet, they would stamp, and cry out of pain
there. After the hearing, the said Cory was
committed to Salem prison, and then their cry-
ing out of her abated.
J^la-xh 24, goodwife Nurse was brought be-
fore mr. Hathorn and mr. Curwii) (magistrates) \/
in the meeting house. Mr. Hale, minister of
Beverly, began with prayer; alter which she,
being nccused of much the same crimes, made
the like answers, asserting her own innocence
with earnestness. Tiie accusers were mostly the
192 MATTERS
same, Thomas Putman's wife, &c. complaining
much. The dreadful shrieking from her and
others was very amazing, which was heard at a
great distance. She was also committed to pri-
son.
A child of Sarah Good's was likewise appre-
hended, being between 4 and 5 years old. The
accusers said this child bit them, and would shew
such like marks, as those of a small set of teeth,
upon their arms: as many of the afflicted as the
child cast its eye upon, would complain they
were in torment: which child they also com-
mitted.
V Concerning those that had been hitherto ex-
amined and committed, it is among other things
observed, by Mr. Lawson (in print) that they
w^ere by the accusers charged to belong to a
company that did muster in arms, and were re-
ported by them to keep days of last, thanksgiv-
ing and sacraments ; and that those afflicted (or
accusers) did in the assembly cure each other,
even with a touch of their hand, when strangled
and other ways tortured, and would endeavour
to get to the afflicted to relieve them thereby
(for hitherto they had not used the experiment
of bringing the accused to touch the afflicted, in
order to their cure) and could foretel one anoth-
er's fit to be coming^, and would say, look to such
a one, she will have a tit presently, and so it
happened; and that at the same time when the
accused person was present, the afflicted said
they saw her spectre or hkeness in other places
of the meeting-house sucking their familiars.
The said mr. Lawson being to preach at the
OF FACT, SiC. 193
Village, after the psalm was siin^y, Abigail Wil-
liams said, jYow stand up and name your text ;
alter it was read, she said, it was a long text,
Mrs. Pope in the beg'r.ning of sermon said to
him, now there is enough of that. In sermon, he
referring to his doctrine, Abigail Williams said
to him, / know no doctrine you had ; if you did
name one^ I have forgot it* Ann Putrijan, an af-
flicted girl, said, there was a yellow bird sat oti
his hat as it hung on the pin in the pulpit,
March 31, 1692, was set apart as a day of
solemn humiliation at Salem, upon the account
of this business ; on which day Abigail Williams
said, that she saw a great yiumber of persons in
the Village at the administration of a mock sacra-
mcnt^ where they had bread as red as raw fleshy and
red drink,
jSpril 1. Mercy Lewis affirmed, that she saw
a man in white, with ivhom she went into a crlorious
place, viz. in her fits, where icas no light of the
sun, much less of candles, yet was full (flight and
brightness, with a great multitude in white glitter-
ing robes, icho sang the song in Rev. v. 9. and the
cxlix Psalm ; and was given that she might tar-
ry no longer in this place. T\m white man is
said to have appeared several times to others of
them, and to have given them notice how long it
should be before they should have another fit.
./^pril 3. Being sacrament day at the Village,
Sarah Cloyce, sister to goodwife Nurse, a mem-
ber of one of the churches, was (though it seems
with difficulty prevailed with to be) present ;
but being entered the place, and mr. Parris
naming his text, John \l 70, Have not 1 chosen
17
i.94 MATTERS
you twelve^ and one of you is a devil; (for what
cause may rest as a doubt, whether upon the
account of her sisters being committed, or be-
cause of the choice of that iQXi) she rose up
and went out; the wind shutting the door forci-
bly, gaye occasion to some to suppose she went
out in anger, and might occasion a suspicion of
her ; however, she was soon after complained of^
examined and committed.
^j^pril 11. By this time the number of the ac-
cused and accusers being much increased, there
was a publick examination at Salem, six of the
magistrates with several ministers being present.
There appeared several who complained against
others with hideous clamours and screechings.
Goodwife Proctor was brought thither, being
accused or cried out against : her husband
coming to attend and assist her, as there might
be need, the accusers cried out of him also, and
that with so much earnestness, -that he was comr
mitted with liis wife. About this time, besides
the experiment of the afflicted felling at the
sight, (fee. they put the accused upon saying the
Lord's prayer, which one among them peribrm-
ed, except in that petition, deliver us from evil^
she exprest it thus, deliver us from all evil : this
was looked upon as if she prayed against what
she was now justly under, and being put upon
it again, and repeating those words, hallowed he
thy name, she exprest it, hollowed he thy name :
this was counted a depraving the words, as sig-
nifying to make void, and so a curse rather than
a prayer: upon the whole it was concluded that
she also could not say it, 6ic* Proceeding in this
OF FACT, &c. 195
work of examination and commitment, many
were sent to prison. As an instance, sec the
following mittimus.
To their Majesties'' Gaol-keeper in Salem.
You are in tlielr majesties' names hereby re-
quired to take into your care, and safe custody,
tile bodies of William Hobs and Deborah his
wife, Mary Easty, the wife of Isaac Easty, and
Sarah Wild, the wife of John Wild, all of Tops-
field; and Edward Bishop, of Salem Village,
husbandman, and Sarah his wife, and Mary
Black, a negro of lieutenant Nathaniel Putman,
of Salem Village ; also Mary English, the wife
of Philip English, merchant, in Salem; who
stand charged with high suspicion of sundry acts
of witchcraft, done or committed by them lately
upon the bodies of Ann Putman, Mary Lewis
and Abigail Williams, of Salem Village ; where-
by great hurt and damage hath been done to
the bodies of the said persons, according to the
complaint of Thomas Putman and John Buxton,
of Salem Village, exhibited; whom you are to
secure in order to their further examination. —
Fail not.
John Hathorn. ) • , ,
, ^ . > assistants.
Jona. Lurwin^ ^
Dated Salem, April 22, 1692.
To marshal George Herrick^
of Salem^ Essex.
You are in their majesties' names hereby required
to convey the above named to the gaol at Salem. — Fail
not. John Hathonu } • i i,.
T r^ . ' > assistants.
Jona. Lurzvm^ ^
Dated Salem, April 22, 1692.
196 MATTERS
The occasion of Bishop's being cried out of,
v/as, he being at an examination in Saiem, when
at the inn an afflicted Indian was very unruly,
whom he undertook, and so managed him, that
he was very orderly ; after which, in riding
home, in company of him and other accusers,
the Indian fell into a fit, and clapping hold with
his teeth on the back of the man that rode be-
fore him, thereby held himself upon the horse;
but said Bishop striking him with his stick, the
Indian soon recovered, and promised he would
do so no more; to which Bishop replied, that
he doubted not but he could cure them all, with
more to the same effect. Immediately after he
was parted from them, he was cried out of, &;c.
May 14, 1692. Sir William Phips arrived
with commission from their majesties to be go-
vernor, pursuant to the new charter, which he
now brought with him, the ancient charter hav-
ing been vacated by king Charles and king
James, (by which they had a power not only to
make their own laws, but also to choose their
ow^n governor and officers) and the country for
some years. was put under an absolute commis-
sion-government, till the Revolution, at which
time, though more than two thirds of the people
were for reassuming their ancient government, (to
which they had encouragement by his then royal
highness's proclamation) yet some that might
have been better emplojcd (in another station)
made it their business (by printing, as w^ell as
speaking) to their utmost to divert them from
such a settlement; and so far prevailed, that
for about seven weeks after the Revolution.
OF FACT,'&c. 197
here was not so much as a lace of any govern-
ment; but some lew men upon their own nomi-
nation would be called a committee of safety;
but at Icngtii tlie assembly prevailed with tiiose
that had been of the government, to promise
that they would reassume; and accordiiifi^lv a
proclamation was drawn, but before publishing
it, it was underwritten, that they would not
have it understood that they did reassume char-
ter-government ; so that between government
and no government, this country remained till
sir William arrived : agents being in this time
empowered in England, which no doubt did not
all of them act accordmg to the minds or inter-
ests of those that empowered them, whicli is
manifest by their not acting jointly in what was
done; so that this place is perhaps a single in-
stance (even in the best of reigns) of a charter
not restored after so happy a revolution. This
settlement by sir William Phips's having come
governor put an end to all disputes of these things;
and being arrived, and having read his com-
mission, the first thing he exerted his power in,
was said to be his giving orders that irons should
be put upon those in prison; for though for
some time after these were committed, the ac-
cusers ceased to cry out of them, yet now the
cry against them was renewed, which occasion-
ed such order; and though there was partiali-
ty in the executing it (some having them taken
off almost as soon as put on) yet the cry of these
accusers against such, ceased after this order.
Mai/ 24. Mrs. Cary, of Charlestown, was
examined and committed. Her husband, rar
,7#
198 MATTERS
Jonathan Gary, has given account thereof, as
also of her escape, to this effect :
"I having heard, some clays, that my wife was
accused of witchcraft, being much disturbed at
it, by advice we went to Salem Village, to see if
the afflicted knew her; we arrived there 24th
May; it happened to be a day appointed for
examination ; accordingly, soon after our arrival,
mr. Hathorn and mr. Curwin, &:c. went to the
meeting-house, which was the place appointed
for that work; the minister began with prayer;
and having taken care to get a convenient place,
I observed that the afflicted were two girls of
about ten years old, and about two or three
others, of about eighteen; one of the girls talk-
ed most, and could discern more than the rest.
The prisoners were called in one by one, and as
they came in were cried out of, (S:c. The pri-
soners were placed about seven or eight leet
from the justices, and the accusers between the
justices and them ; the prisoners were ordered
to stand right before the justices, with an officer
appointed to hold each hand, lest they should
therewith afflict them; and the prisoners' eyes
must be constantly on the justices ; for if tiiey
looked on the afflicted, they would either fall
into their fits, or cry out of being hurt by them.
After an examination of the prisoners, who it
was afflicted these girls, &c. they were put up-
on saying the Lord's prayer, as a trial of their
o-uilt. After the afflicted seemed to be out of
their ffts, they would look steadfastly on some
one person, and frequently not speak ; and then
the justices said they were struck dumb^ and a!-
OF FACT, &c. 199
ter a little time would speak again; then the
justices said to the accusers, Which of you will
go aixl touch the prisoner at the bar? Then the
most courageous would adventure, but before
they had made three steps would ordinarily fall
down as in a fit. The justices ordered that
they should be taken up and carried to the pri-
soner, that she might touch them; and as soon
as they were touched by the accused, the justi-
ces would say, they are well, before 1 could dis-
cern any alteration; by which I observed that
the justices understood the manner of it. Thus
far I was only as a spectator ; my wife also was
there part of the time, but no notice taken of
her by the alHicted, except once or twice they
came to her and asked her name.
'• But I having an opportunity to discouse mr.
Hale (with whom I had formerly acquaintance)
I took his advice what 1 had best to do, and
desired of him that I might have an opportuni-
ty to speak with her that accused my wife;
which he promised should be, I acquainting him
that I reposed my trust in him. Accordingly
he came to me after the examination was over,
and told me I had now an opportunity to speak
with the said accuser, viz. Abigail Williams, a
girl of 11 or 12 years old; but that we could
not be in private at mr. Parris's house, as he
had promised me; we went therefore into the
alehouse, where an Indian man attended us,
who it seems was one of the atjjie4«d : to him
we gave some cider : he shew^'d several scars,
that seemed as if they had been long there, and
shewed them as done by witchcraft, and ac-
200 MATTERS
quainted us that his wife, who also was a slave,
was imprisoned for witchcraft. And now, in-
stead of one accuser, thej all came in, and be-
gan to tumble down like swine ; and then three
women were called in to attend them. We in
the room were ail at a stand, to see who they
would cry out of ; but in a short time they cri-
ed out, Gary; and immediately after a warrant
was sent from the justices to bring my wife be-
fore them, who were sitting in a chamber near
by, waiting ior this.
''Being brought before the justices, her chief
accusers were two girls. My wife declared to
the justices, that she never had any knowledge
of them before that day. She was i'orced to
stand with her arms stretched out. I requested
that I might hold one of her hands, but it was
denied me; then she desired me to w^ipe the
tears from her eyes, and the sweat from her
face, which 1 did; then she desired she might
lean herself on me, saying she should faint.
" Justice Hathorn replied, she had strength
enough to torment those persons, and she should
have strength enough to stand. 1 speaking
something against their cruel proceedings, they
commanded me to be silent, or else I should be
turned out of the room. The Indian before
mentioned was also brought in, to be one of her
accusers: being come m, he now (when belbre
the justices) fell down and tumbled about like a
hog, but said nothing. The justices asked the
girls who afilicted the Indian; they answered,
she, (meaning my wife) and that she now lay
upon him ; the justices ordered her to touch
OF FACT, kc. 201
him, in order to his cure, but her head must be
turned another way, lest, instead of curing, she
should make liim worse, by licr looking on him,
her hand being guided to take hold of his; but
the Indian took liold of her liand, and pulled her
down on the floor, in a barbarous manner ; then
his hand was taken oi\\ and her hand put on his,
^nd the cure was quickly wrought. I, being
extremely troubled at their inhuman dealings,
uttered a hasty speech, That God would take
vengeance on them, and desired that God would
deliver us out of the hands of unmerciful men.
Then her mittmius was writ. I did with diffi-
culty and charge obtain ihe liberty of a room,
but no beds in it ; il' there had been, could have
taken but little rest that night. She was com-
mitted to Boston prison ; but 1 obtained a ha-
beas corpus to remove her to Cambridge pri-
son, which is in our county of Middlesex. Hav-
ing been there one night, next morning the jail-
er put irons on her legs (having received such
a command ;) the weight of them was about
eight pounds : these irons and her other afflic-
tions soon brought her into convulsion fits, so
that I thought she would have died that night.
I sent to entreat that the irons might be takeu
ofi'; but all entreaties were in vain, if it would
have saved her life, so that in this condition she
must continue. The trials at Salem coming on,
1 went thither, to see how things were mana-
ged ; and finding that the spectre evidence was
there received, together with idle, if not mali-
cious stories, against people's lives, 1 did easily
perceive which way the rest would go ; for the
:202 MATTERS
same evidence that served for one, would serve
for all the rest. I acquainted her with her
danger ; and that if she were carried to Salem
to be tried, I feared she would never return. I
did my utmost that she might have her trial in
our own county, I with several others petition-
ing the judge for it, and were put in hopes of it;
but I soon saw so much, that I understood there-
by it was not intended, which put me upon con-
sulting the means of her escape ; which through
the goodness of God was effected, and she got
to Rhode-Island, but soon found herself not safe
when there, by reason of the pursuit after her ;
from thence she went to New-York, along with
some others that had escaped their cruel hands ;
where we found his excellency Benjamin Fletch-
er, esq. governor, who was very courteous to us.
After this, some of my goods were seized in a
friend's hands, with whoin I had lett tliem, and
myself imprisoned by the sheritif', and kept in
custody half a day, and then dismissed ; but to
speak of their usage of the prisoners, and the
inhumanity shewn to them at the time of their
execution, no sober christian could bear. They
had also trials of cruel mockings ; which is the
more, considering wliat a people for religion, I
mean the profession of it, we have been ; those
that suffered being many of them church mem-
bers, and most of them unspotted in their con-
versation, till their adversary the devil took up
this method for accusing them.
"Per Jonathan Gary."
May 31. Capt. John Aldin was examined
la Salem, and committed to Boston prison. The
OF FACT, ij-c. 203
prison-koepen seeing such a man committed, of
wliom he had a good esteem, was ai'ter this the
more compassionate to those that were in prison
on the like account ; and re Trained from such
hard things to the prisoners, as hefore he had
used. Mr. Aldin himself has given an account
of his examination, in tliese words :
An account how John Jlldin^ senior, ivas dealt with
at Salem Village,
John Aldin, senior, ol Boston, in the county of
Sulfolk, manner, on the 28th day of May, 1692,
was sent for by the magistrates of Salem, in the
county of Essex, upon the accusation of a com-
pany of poor distracted or possessed creatures
or witches ; and being sent by mr. Stoughton,
arrived there the 31st of May, and appeared at
Salem Village, before mr. Gidney, mr. Hathorn
and rar. Cur win.
Those wenches being present, who played
their juggling tricks, falling down, crying out,
and staring in people's faces; the magistrates
demanded of them several times, who it was of
all the people in the room that hurt them : one
of these accusers pointed several times at one
captain Hill, there present, but spake nothing;
the same accuser had a mac standing at her
back to hold her up; he stooped down to her
ear, then she cried out, Aldin, Aidin afflicted her;
one of the masfist rates asked her if she had ever
seen Aldin, she answered no ; he asked how she
knew it wis Aldin; she said the man told her so.
Then all were ordered to go down into the
street, where a ring was made; and the same
accuser cried out, There stands Aldin, a bold /
204 MATTERS
fellow, with his hat on before the judges; he
sells powder and shot to the Indians and French,
and hes with the Indian squaws, and has Indian
papooses. Then was Aldin committed to the
marshal's custody, and his sword taken from
him; for they said he afflicted them with his
sword. After some hours Aldin was sent for
to the meeting-house in the Village, before the
magistrates; who required Aldin to stand upon
a chair, to the open view of all the people.
The accusers cried out that Aldin pinched
them, then, when he stood upon the chair, in
the sight of all the people, a good way distant
from them. One of the magistrates bid the
marshal to hold open Aldin's hands, that he
mi^ht not pinch those creatures. Aldin asked
them why they should think that he should
come to that Village to afflict those persons
that he never knew or saw before. Mr. Gid-
ney bid Aldin confess, and give glory to God.
Aldin said, he hoped he should give glory to
God, and hoped he should never gratify the
devil; but appealed to all that ever knew him,
if they ever suspected him to be such a per-
son, and challenged any one, that could bring
in any thing upon their own knowledge, that
might give suspicion of his being such an one.
Mr. Gidney said he had known Aldin many
years, and had been at sea with him, and al-
ways looked upon him to be an honest man,
but now he saw cause to alter his judgment.
Aldin answered, he was sorry for that, but he
hoped God would clear up his innocency, that
he w^ould recal that judgment again ; and added,
OF FACT, iX-c. 206
that he hoped that he should with Job maintain his
integrity till he died. Thej bid Aldin look upon
the accusers, which he did, and then thej fell
down. Aldin asked mr. Gidney what reason
there could be given, why Aldin's looking upon
hirn did not P >ike him down as well ; but no rea-
son was given that I heard. But the accusers
were brought to Aldin to touch them, and this
touch they said made them well. Aldin began
to speak of the providence of God, in suffeiing
these creatures to accuse innocent persons. Mr.
Noyes asked Aldin why he w^ould otfer to speak
of the providence of God : God by his provi-
dence (said mr. Noyes) governs the world, and
keeps it in peace ; and so went on with discourse,
and stopt Aldin's mouth as to that. Aldin told
Mr. Gidney, that he could assure him that there
Avas a lying spirit in them, for I can assure you
that thei-e is not a w^ord of truth in all these say
of me. But Aldin was again committed to the
marshal, and his mittimus written, which was as
follows :
To im\ John j^rnold^ keeper of the prison in Bos^
ton, in the county of Suffhlk*
Whereas captain John Aldin, of Boston, mari-
ner, and Sarah Rice, Avife of Nicholas Rice,
of Reading, husbandman, have been this day
brought before us, John Hathorn and Jonathan
Curwin, esquires ; being accused and suspected
of perpetrating divers acts of witchcraft, contra-
ry to the form of the statute, in that case made
and provided: these are therefore, in their ma-
jesties king William and queen Mary's names,
18
206 MATTERS
to will and require you to take into your custo-
dy the bodies of the said John Aldin and Sarah
Rice, and them safely keep, until they shall be
delivered by due course of law, as you will an-
swer the contrary at your peril ; ^^nd this shall
be your sufficient warrant. GH'^'n under our
hands at Salem Village, the 31st of May, in the
fourth year of the reign of our sovereign lord
and lady, William and Mary, now king and
queen over England, &c. Anno Domini 1692.
John Hat horn. ) • ^ ^
7 r^ ' } assistants,
Jona, Cunvin, ^
To Boston, Aldin was carried by a constable ;
no bail would be taken for him ; but vv'as deli-
vered to the prison-keeper, where he remained
fifteen weeks ; and then, observing the manner
of trials, and evidence then taken, was at length
prevailed with to make his escape, and being re-
turned, was bound over to answer at the supe-
rior court at Boston, the last Tuesday in April,
anno 1693; and was there cleared by procla-
mation, none appearing against him.
Per John Aldin.
At the examination, and at other times, it was
usual for the accusers to tell of the black man,
or of a spectre, as being then on the table, &c.
The people about would strike with swords, or
sticks, at those places. One justice broke his
cane at this exercise ; and sometimes the accu-
sers would say, they -struck the spectre, and it
is reported several oi'the accused were hurt and
wounded thereby^ though at home at the same
time.
OF FACT, &c. 207
The justices proceeding in these works of ex-
nmination and conunitrnent to the end of May,
I here were by that time about a hundred per-
bons imprisoned upon that account.
June 2. A special commission of oyer and ter-
miner having been issued out, to mr. Stoughton,
the new lieutenant governor, major Saltonstall,
major Richards, major Gidney, mr. Wait Win-
throp, captain Sewall, and mr. Sergeant, a quo-
rum of wliom sat at Salem this daj, where the
most that was done this week was the trial of
one Bishop, alias Oliver, of Salem ; who had
long undergone the repute of a witch, occasioned
by f hr» accusationc oi' oiie Samucl Gray ; he,
about twenty years since, having charged her
with such crimes; and though upon his death-
bed he testified his sorrow and repentance for
such accusations, as being Avholly groundless,
yet the report, taken up by his means, continu-
ed, and she JDeing accused by those afflicted,
and upon search a teat, as they call it, being
found, she was brought in guilty by the jury ;
she received her sentence of death, and was
executed June 10, but made not the least coD'
fession of any thing relating to witchcraft.
June 13. Several ministers in and near Bos-
ton, having been to that end consulted by his
excellency, exprest their minds to this etfect, viz.
That they were affected with the deplorable V
state of the afflicted; that they were thankful
for the diligent care of the rulers to detect the
abominable witchcrafts which have been com-
mitted in the country, praying for a perfect dis-
covery thereof; but advised to a cautious pro-
^On MATTERS
ceeding, lest many evils ensue, &;c. and that
tenderness be used towards those accused, re-
lating to matters presumptive and convictive,
and also to privacy in examinations ; and to con-
sult mr. Perkins and mr. Bernard what tests to
make use of in the scrutiny : that presumptions
and convictions ought to have better grounds
than the accusers affirming that they see such
persons' spectres afflicting them ; and that the
devil may afflict in the shape of good men; and
that falhng at the sight, and rising at the touch,
of the accused, is no infallible proof of guilt;
that seeing the devil's strength consists in such
accusations, our disbelieving them may be a
means to put a period to the dreadful calami-
ties. Nevertheless they humbly recommend to
the government, the speedy and vigorous pros-
ecution of such as have rendered themselves
obnoxious, according to the direction given in
the laws of God, and the wholesome statutes of
the English nation, for the detection of witch-
craft.
This IS briefly the substance of what may be
seen more at large in Cases of Conscience* Qdt.)
And one of them since taking occasion to repeat
some part of this advice, (^Wonders of the Invisi-
hie World, p. 83) declares (notwithstanding the
dissatisfaction of others) that if his said book
niay conduce to promote thankfulness to God
for such executions, he shall rejoice, &c.
The 30th of June, the court according to ad-
journment again sat ; five more were tried, viz.
Sarah Good and Rebecca Nurse, of Salem Vil-
lage ; Susanna Martin, of Amsbury ; Elizabeth
OF FACT, &c. 20^
How of [pswlcli; and SarahWildcs of Topsficld:
these were all coiidenined that session, and were
all executed on the 19th of July.
At the trial of Sarah Good, one of the afflict-
ed fell in a fit ; and after coming out of it she
cried out of the prisoner, for stabbing her in the
breast with a knife, and that she had broken
the knife in stabbing of her; accordingly a piece
ol' the blade of a knife was found about her.
Immediately information being given to the
court, a young man was called, who produced a
haft and part of the blade, which the court hav-
ing viewed and compared, saw it to be the same;
and upon inquiry the young man affirmed, that
yesterday he happened to break that knife, and
that he cast away the upper part. This afflicted
person being then present, the young man was
dismissed, and she was bidden by the court not
to tell lies; and was improved after (as she had
been before) to give evidence against the pri-
"soners.
At the execution, Mr. Noyes urged Sarah
Good to confess, and told her she was a witch,
and she knew she was a witch; to which she
replied, you are a liar; I am no more a witch
than you are a wizard; and if you take away
my life, God will give you blood to drink.
At the trial of Uebecca Nurse, it was remarka-
ble that the jury brought in their verdict not
gailty ; immediately all the accusers in the court,
aiid suddenly after all the afflicted out of court,
made an hideous outcry, to the amazement not
only of the spectators, but the court also seemed
strangely surprised : one of the judges exprest
18*
^10 MATTERS
himself not satisfied ; another of them, as he was
going off the bench, said they would have her
indicted anew. The chief judge said he would
not impose upon the jury; but intimated as if
they had not well considered one expression of
the prisoner when she was upon trial, viz. that
when one Hobbs, \vho had confessed herseh" to
be a witch, was brought into the court to wit-
ness against her, the prisoner, turning her head
to her, said, What, do you bring her ? she is one
of us, or to that effect; this, together with the
clamours of the accusers, induced the jury to go
put again, after their verdict, not guilty. But
not agreeing, they came into the court ; and she
being then at the bar, her words were repeated
to her, in order to have her explanation of them ;
and she making no reply to them, they found the
bill, and brought her in guilty ; these words
being the inducement to it, as the foreman ha^?
signified in writing, as follows :
July 4, 1692. I, Thomas Fisk, the subscrib-
er hereof, being one of them that were of the
lury last week at Salem court, upon the trial of
Rebecca Nurse, &c. being desired by some of
the relations to give a reason why the jury
brought her in guilty, after her verdict not guil-
ty; 1 do hereby give my reasons to be as fol-
lows, viz.
When the verdict was, not guilty, the honour-
ed court was pleased to object against it, saying
to them, that they think they let slip the words
which the prisoner at the bar spake against her-
self, which were spoken in reply to goodwife
Hobbs and her daughter, who had been faulty in
OF FACT, &c. 211
setting tlielr hands to the devil's book, as they
iiad conlessed I'orinerly ; the words were, IVkat,
do tkese persons give in evidence against me now ?
they used to come among us. Alter the honoured
court had manil'ested their dissati^slaction of the
verdict, several of the jury dech^red themselves
desirous to go out again, and tliereupon the court
gave leave; but when we came to consider of
the case, I could not tell how to take lier words
as an evidence against her, till she had a further
opportunity to put her sense upon them, if she
would take it; and then, going into court, I men-
tioned the words aforesaid, w^hich by one of the
court were affirmed to have been spoken by
her, she being then at the bar, but made no re-
ply, nor interpretation of tliem; whereupon
these words weie to me a principal evidence
against her. ThoiMas Fisk.
When good wife Nurse was informed what
use was made of these words, she put in this
following declaration into the court:
These presents do humbly shew to the hon-
oured court and jury, that I being informed that
the jury brought me in guilty, upon my saying
that good wife Hobbs and her daughter were of
our companv ; but I intended no otherways, than
as they were prisoners with us, and therefore
did then, and yet do, judge them not legal evi-
d(^nce against their fellow prisoners. And 1 be-
ins^ somethinsj hard of hearinor, and full of ornef,
none miormmg me Ijovv the court took up my
words, and therefore had no opportunity to de-
clare what I intended, when I said they were of
our company. Rf.becca *Nurs^
'ilQ MATTERS
After Tier condemnation she was by one of
the ministers of Salem excommunicated; yet
the governor saw cause to grant a reprieve;
which when known (and some say immediately
upon granting) the accusers renewed their dis-
mal outcries against her, insomuch that the go-
vernor was by some Salem gentlemen prevailed
with to recall the reprieve, and she was execut-
ed with the rest.
The testimonials of her christian behaviour,
both in tlie course of her life and at her death,
and her extraordinary care in educating her chil-
dren, and setting them good examples, &;c. un-
der the hands of so many, are so numerous, that
for brevity they are here omitted.
It was at the trial of these that one of the
accusers cried out publicly of Mr. Willard, mi-
nister in Boston, as afflicting of her : she was
sent out of the court, and it was told about she
was mistaken in the person.
August 5, the court again sitting, six more
were tried on the same account, viz. mr. George
Burroughs, sometime minister of Wells, John
Proctor, and Elizabeth Proctor his wife, with
John Willard, of Salem Village, George Jacobs
senior, of Salem, and Martha Carrier, of Ando-
ver; these were all brought in guilty, and coi>
demned; and were all executed, August 19, ex-
cept Proctor's wife, who pleaded pregnancy.
Mr. Burroughs was carried in a cart with the
others, throu^^h the streets of Salem to execu-
tion. When he was upon the ladder, he made
a speech for the clearing of his innecency, Avith
such solemn and serious expressions, as were to
OF FACT, Lc. t\3
Ihe admiration of all present: his prayer (which
he concluded by repeating the Lord's prayer)
was so well worded, and uttered with such coiri-
posedness, and such (at least seeming) fervency
of spirit, as was very aifecting, and drew tears
from many, so that it seemed to some that the
spectators would hinder the execution. The
accusers said the black man stood and dictated
to him. As soon as he was turned otij mr. Cot-
ton Mather, being mounted upon a horse, ad-
dressed himself to the people, partly to declare
that he [Burroughs] was no ordained minister,
and partly to possess the people of his guilt, say-
ing that the devil has often been transformed in-
to an angel of light; and this somewhat appeas-
ed the people, and the executions went on.
When he was cut down, he was dragged by the
halter to a hole, or grave, between the rocks,
about two feet deep, his shirt and breeches be-
ing pulled olf, and an old pair of trowsers of one
executed put on his lower parts ; he was so put
in, together with Willard and Carrier, that one
of his hands and his chin, and a foot of one of
them, were left uncovered.
John Willard had been employed to fetch in
several that were accused ; but taking dissatis-
faction from his being sent to fetch up some
that he had better thoughts of, he declined the
service ; and presently after he himself was ac-
cused of the same crime, and that with such ve-
hemency, that they sent after him to apprehend
him. He had made his escape as far as Nasha-
wag, about forty miles from vSalem; yet it is
said those accusers did then presently tell the
exact time, saying, Now Willard is takei>
214 MATTERS
John Proctor and his wife being in prison, the
sheriiFcame to his house and seized all the goods,
provisions and cattle that he could come at, and
sold some of the cattle at half price, and killed
others, and put them up for the West-Indies ;
threw out the beer out of a barrel, and carried
away the barrel ; emptied a pot of broth, and
took away the pot, and left nothing in the house
for the support of the children. No part of the
said goods are known to be returned. Proctor
earnestly requested mr. Noyes to pray with and
for him; but it was wholly denied, because he
would not own liimself to be a witch.
During his imprisonment he sent the follow-
ing letter, in behalf of himself and others.
Snlem Prison. July 23, 1692.
Mr. Mather, Mr. Allen, Mr. Moody, Mr. VVuLr
LARD, and Mr. Baily.
Reverend Gentlemen,
The Innocency of our case, with the enmity
of our accusers and our judges and jury, whom
nothing but our innocent blood will serve, hav-
ing condemned us already before our trials, be-
ing so much incensed and enraged against us by
the devil, makes us bold to beg and implore
your favourable assistance of this our humble
petition to his excellency, that if it be possible
our innocent blood may be spared, which un-
doubtedly otherwise will be shed, if the Lord
doth not mercifully step in; the magistrates,
ministers, juries, and all the people in general,
being so much enraged and incensed against us
by the delusion of the devil, which we can term
OF FACT, kc. 215
no other, by reason we know in our own con-
sciences we are all innocent persons. Plerc are
live persons who have lately confessed them-
selves to be witches, and do accuse some of us
oi" being along with them at a sacrament, since
we were committed into close prison, which we
know to be lies. Two of the five are (Carrier's
sons) young men, who would not confess any
thing till they tied them neck and heels, till the
blood was ready to come out of their noses ; and
it is credibly believed and reported this was the
occasion of making them confess what they ne-
ver did, by reason they said one had been a
witch a month, and another five weeks, and that
their mother had made them so, who has been
confined here this nine weeks. My son William
Proctor, when he was examined, because he
would not confess that he was guilty, when he
was innocent, they tied him neck and heels till
the blood gushed out at his nose, and would
have kept him so twenty-four hours, if one, more
merciful than the rest, had not taken pity on
him, and cacsed him to be unbound. These
actions are very like the popish cruelties. They
have already undone us m our estates, and that
will not serve their turns without our innocent
blood. If it cannot be granted that we can
have our trials at Boston, we humbly beg that
you would endeavour to have these magistrates
changed, and others in their rooms; begging
^Iso and beseeching you would be pleased to be
here, if not all, some of you, at our trials, hoping
thereby you may be the means of saving the
shedding of our innocent blood. Desiring your
tie MATTERS
prayers to the Lord in our behalf, we rest your
poor aliiicted servants,
John Proctor, &;c.
He pleaded very hard at execution for a little
respite of time, saying that he was not fit to die ;
but it was not granted.
Old Jacobs being condemned, the sheriff and
officers came and seized all he had ; his wife had
her wedding ring taken from her, but with great
difficulty obtained it again. She was Ibrced to
buy provisions of the sheriff, such as he had ta-
ken, towards her own support, which not being
sufficient, the neighbours in charity relieved her.
Margaret Jacobs being one that had confess-
ed her own guilt, and testified against her grand-
father Jacobs, mr. Burroughs and John Willard,
she the day before execution came to Mr. Bur-
roughs, acknowledging that she had belied them,
and begged mr. Burroughs's forgiveness; who
not only forgave her, but also prayed with and
for her. She wrote the following letter to her
father :
From the dmigeon in Salem prison, Aug, 20, 1692.
Honoured Father^
After my humble duty remembered to you,
hoping in the Lord of your good health, as bles-
sed be G(;d I enjoy, though in abundance of af-
fliction, being close confined here in a loathsome
dungeon; the Lord look down in mercy upon
me, not knowing how soon I shall be put to
death, by means of the afflicted persons; my
grandfather having suffered already, and all his.
estate seized for the king. The reason of my
OF FACT, kc. 217
confinement is this: I linving, through the ma-
gistrates' threatcnings, and my own vile and
wretched heart, conlessed several things contra-
ry to my conscience and knowledge, though to
the wounding ol' my own soul, (the Lord pardon
me lor it); but oh! the terrors of a wounded
conscience who can bear? But blessed be the
Lord, he would not let me go on in my sins, but
in mercy, 1 hope, to my soul, would not suffer
me to keep it in any longer, but I was forced to
confess the truth of all before the magistrates,
who would not believe me; but 'tis their plea-
sure to put me in here, and God knows how
soon I shall be put to death. Dear father, let
me beg jpuv prayers to the Lord on my behalij
and send us a joyful and liappy meeting in hea-
ven. My mother, poor woman, is very crazy,
and remembers her kind love to you, and to un-
cle, viz. D. A. So leaving you to the protection
of the Lord, I rest your dutiful daughter,
Margaret Jacobs.
At the time appointed for her trial, she had an
imposthume in her head, which w^as her escape.
September 9, six more were tried, and re-
ceived sentence of death, viz. Martha Cory, of
Salem Village ; Mary Easty, of Topsfield ; Alice
Parker and Ann Pudeater, of Salem ; Dorcas
Hoar, of Beverly, and Mary Bradberry, of Sa-
lisbury. Sept. 16, Giles Cory was prest to
deatli.
September 17, nine more received sentence of
death, viz. Margaret Scot, of Rowley ; good-
wife Reed, of JViarblehead ; Samuel Wardweil
19
D
2i§ MATTERS
and Mary Parker, of Andover ; also Abigail
Falkner, of Andover, who pleaded pregnancy ;
Rebecca Eames, of Boxford, Mary Lacy and
Ann Foster, of Andover, and Abigail Hobbs, of
Topsfield. Of these, eight were executed, Sept.
22, viz. Martha Cory, Mary Easty, Alice Par- '
leer, Ann Pudeater, Margaret Scot, William
Reed, Samuel Ward well and Mary Parker.
Giles Cory pleaded not guilty to his indict-
ment, but would not put himself on trial by the
iury (they having cleared none upon trial) and
knowing there would be the same witnesses
against him, rather chose to undergo what death
they would put him to. In pressing, his tongue
being prest out of his mouth, the sheriff with
his cane forced it in again when he was dying.
He was the first in New-England that was ever
prest to death.
The cart, going to the hill with these eight
to execution, was for some time at a set ; the
afflicted and others said, that the devil hindered
it, &c.
Martha Cory, wife to Giles Cory, protesting
her innccency, concluded her life with an emi-
nent prayer upon the ladder.
Wardwell, having formerly confessed himself
guilty, and after denied it, was soon brought up-
on his trial ; his former confession and spectre
testimony was all that appeared against him.
At execution, while he was speaking to the peo-
ple, protesting his innocency, the executioner
being at the same time smoking tobacco, the
smoke coming in his face interrupted his dis-
course ; those accusers said that the devil did
hinder him with smoke.
OF FACT, kc. 219
Mary Easty, sister also to Rebecca Nurse,
when she took lier last larevvell of hor husband,
children and i'riends, was, as is reported by them
present, as serious, religious, distinct and affec-
tionate as could well be expiest, drawing tears
from the eyes of almost all present. It seems,
besides the testimony of the accusers and con-
fessors, another proof, as it was counted, ap-
peared against her : it having been usual to
search the accused for teats, upon some parts
of her body, not here to be named, was found
an excrescence, which they called a teat. Be-
fore her death she presented the following pe-
tition :
" To the honourable judge and bench now
sitting in judicature in Salem, and the reverend
ministers, humbly sheweth, That whereas your
humble poor petitioner, being condemned to
die, doth humbly beg of you to take It into your
judicious and pious consideration, that your poor
and humble petitioner, knowing my own inno-
cency (blessed be the Lord for it) and seeing
plainly the wiles and subtilty of my accusers, by
myself, cannot but judge charitably of others,
that are going the same way with myself, if the
Lord step not mightily in. I was confined a whole
month on the same account that I am now con-
demned, and then cleared by the afflicted persons,
as some of your honours know; and in two days
time 1 was cried out upon by them again, and
have been confined, and now am condemned to
die. The Lord above knows my innocence then,
and likewise doth now, as at the great day will
be known by men and angels. I petition to your
2^0 MATTERS
honours not for my own life, for I know 1 must
die, and my appointed time is set ; but the Lord
he knows if it be possible that no more innocent
blood be shed, which undoubtedly cannot be
avoided in the way and course you go in. I ques-
tion not but your honours do to the utmost of
your powers, in the discovery and detecting of
witchcraft and witches, and would not be guilty
of innocent blood for the world ; but by my own
innocency 1 know you are in the wrong way.
The Lord in his infinite mercy direct you in this
great work, if it be his blessed will, that innocent
biood be not shed. I would humbly beg of you
that your honours would be pleased to examine
some of those confessing witches, I being confi-
dent there are several of them have belied them-
selves and others, as will appear, if not in this
world, I am sure in the world to come, whither
I am going; and I question not but yourselves
will see an alteration in these things. They
say, myself and others have made a league
with the devil; w^e cannot confess; 1 know and
the Lord knows (as will shortly appear) they
belie me, and so I question not but they do
others; the Lord alone, who is the searcher of
?dl hearts, knows, as I shall answer it at the
tribunal seat, that I know not the least thing
of witchcraft, therefore I cannot, I durst not,
belie my own soul. I beg your honours not to
deny this my humble petition, from a poor dying,
innocent person, and I question not but the Lord
will give a blessing to your endeavours.
"Mary East\%"
OF FACT, Sic. 221
After execution, mr. Noyes, turning him to
the bodies, said, What a sad thing it is to see
eiffht firebrands of hell hanging there !
In October, 1692, one of Wenham complained
of rars. Hale, whose husband, the minister of
Beverly, had been very forward in these prose-
cutions; but being fully satisfied of his wife's
sincere Christianity caused him to alter his judg-
ment ; for it was come to a stated controversy,
among the New-England divines, whether the
devil could afflict in a good man's shape ; it seems
nothing else could convince him, yet when it
came so near to himself he was soon convinced,
that the devil might so afflict. Which same rea-
son did afterwards prevail with many others, and
much influenced to the succeeding change at
trials.
October 7. Edward Bishop and his wife hav-
ing made their escape out of prison, this day mr.
Corwin, the sheriff, came and seized his goods
and chattels, and had it not been for his second
son (who borrowed ten pound and gave it him)
they had been wholly lost. The receipt fol-
lows ; but it seems they must be content with
such a receipt as he would give them :
Received, this 7th day of October, 1692, of Samuel
Bishop, of the town of Salem, of the county of Essex, in
New-England, cordwainer, in full satisfaction, a valuable
sum of money, for the goods and chattels of Edward Bi-
shop, senior^ of the town and county aforesaid, husband-
man ; which goods and chattels being seized, for that the
said Edward Bishop, and Sarah his wife, having beea
committed for witchcraft and felony, have made their
escape ; and their goods and chattels were forfeited unto
their majesties, and now being in possession of the said
Samuel Bishop; and in behalf of their majesties. 1 do
19*
222 MATTERS
hereby discharge the said goods and chattels, the day and
year above written, as witness my hand,
George Corwin, Sheriff.
But before this, the said Bishop's eldest son
having married into that family of the Putmans,
who were chief prosecutors in this business, he
holding a cow to be branded lest it should be
seized, and having a push or boil upon his thigh,
Avith his straining it broke ; this is that that was
pretended to be burnt with the said brand, and
is one of the bones thrown to the dogmatical to
pick, in yVonders of the Invisible World, p. 143.
The other, of a corner of a sheet, pretended to
be taken from a spectre ; it is known that it
was provided the day before by that afflicted
person ; and the third bone of a spindle is almost
as easily provided, as the piece of the knife; so
that Apollo needs not herein be consulted, &c.
Mr. Philip English, and his wife, having made
their escape out of prison, mr. Corwin, the she-
riff, seized his estate, to the value of about fifteen
hundred pound, which was wholly lost to him,
except about three hundred pound value (which
was afterward restored.)
After goodwnfe Hoar was condemned, her
estate was seized, and was also bought again for
eight pound.
George Jacobs, son to old Jacobs, being ac-
cused, he fled ; then the officers came to his
house ; his wife was a w^oman crazy in her sen-
ses, and had been so several years. She it
seems had been also accused. There were in
the house w ith her only four small children, and
one of them sucked her eldest dau2:hter, being
OF FACT, &c. 223
in prison : llie officer persuaded her out of" the
house, to go along with hlni, teHing her she
should speedily return; the children ran a great
way alter her, crying.
When she came where the afflicted >vere,
being asked, they said tliey did not know her;
at length one said, Don't you know Jacobs^ the
old witch ? and then they cried out of her, and
fell down in their lits. She was sent to prison,
and lay there ten months ; the neighbours of
pity took care of tlie children to preserve them
from perishing.
About this time a new scene was begun; one
Joseph Ballard, of Andover, whose w lie was ill
(and after died of a fever) sent to Salem for
some of those accusers, to tell him who afflicted
his wife ; others did the like : horse and man
were sent from several places to fetch those ac-
cusers who had the spectral sight, that they
might thereby tell who alBlcted those that were
any ways ill.
When these came into any place where such
were, usually they fell into a fit : after which,
being asked who it was that afflicted the per-
son, they would, for the most part, name one
who they said sat on the head, and another that
sat on the lower parts, of the afflicted. Soon
after Ballard's sending (as above) more than
fifty of the people of Andover were complained
of, for afflicting their neighbours. Here it w as
that many accused themselves of riding upon
poles through the air; many parents believing
their children to be witches, and many husbands
their wives, &c. When these accusers came to
224 , MATTERS
the house of any upon such account, it was or-
dinary for other young people to be taken in
fits, and to have the same spectral sight.
Mr. Dudley Bradstreet, a justice of peace in
Andover, having granted out warrants against,
and committed, thirty or forty to prison, for the
supposed witchcrafts, at length saw cause to
forbear granting out any more warrants. Soon
after which, he and his wife were cried out of;
himself was (by them) said to have killed nine
persons by witchcraft, and he found it his safest
course to make his escape.
A dog being afflicted at Salem Village, those
that had the spectral sight being sent for, they
accused mr. John Bradstreet (brother to the
justice) that he afflicted the said dog, and now
rid upon him. He made his escape into Pisca-
tuqua government, and the dog was put to death,
and was all of the afflicted that suffered death.
At Andover, the afflicted complained of a
dog, as afflicting them, and would fall into their
fits at the dog's looking upon them ; the dog
was put to death.
A worthy gentleman of Boston being about
this time accused by those at Andover, he sent
by some particular friends a writ to arrest those
accusers in a thousand pound action for defama-
tion, with instructions to them to inform them-
selves of the certainty of the proof, in doing
which their business was perceived, and from
thenceforward the accusations at Andover gen-
erally ceased.
In October some of these accusers were sent
for to Gloucester, and occasioned four women to
GF FACT, &c. 225
be sent to prison; but Salem prison bcin^ so lull
it could receive no more, two were sent to Ips-
wich prison. In November they were sent lor
again by lieutenant Stephens, wfio was told that
a sister ol' his was bewitclicd; in their way
passing over Ipswich-bridge, they met with an
old woman, and instantly fell into their fits.
But by this time the validity oisuch accusations
being much questioned, they Ibund not that en-
couragement they had done elsewhere, and soon
withdrew.
These accusers swore that they saw three
persons sitting upon lieutenant Stephens's sister
till she died ; yet bond was accepted for those
three:
And now^ nineteen persons having been hang-
ed, and one prest to death, and eight more con-
demned, in all twenty-eight, of which above a
third part were members of some of the church-
es in New-England, and more than half of them
of a good conversation in general, and not one
cleared; about fifty having confest themselves
to be witches, of which not one executed ; above
an iiundred and fifty in prison, and above two
hundred more accused ; tlie special commission
of oyer and terminer comes to a period, which
has no other foundation than the governor's com-
mission; and iiad proceeded in the manner of
swearing witnesses, viz. by holding up the hand,
(and by receiving evidences in writing) accord-
ing to the ancient usage of this country; as also
having their indictments in English. In the tri-
als, when any were indicted for afflicting, pining
and wasting the bodies of particular persons by
226 BIATTERS
witchcraft, it v/as usual to hear evidence of mat-
ter foreign, and of perhaps twenty or thirty
years standing, about oversetting carts, the death
of cattle, unkindness to relations, or unexpected
accidents befalHng after some quarrel. Wheth-
er this was admitted by the law of England, or
by what other law, wants to be determined;
the executions seemed mixt, in pressing to death
for not pleading, Avhich most agrees with the
laws of England; and sentencing women to be
hanged for witchcraft, according to the former
practice of this country, and not by burning, as
is said to have been the law of England. And
though the confessing witches were many, yet
not one of them that confessed their own guilt,
and abode by their confession, was put to death.
Here folioweth what account some of those
miserable creatures give of their confession un-
der their own hands;
" We, whose names are under written, inhabi-
tants of Andover, when as that horrible and tre-
mendous judgment beginning at Salem Village, in
the year 1692, (by some called witchcraft) first
breaking forth at mr. Parrls's house, several
young persons being seemingly afflicted, did ac-
cuse several persons for afflicting them, and ma-
ny there believing it so to be; we being inform-
ed that if a person were sick, the afflicted per-
son could tell what or who was the cause of that
sickness: Joseph Ballard, of Andover (his wife
being sick at the same time) he either from
himself, or by the advice of others, fetched two
of the persons, called the afflicted persons, from
OF FACT, 4c. 227
Salem Village to Andover: which was the be-
ginning of that dreadful calamity that befel us
in Andover. And the authority in Andover,
believing the said accusations to be true, sent for
the said persons to come together to the meet-
ing-house in Andover (the afflicted persons be-
ing there.) After mr. Barnard had been at
prayer, we were blindfolded, and our hands
were laid upon the afflicted persons, they being
in their fits, and falling into their fits at our
coming into their presence (as they said) and
some led us and laid our hands upon them, and
then they said they were well, and that we
were guilty of afflicting of them ; whereupon
we were all seized as prisoners, by a warrant
from a justice of the peace, and forthwith car-
ried to Salem. And by reason of that sudden
surprisal, we knowing ourselves altogether
innocent of that crime, we were all exceed-
ingly astonished and amazed, and affrighted
even out of our reason; and our nearest and
dearest relations, seeing us in that dreadful con-
dition, and knowing our great danger, appre-
hending that there was no other way to save
our lives, as the case was then circumstanced,
but by our confessing ourselves to be such and
such persons, as the afflicted represented us to
be, they out of tender love and pity persuaded
us to confess what we did confess. And indeed
that confession, that it is said we made, was no
other than what was suggested to us by some
gentlemen; they telling" us, that we were
witches, and they knew it, and we knew it,
and they knew that we knew it, which made
228 MATTERS
us think that it was so; and our understand-
ing, our reason and our faculties almost gone,
we were not capable of juds;irjg our condi-
tion; as also the hard measures they used with
us rendered us uncapable of making our defence ;
but said any thing and every thing which they
desired; and most of what we said was but in
effect a consenting to what they said. Some-
time after, when we were better composed,
they telling of us what we had confessed, we
did profess that we were innocent, and ignorant
of such things. And we hearing that Samuel
Ward well had renounced his confession, and
quickly after was condemned and executed,
some of us were told that we were going after
Wardweil.
Mary Osgood^
Mary Tiler ^
Deliv. Dane,
Abigail Barker^
Sarah Wilson,
Hannah Tiler,''^
It may here be further added, concerning
those that did confess, that besides that power-
ful argument, of life (and freedom from hard-
ships, not only promised, but also performed to
all that ow-ned their guilt) there are numerous
instances, too many to be here inserted, of the
tedious examinations before private persons,
many hours together; they all that time urging
them to confess (and taking turns to persuade
them) till the accused were wearied out by be-
ing forced to stand so long, or for want of sleep,
&c. and so brought to give an assent to what
they said ; they then asking them. Were you at
such a witch-meeting ? or, Have you signed the
OF FACT, &c. 229
t)evil's book ? (fee. Upon their replying, Yes,
the whole was drawn into form, as their con-
I'ession.
But that which did mightily further puch
confessions was, their nearest relations urging
them to it. These, seeing no other way of
ecape for them, thought it the best advice that
could be given ; hence it was that the husbands
of some, by counsel often urging, and utmost
earnestness, and children upon their knees in-
treating, have at length prevailed with them to
say they were guilty.
As to the manner of trials, and the evidence
taken for convictions at Salem, it is already set
forth in print, by the rev,, mr. Cotton Mather,
in his Wonders of the Invisible World, at the com-
mand of his excellency feir William Phips; with
not only the recommendation, but thanks, of the
heutenant governor; and with the approbation
of the rev. mr. I. M. in his postscript to his Cases \/^
of Conscience ; which last book was set forth by X
the consent of the ministers In and near Boston. \
Tvvo of the judges have also given their sen-
timents in these words, p. 147.
The reverenrl and worthy author having:, at the direc-
tion of his excellency the governor, so far obliged the
puMick, as to give some account of tlie sufferings brought
upon the country by witchcrafts, and of the trials which
have passed upon several executed tor the same :
Upon perusal thereof, we find the matters of, fact and
evidence truly repo.'ted, and a prospect given of the me-
thods of conviction, used in the proceedings of the court
at Salem. ,,^ ^
U ILLIAM bTOUGHTOIf,
Boston, Oct U,m2. ^^''''^^^ ^^'''^^^•
20
250 MATTERS
And considering that this may fall Into the
hands of such as never saw those IVonders, it
may be needful to transcribe the whole account
he has given thereof, without any variation (but
■with one of the Indictments annexed to the tri-
al of each) which is thus prefaced, pp. 8],
82, 83.
" But I shall no longer detain my reader from
his expected entertainment, in a brief account
of the trials which have passed upon some of
the malefactors lately executed at Salem for
the witchcrafts whereof they stood convicted.
For my own part I was not present at any of
them; nor ever had 1 any personal prejudice
against the persons thus brought upon the stage ;
much less, at the surviving relations of those
persons, with and for whom I would be as
hearty a mourner, as any man living in the
world : The Lord comfort them ! But having re-
ceived a command so to do, I can do no other
than shortly relate the chief matters of fact,
which occurred in the trials of some that were
executed, in an abridgment collected out of the
court-papers, on this occasion put into my hands.
.You are to take the truth, just as It was ; and
the truth will hurt no good man. There might
have been more of these : and if some other
worthy hands did not perhaps intend something
further in these collections ; for wdilch cause I
have only singled out four or five, which may
serve to illustrate the way of dealing, wherein
witchcrafts use to be concerned ; and I report
matters, not as an advocate, but as an historian.
" These were some of the gracious words in-
OF FACT, kc. 2»1
serted in the advice, wliich many of llic noi£(h-
bouring ministers did this summer iiumbly lay
before our honourable judges : ' We cannot but
with all thankfulness acknowledge the success,
which the mercii'ul God has given unto the se-
dulous and assiduous endeavours of our honour-
able rulers, to detect the abominable witchcrafts
which have been committed in the country ;
humbly praying that the discovery of those mys-
terious and mischievous wickednesses may be
perfected.' If, in the midst of the many dissat-
isfactions among us, the publication of these
trials may promote such a pious thankfulness
unto God, for justice being so far executed
among us, I shall rejoice that God is glorified ;
and pray that no wrong steps of ours may ever
sully any of his glorious works."
The Indictment of George Burroughs.
Essex ss. Anno Regni Regis Sf Rcgince Willielmi ^ Marice, nunc.
Anglice^ 8fc. quarto.
The jurors for our sovereign lord and lady the king
and queen present, that George Burroughs, late of Fal-
mouth, in the province of the Massachusetts Bay, in New-
England, clerk, the 9th day of May, in the fourth year of
the reign of our sovereign lord and lady William and
Mary, by the grace of God, of England, Scotland, France
and Ireland, king and queen, defenders of the faith, &c.
and divers other days and times, as well before as after,
certain detestable arts, called witchcrafts and sorceries,
wickedly and feloniously hath used, practised and exer-
cised, at and within the township of Salem, in the county
of Essex, aforesaid, in, upon and against one Mary Wol-
cott, of Salem Village, in the county of Essex," single wo-
man ; by which said wicked arts the said Mary Wolcott,
the 9th day of May, in the fourth year abovesaid, and di-
vers other days and times, as well betore as after, was
and is tortured, alllictcd, pined, consumed, wasted and
t5t MATTERS
tormented, against the peace of onr sovereign lord and
lady, the king and queen, and against the form of the
statute in that case made and provided.
Witnesses, Mary Wolcott, Sarah Fibber^ Mercy Le-^is^
Ann Putman, Eliz. Hubbard.
Endorsed by the grand jury, Billa Vera.
There was also a second indictment, for af-
flicting Elizabeth Hubbard. The witnesses to
the said indictment were Elizabeth Hubbard^
Mary Wolcoit and ^^nn Putman.
The third indictment was for afflicting Mercy
Lewis: the witnesses, the said Mercy Lewis,
Mary iVolcott, Elizabeth Hubbard and Ann Put-
man,
The fourth, for acts of witchcraft on Ann
Putman: the witnesses, the said Ann Putman,
Mary Wolcott, Elizabeth Hubbard and Mary
Warren*
The Trial of G. B. as printed in Wonders of the
Invisible World, from p, 94 to 104.
Glad should I have been, if I had never
known the name of this man, oi' never had this
occasion to mention so much as the hrst letters
©f his name; but the gov^ernment requiring
some account of his trial to be inserted in this
took, it becomes me with all obedience to sub-
mit unto the order.
1. This G. B. was indicted for witchcrafts;
and, in the prosecution of the charge against
him, he was accused by fwe or six of the be-
witched, as the author of their miseries; he
was accused by eight of the confessing witches,
as being a head actor at some of their hellish
rendezvous, and who had the promise of being
OF FACT, &c. 233
/
5 king m Satan's kingdom, now going to be erect-
ed ; he was accused by nine persons, for extra-
ordinary lilting, and such feats of strength as
could not be done without a diabolical assist-
ance; and for other such things he was accused,
until about thirty testimonies were brought in
against him; nor were these judged the half of
what might have been considered, for his con-
viction: however, they were enough to fix the
character of a witch upon him, according to the
rules of reasoning, by the judicious Gaule in that
case directed.
2. The court being sensible that the testimo-
nies of the parties bewitched used to have a
room among the suspicions, or presumptions,
brought in against one indicted for witchcraft,
there were now heard the testimonies of several
persons who were most notoriously bewitched,
and every day tortured by invisible hands, and
these now all charged the spectres of G. B. to
have a share in their torments. At the exam-
ination of this G. B. the bewitched people were
grievously harassed with preternatural mischiefs,
which could not possibly be dissembled; and
they still ascribed it unto the endeavours of G.
B. to kill them. And now, upon his trial, one
of the bewitched persons testified, that in her
agonies a little black-haired man came to her,
saying his name was B. and bidding her set her
hand unto a book, which he shewed unto her;
and bragging that he was a conjurer above the
ordinary rank of witches ; that he often perse-
cuted her with the offer of that book, saying,
she should be well, and need fear nobody, if she
V
234 MATTERS
would but sign it : but he inflicted cruel pains
and hurts upon her, because of her denying go
to do. The testimonies of the other suiTerers
concurred with these ; and it was remarkable,
that whereas biting was one of the ways which
the witches used for the vexing of the sufferers,
when they cried out of G. B. biting them, the
print of his teeth would be seen on the flesh of
the complainers; and just such a set of teeth as
G. B's would then appear upon them, which
could be distinguished from those of some other
men's.
Others of them testified, that in their tor-
ments G. B. tempted them to go unto a sacra-
ment, unto which they perceived him with a
sound of trumpet summoning other w^itches ;
who quickly after the sound w^ould come from
all quarters unto the rendezvous. One of them,
falling into a kind of a trance, afterwards affirm-
ed, that G. B. had carried her into a very high
mountain, where he showed her mighty and
glorious kingdoms, and said he w^ould give them
all to her, if she would write in his book ; but
she told him, they were none of his to give, and
refused the motion, enduring much misery for
that refusal.
It cost the court a w^onderful deal of trouble
to hear the testimonies of the sufferers ; for
when they were going to give in their deposi-
tions, they would for a long w^hile be taken with
fits, that made them uncapable of saying any
thing. The chief judge asked the prisoner, who
he thought hindered these witnesses from giving
their testimonies; and he answered, he supposed
OF FACT, &c. 235
it was the devil. That honourable person then
re|jlicd, How comes the devil so loth to iiave
aij) testimony borne against you ? which cast
hnn into very great confusion.
3, It hath been a frequent thing for the be-
witched people to be entertained with appari-
tions of ghosts of murdered people, at the same
time that the spectres of tlie witches trouble.
them. These ghosts do always alfright tlie be-
holders, more than all the other spectral re]>
resentations ; and when they exhibit themselves,
they cry out of being murdered by the witch-
crafts or otiier violences of the persons who are
then in spectre present. It is further consider-
able, that once or twice these apparitions have
been seen by others, at the very same time they
have shown themselves to the bewitched; and
seldom have there been these apparitions, but
w'hen something unusual and suspected hath
attended the death of the party thus appearing.
Some, that have been accused by these appari-
tions, accosting the bewitched people, who had
never heard a word of any such persons ever
being in the world, have, upon a fair examination,
freely and fully confessed the murders of those
very persons, although these also did not know^
how the apparitions had complained of them.
Accordingly several of the bewitched had given
in their testimony, that they had been troubled
\fith the apparitions of two women, who said
they were G. B's two wives ; and that he had
been the death of them; and that the magis-
trates must be told of it, before whom, if B.
Mpon his trial denied it, they did not know but
236 JMATTERS
that they should appear agafn in the court.
Now G. B. had been infamous, for the barbarous
usage of his two successive wives, all the coun-
try over. Moreover, it was testified, the spectre
of G. B. threatening the sufferers, told tliern he
had killed (besides others) mrs. Lawson and her
daughter Ann. And it was noted, that tlrese
were the virtuous wife and daughter of one, at
whom this G. B. might have a prejudice, for
being serviceable at Salem Village, from whence
himself had in ill terms removed some years be-
fore ; and that when they died, which was long
since, there were some odd circumstances about
them, which made some of the attendants there
suspect something of witchcraft, though none
imagined from what quarter it should come.
Well, G. B. being now upon his trial, one of
the bewitched persons was cast into horror at
the ghosts of B's two deceased wives, then ap-
l^earing before him, and crying for vengeance
against him. Hereupon several of the bewitch-
ed persons were successively called in, who all,
not knowing what the former had seen and said,
concurred in their horror of the apparition,
which they affirmed that he had before him.
But he, though much appalled, utterly denied
that he discerned any thing of it, nor w^as it any.
part of his conviction.
4. Judicious v/riters have assigned it a great
place in the conviction of witches, when persons
are impeached by other notorious witches to be
as ill as themselves, especially if the persons
have been much noted for neglecting the wor-
ship of God. Now, as tliere might have been
OF FACT, ^. 237
testimonies enough of G. B's antipathy to prayer,
and the other ordinances ol" God, though by his
proiession singularly obliged thereunto; so there
now came in against the prisoner, the testi mo-
Dies oi' several persons, who conlesscd their own
having been horrible witches, and, ever since
their confessions, had been themselves terribly
tortured by the devils and other witches, even
like the other suiFerers, and therein undergone
the pains of many deaths for their confessions.
These now testified, that G. B. had been at \
witch-meetings with them; and that he was the
person who had seduced and compelled them
into the snares of witchcraft ; that he promised
them fine clothes for doing it; that he brought
poppets to them, and thorns to stick into those
poppets, for the afflicting of other people ; and
that he exhorted them, with the rest of the
crew, to bewitch all Salem Village ; but be sure
to do it gradually, if they would prevail in what
they did.
When the Lancashire witches were condem-
ned, I do not remember that there was any con-
siderable further evidence, than that of the be-
witched, and than that of some that had confes-
sed. We see so much already against G. B.
B>it this being indeed not enough, there were
otlier things to render what had already been
produced credible.
5. A famous divine recites this among the
convictions of a witch; the. testimony of the .
party bewitched, whether pining or dying; to- V
o-ether with the joint oaths of sulhcicnt persons, /\
that have seen certam prodigious pranks, or feats,
238 MATTERS
wrought by the party accused. Now, God had
been pleased so to leave G. B. that he had en-
snared himself, by several instances, which he
had i'ornierly given, of a preternatural strength;
and which were now produced against him. He
was a very puny man, yet he had often done
things beyond the strength of a giant. A gun
of about seven feet barrel, and so heavy that
strong men could not steadily hold it out, with
both hands; there were several testimonies giv-
en in by persons of credit and honour, tliat he
made nothing of taking up such a gun behind the
lock w^ith but one hand, and holding it out, like
a pistol^ at arm's end. G. B. in his vindication
was so foolish as to say, that an Indian was there,
and held it out, at the same time ; whereas, none
of the spectators ever saw any such Indian ; but
they supposed the black man (as the witches
call the devil, and tliey generally say he resem-
bles an Indian) might give him that assistance*
There w^as evidence likewise brought in, that
he made nothing of taking up whole barrels filled
with molasses, or cider, in very disadvantageous
postures, and carrying them off, through the
most diificult places, out of a canoe to the shore.
Yea, there were two testimoDies, that G. B.
with only putting the fore-finger of his right hand
into the muzzle of an heavy gun, a fowling piece
of about six or seven i'eet barrel, lifted up the
gun, and held it out at arm's end ; a gun which
the deponents, though strong men, could not
with both hands lift up, and hold out at the but-
end, as is usual. Indeed one of these witnesses
was over-persuaded by some persons to be out
OF FACT, &c. 23y
ei' the way upon G. B's trial ; but he came after-
wards, with sorrow lor his withch'awinc^, and
gavfe in his testimony, Nor were either oi these
witnesses made use of as evidence in the trial.
There came in several testimonies, relating
to the domestic all'airs of G. B. which had a ve-
ry hard aspect upon him; ar)d not only proved
him a very ill man, but also confirmed the belief
of the character which had been already fasten-
ed on him. 'Twas testified, that, keeping his
two successive wives in a strange kind of sla-
very, he would, when he came home from
abroad, pretend to tell the talk which any had
with them: that he has brought them to the
point of death, by his harsh dealings with his
wives, and then made the people about him to
promise that in case death should happen they
v»'ould say nothing of it : that he used all means
to make his wives write, sign, seal and swear a
covenant never to reveal any of his secrets :
that his wives had privately complained unto
the neighbours about frightly apparitions of evil
spirits, with which their house was sometimes
infested; and that many such things had been
whispered among the neighbourhood. There
were also some other testimonies, relating to
the death of people, whereby the consciences
of an impartial jury were convinced that G. B.
had bewitched the persons mentioned in the
complaints. But I am forced to omit several
such passages in this as well ss m all the suc-
ceeding trials, because the scribes who took no-
tice of them have not supplied me.
7. One Mn Ruck, brother-in-law to this
240 MATTERS
G. B. testified, that G. B. and he himself, aud
his sister, who was G. B's wife, j^oing out for
two or three miles, to gather strawberries,
Ruck, with his sister, the wife of G. B. rode
home very softly, with G. B. on foot, in their
company; G. B. stept aside a little into the
bushes, whereupon they halted and hollowed
for him : he not answering, they went away
homcAvards, with a quickened pace, without
any expectation of seeing him in a considerable
while ; and yet, when they were got near home,
to their astonishment they found him on foot,
with them, having a basket of strawberries.
G. B. immediately then fell to chiding his wife,
on the account of what she had been speaking
to her brother of him on the road; Avhich when
they w^ondered at, he said, he knew their
thoughts. Ruck, being startled at that, made
some reply, intimating that the devil himself
did not know so far ; but G. B. answered, my
God makes known your thoughts unto me.
The prisoner now at the bar had nothing to an-
swer unto what was thus witnessed against him,
that was worth considering; only he said, Ruck
and his wife left a man with him, when they
left him; which Ruck now affirmed to be false;
and when the court asked G. B. what the man's
name was, his countenance was much altered,
nor could he say who it was. But the court
began to think that he then stept aside, only
that by the assistance of the l)lack man he
might put on his invisibility, and in that fascin-
ating mist gratify his own jealous humour, to
hear what they said of him : which trick of
OF FACT, kc. 241
rendering themselves invisible, our witches do
in their conlessions pretend that they sometimes
are masters ol'; and it is the more credible, be-
cause there is demonstration that they ol'ten
render many other things utterly invisible.
8. Faultering, faulty, unconstant and contrary
answers, upon judicial and deliberate examina-
tion, are counted some unlucky symptoms of
guilt in all crimes, especially in witchcrafts.
No^v there never was a prisoner more eminent
for rhem than G. B. both at his examination and
on his trial. His tergiversations, contradictions
and falsehoods were very sensible; he had little
to say, but that he had heard some things, that
he could not prove, reflecting upon the reputa-
tion of some of the witnesses: only he gave in a
paper to the jury, wherein, although he had ma-
ny times before granted, not only that there are
witches, but also that the [)resent sufferings of
the country are the elfects of horrible witch-
crafts, yet he now goes to evince it, that there
neither are, nor ever were, witches, that, hav-
ing made a compact with the devil, can send a
devil to torment other people at a distance.
This paper was transcribed out of.Ady; which
the court presently knew, as soon as they heard
it. But he said, he had taken none of it out of
any book ; for which his evasion afterwards was,
that a gentleman gave him the discourse in a
manuscript, Irom whence he transcribed it.
9. The jury brought him in guilty ; but when
he came to die, he utterly denied the fact, where-
of he had been thus convicted.
21
242 MATTERS
The Indictment of Bridget Bishop.
Essex SB. Anno Regni Regis 8^ Regince, Willielmi 8; Marice, nunc
Jinglice^ 8fc. quarto.
The jurors for our sovereigfn lord and lady the king
and queen present, that Bridget Bishop, alias Oliver, the
wife of Edward Bishop, in Salem, in the county of Essex,
sawyer, the nineteenth day of April, in the fourth year of
the reign of our sovereign lord and lady William and
Mary, by the grace of God, of England, Scotland, France
and Ireland, king and queen, defenders of the faith, &c.
and divers other days and times, as well before as after,
certain detestable arts, called witchcrafts and sorceries,
wickedly and feloniously hath used, practised and exer-
cised, at and within the township of Salem, in the county
of Essex, aforesaid, in, upon and against one Mercy Lew-
is, of Salem V^illage, in the county aforesaid, single wo-
man ; by which said wicked arts the said Mercy Lewis,
the said 19th day of April, in the fourth year abovesaid, and
divers other days and times, as well before as after, was
and is hurt, tortured, afflicted, pined, consumed, wasted
and tormented, against the peace of our sovereign lord
and lady, the king and queen, and against the form of
the statute in that case made and provided.
Endorsed, Billa Vera.
Witnesses, Mercy Lbkdu.^ JVathaniel Ingersoll.^ mr. Sum-
nel Parris^ Thomas Putman. junior, Mary Woicott., junior,
Ann Putman^ junior, EHz. Hubbard., and Abigail Williams.
There was also a second indictment, on the
said Bishop, for afflicting and practising Avitch-
craft on Jlbigail WilUams, Witnesses to the
said indictment were, the said Abigail Williams,
mr. Parris, Nathaniel Ingersoll, Thomas Put-
man, Ann Putman, Mary Wolcott, Elizabeth
Hubbard.
The third indictment was for afflicting Mary
Wolcott; witnesses to which said indictment
•were, Mary Wolcott, Mary Lewis, mr, Samuel
Parris, Nathaniel Ingersoll, Thomas Putman,
OF FACT, kc. 24S
Ann Putman, Elizabctli Hubbard, Abigail Wil-
Hiams.
The fourth indictment was for afflicting Eliza-
beth Hubbard; witnesses to which said indict-
ment were, the said EHzabcth Hubbard, Mercy
Lewis, mr. Parris, Nathaniel Ingersoll, Thomas
Putman, Ann Putman, Mary Wolcott, Abigail
Williams.
The fifth indictment was for afflicting ^nn
Putman; witnesses to which said indictment
were the said Ann Putman, mr. Samuel Parris,
Nathaniel IngersoU, Thomas Putman, Mercy
Lewis, Mary Wolcott, Abigail Williams, Eliza-
beth Hubbard.
The Trial o/* Bridget Bishop, as printed in Won-
ders of the Invisible Worlds June 2, 1692,yrom
p. 104 top, 114.
1. She was indicted for bewitching several
persons in the neighbourhood. The indictment
being drawn up, according to the form in such
cases usual, and pleading not guilty, there were
brought in several persons, who had long under-
gone many kinds of miseries, which were pre-
ternaturally inflicted, and generally ascribed un-
to an horrible witchcraft. There was little oc-
casion to prove the witchcraft, it being evident
and notorious to all beholders. Now to fix the
witchcraft on the prisoner at the bar, the first
thing used was the testimony of the bewitched;
whereof several testified, that the shape of the
prisoner did oftentimes very grievously pinch
them, choke them, bite them, and afflict them;
urging them to write their names in a book,
244 MATTERS
which the said spectre called ours. One of
them did further testily, that it was the shape
of this prisoner, with another, which one day-
took her from her wfieel, and, carrying her to
the river side, threatened there to drown her,
if she did not sign the book mentioned ; which
yet she refused. Others of them did also testify,
that the said shape did, in her threats, brag to
them, that she had been the death of sundry
persons, then by her named. Another testified,
the apparition of ghosts unto the spectre of
Bishop, crying out, You murdered us. About
the truth whereof, there was in the matter of
fact but too much suspicion.
2. It was testified, that at the examination of
the prisoner, before the magistrates, the be-
witched were extremely tortured. If she did
but cast her eyes on them, they were presently
struck down ; and this in such a manner as there
could be no collusion in the business. But upon
the touch of her hand upon them, when they lay
in their swoons, they would immediately revive;
and not upon the touch of any one's else. More-
over, upon some special actions of her body, as
the shaking of her head, or the turning of her
eyes, they presently and painfully fell into the
like postures. And many of the like accidents
now fell out, while she was at the bar ; one at
the same time testifying, that she said, she
could not be troubled to see the afflicted thus
tormented.
3. There was testimony likewise brought in,
that a man striking once at the place where a
feewitched person said the shape of this Bishop
OF FACT, kc. 245
stood, the bewitched cried out that he had torn
her coat, in the place then particularly specifi-
ed; and the woman's coat was found to be torn
in the very place.
4. One Deliverance Hobbs, who had confess-
ed her being a witch, was now tormented by the
spectres for her confession. And she now testi-
tied, that this Bishop tempted her to sigri the
book again, and to deny what she had confessed.
She allirmed, that it was the shape of this priso-
ner whicli whipped her with Iron rods, to com-
pel her thereunto. And she affirmed, that this
bishop was at a general meeting of the witches
in a field, at Salem Village, and there partook
of a diabolical sacrament, In bread and wine, then
administered.
5. To render It further unquestionable, that
the prisoner at the bar was the person truly
charged in this witchcraft, there were produced
many evidences of other witchcrafts, by her
perpetrated. For instance, John Cook testified,
that about five or six years ago, one morning
about sunrise, he was, in his chamber, assaulted
by the shape of this prisoner; which looked on
him, grinned at him, and very much hurt him
with a blow on the side of the head ; and that
on the same day, about noon, the same shape
walked in the room where he was, and an ap-
ple strangely flew out of his hand into the lap
of his mother, six or eight feet from him.
6. Samuel Gray testified, that about fourteen
years ago, he waked on anight, and saw the
room where he lay hill of light ; and that he
then saw plainly a woman between the cradle
21*
X
,246 MATTERS
and the bedside, which looked upon him. He
rose, and it vanished, though he found the doors
all fast. Looking out at the entry door, he saw
the same woman in the same garb again; and
said, In Gocfs name^ ichat do you come for ? He
went to bed, and had the same woman again
assaulting him. The child in the cradle gave a
great screech, and the woman disappeared. It
was long before the child could be quieted ; and
though it were a very likely, thriving child, yet
from this time it pined away, and after divers
months died in a sad condition. He knew not
Bishop, nor her name ; but vfhen he saw her af-
ter this, he knew by her countenance, and ap-
parel, and all circumstances, that it was the
apparition of this Bishop, which had thus trou-
bled him.
7. John Bly and his wife testified, that he
bought a sow of Edward Bishop, the husband
of the prisoner, and was to pay the price agreed
unto another person. This prisoner, being
angry that she was thus hindered from fingering
the money, quarrelled with Bly; soon after
which the sow was taken with strange fits,
jumping, leaping, and knocking her head against
the fence ; she seemed blind and deaf, and
would neither eat nor be sucked. Whereupon
a neighbour said, she believed the creature was
overlooked ; and sundry other circumstances
concurred, which made the deponents believe
tiic.t Bishop had bewitched it.
8. Richard Coman testified, that eight years
ago, as he lay awake in his bed, with a light burn-
ing in the room, he was annoyed with the appari^
OF FACT, &c. 247
tlon of this Bishop, and of two more that were
strangers to him, who came and oppressed him,
so that he could neither stir himself, nor wake
any one else; and that he was the night after
molested again in the like manner, the said Bi-
shop taking him by the tliroat, and pulling him
almost out of the bed. His kinsman offered for
this cause to lodge with him ; and that night, as
they were awake, discoursing together, this Co-
man was once more visited by the guests which
had formerly been so troublesome, his kinsman
being at the same time struck speechless, and
unable to move hand or foot. He had laid his
''sword by him; which those unhappy spectres
did strive much to wrest from him, but he held
too fast for them. He then grew able to call
the people of his house ; but although they
heard him, yet they had not power to speak or
stir, until at last one of tlie people crying out,
What's the matter? the spectres all vanished.
9. Samuel Shattock testified, that in the year
16B0, this Bridget Bishop often came to his
house upon such frivolous and foolish errands,
that they suspected she came indeed with a
purpose of mischief ; presently w^hereupon, his
eldest child, which was of as promising health
and sense as any child of its age, began to droop
exceedingly ; and the oftener that Bishop came
to his house, the worse grew the child. As
the child would be standing at the door, he
would be thrown and bruised against the stones,
by an invisible hand, and in like sort knock his
face against the sides of the house, and bruise it
after a miserable manner. Afterwards this Bi-
248 MATTERS
shop would bring him things to dye, whereof he
could not imagine any use ; and when she paid
him a piece ol' money, the purse and money
were unaccountably conveyed out of a locked
box, and never seen more. The child was im-
mediately hereupon taken with terrible fits,
whereof his friends thought he would have di-
ed ; indeed he did nothing but cry and sleep,
for several months together; and at length his
understanding was utterly taken away. Among
otiier symptoms of an enchantment upon him,
one was, that there was a board in the garden,
whereon he would walk; and all the invitations
in the world would never fetch him off. About
seventeen or eighteen years after, there came a
stranger to Shattock's house, who, seeing the
child, said, This poor child is bewitched; and
yon have a neighbour living not far off who is a
ivitch. He added, Yonr neighbour has had a
falling out with your wife ; and she said in her
heart, your wife is a proud woman^ and she woidd
bring down her pride in this child. He then re-
membered that Bishop had parted from his
wife in muttering and menacing terms, a little
before the child was taken ill. The abovesaid
stranger would needs carry the bewitched boy
with him to Bishop's house, on pretence of
buying a pot of cider. The woman entertained
him in a furious manner; and flew also upon
the boy, scratching his face till the blood came,
and saying, Thou rogue, what ! dost thou bring
this fellow here to plague me ? Now it seemi the
man had said, before he went, that he would
fetch blood of her. Ever after the boy was
OF FACT, H. 24d
foUovverl by grievo.is fit!=», which the doctors
theinseives i^enerally .iscribed unto witCLvil't ;
and wherein fie would be thrown still int.» fire
or water, if he were not constantly looked dlfer;
and it was verily believed that Bishop was the
cause of it.
10. John Louder testified, that upon some
little controversy with B sh ip about her fowls,
going well to bed, he awaked in the night by-
moonlight, and clearly saw the likeness of this
woman grievously oppressing him ; in which
miserable condition siie held him, unable to help
himself, till near day. He told Bishop of this,
but she utterly denied it, and tiireatened him
very much. Quickly after this, being at home
on a Lord's day, witli the doors shut about him,
he saw a black pig approach him ; at which he
going to kick, it vanished away. Immediately
after, sitting down, he saw a black thing jump
in at the window, and come and stand before
him : the body was like that of a monkey, the
feet like a cock's, but the face much like a
man's. He being so extremely frighted that
he could not speak, this monster spok6 to him,
and said, / am a messenger sent unto you, for 1
understand that you are in some trouble of mindj
and if you will be ruled by me, you shall want for
nothing in this world. Whereupon he endea-
voured to clap his hands upon it ; but he could
feel no substance, and it jumped out of the win-
dow again ; but immediately came in by the
porch, though the doors were shut, and said,
You had better take my counsel He then struck
at it with a stick, but struck only the ground-
250 MATTERS
sel, and broke the stick. The arm with which
he struck was presently disenabled, and it van-
ished away. He presently went out at the back
door, and spied this Bishop, in her orchard, go-
ing towards her house ; but he had not power
to set one foot forward unto her. Whereupon,
returning into the house, he was immediately
accosted by the monster he had seen before ;
which goblin was now §^^^K ^^ % ^^ ^^^ '
w^iereat he cried out, The whole armour of God
he between me and you ! so it sprang back, and
flew over the apple-tree, shaking many apples
off the tree in its flying over. At its leap, it
flung dirt with its feet against the stomach of
the man; whereon he was then struck dumb,
and so continued for three days together. Uf>
on the producing of this tetimony, Bishop denied
that she knew this deponent. Yet their two
orchards joined, and they had often had their
little quarrels for some years together.
11. William Stacy testified, that receiving
money of this Bishop for work done by him, he
was gone but about three rods from her, and,
looking lor his money, found it unaccountably
gone from him. Some time after, Bishop asked
him whether his father would grind her grist
for her. He demanded why. She replied, Be-
cause folks count me a witch. He answered,
No question but he will grind it for you. Being
then gone about six rods from her, with a small
load in his cart, suddenly the oti' wheel slumpt,
and sunk down into an hole, upon plain ground,
so that the deponent was forced to get help for
the recovering of the wheel. But stepping back
OF FACT, &c. 251
to look for the hole which might give him this
disaster, there was none at ail to be found.
Some time after he was awakened in the night;
but it seemed as hght as day ; and he perfectly
saw the shape of this Bisliop in the room, trou-
bling him ; but upon her going out, all was dark
again. He charged Bishop afterwards with
it, and she denied it not, but was very angry.
Quickly after, this deponent having been threat-
ened by Bishop, as he was in a dark night going
to the barn, he was very suddenly taken or lilt-
ed up from the ground, and thrown against a
stone wall; alter that he was again hoisfed up,
and thrown down a bank, at the end of his house.
After this, again passing by this Bishop, his horse,
Avith a small load, striving to draw, ail his gears
flew to pieces, and the cart fell down; and this
deponent going then to lift a bag of corn, of
about two bushels, could not lift it with all his
might.
Many other pranks of this Bishop, this depo-
nent Was ready to testify. He also testified,
that he verily believed tlie said Bishop was the
instrument of his daughter Priscilla's death; of
Avhich suspicion, p^^egnant reasons were assigned.
i2. To crown all, John Bly and William Bly
testified, that, being employed by Bridget
Bishop to help take down the cellar-wall of the
old house, wherein she formerly lived, they did
in holes of the said old wall find several poppets
made up of rags and hogs' bristles, with head-
less pins in them, the points being outward:
whereof she could now give no account unto
the court, that was reasonable or tolerable.
252 MATTERS
13. One thing that made against the prisoner
was, her beaig evidcntlj convicted of gross Ijing
in the court, several times, while she vi^as mak-
ing her plea. But besides this, a jur} of wo-
men found a preternatural teat upon her body;
but upon a second search, within three tyrkmr
hours, there was no such thing to be seen. There
was also an account of other people, whom this
woman had afflicted; and there might have
been many more, if they had been inquired ibr;
but there was no need of them.
14. There was one very strange thing more,
with which the court was newly entertained.
As this- woman was, under a guard, passing by
the great and spacious meeting house of Salem,
she gave a look towards the house; and imme-
diately a daemon, invisibly entering the meeting-
house, tore down a part of it; so that thcuo^h
there were no person to be seen there, yet the
people, at the noise running in, found a boeid,
which was strongly fastened with several nails,
transported uuto another quarter of the house.
The Indictment of Susanna JMartin,
Essex ss. Anno Regni Rcg->s S,- Reg^nce JVilliehni 8f Marios, nunc
Angtlice^ Sfc. quarto. —
The jurors for our snverf ^gn lord and lady the king and
queen present, that Susanna Martin, of Amesbury, in the
connty of Essex, widow, the second day of May, in the
fonrth year of the reign of our sovereign lord and lady
William and Mary, by the grace of God, of England. Scot-
land, Franco and Ireland, king and queen, defenders oithe
faith, &LC. and divers other days and times, as well before
as after, certain detestable arts, called witchcrafts and sor-
ceries, wickedly and felcniousiy hath used, practised and
exercised, at and wathin the township of Salem, in the
county of Essex, aforesaid, in, upon and against one Mary
OF FACT, &c. 25S
Wolcott, of Salem Village, in (he county of Es'^ftx, single
woman ; by which said wicked arts the said Mary Wolcott,
the second day of May, in the fourth year aforesaid, and
at divers other days and times, as well l)efore as after,
was and is tortured, atflicted, pined, consumed, wasted and
tormented ; as also tor sundry other acts of witchcraft by
sad Susanna Martin committed and done before and since
that time, against the peace of our sovereign lord and
lady, William and Mary, king and' queen of Kngland, their
crown and dignity, and against the form of the statute, in
that case made and provided.
lie turned by the grand jury, Billa vera.
Witnesses — Sarah Vibber^ Mary Wolcoti^ Samuel Parrisj
Elizabeth Hubbard and Mercy Lewis.
The second indictment was for afflicting Mer-
cy Lewis. Witnesses — Samuel Parris, Ann Put-
man, Sarah Vibber, Elizabeth Hubbard, Mary
Wolcott and Mercy Lewis.
The Trial of SusAH^x Martin, June 29, 1692/
as is printed in Wonders of the Invisible World,
from p. 1^4 to p. 1 16.
* 1. Susanna Martin pleading not guilty to the
indictment of witchcraft brought in against her,
there were produced the evidences of many
persons very sensibly and grievt^usly bewitched,
who all complained of the prisoner at the bar,
as the person Avhom they believed the cause of
their miseries. And now, as well as in the other
trials, there was an extraordinary endeavour by
witchcrafts, with cruel and frequent fits, to hin-
der the poor sufferers from giving in their com-
plaints ; which the court was forced with much
patience to obtain, by much waiting and watch-
ing for it.
There was now also an account given of what
had passed at her first examination before the
22
254 MATTERS
magistrates ; the cast of her eye then striking
the afflicted people to the ground, whether they
saw that cast or no. There were these among
other passages between the magistrates and the
examinant :
Magistrate, Pray, what ails these people ?
Martin. I don't know.
Mag. But, what do you think ails them ?
Martin. I do not desire to spend my judgment
upon it.
Maxr, Don't you think they are bewitched?
Martin. No, I do not think they are.
Mag. Tell us your thoughts about them,
then.
Martin. No, my thoughts are my own when
they are in, but when they are out they are
another's. Their master
Mag. Their master! Who do you think is
their master ?
Martin. If they be dealing in the black art,
you may know- as well as I.
Mag. Well, what have you done towards
this }
Martin. Nothing at all.
Mag. Why, 'tis you or your appearance.
Martin. I can't help it.
Mag. Is it not your master ? How comes
your appearance to hurt these ?
Martin. How do I know ? He that appeared
in the shape of Samuel, a glorified saint, may ap-
pear in any one's shape.
It was then also noted in her, as in others
like her, that if the afflicted wont to approach
her, they were flung down to the ground ; and
OF FACT, &c. 25&
Nvheh she was asked the reason of it, she said, I
cannot tell; it may be the devil bears me more
malice than another.
The court accounted tlicniselvcs alarmed by
these things to inquire further into the conversa-
tion of the prisoner, and see what there might
occur to render these accusations further cred-
ible. Whereupon John Allen, of Salisbury,
testified, tiiat he refusing, because of the weak-
ness of his oxen, to cart some staves at the request
of this Martin, she was displeased at it, and said,
it had been as good that he had, for his oxen
should never do him much more service. Where-
upon this deponent said, Dost thou threaten me,
fhoxx old witch ? I'll throw thee into the brook;
which to avoid, she flew over the bridge, and
escaped. 13ut as he was going home, one of his
oxen tired, so that he was forced to unyoke him
that he might get him home. He then put his
oxen, with many more, upon Salisbury-beach,
^vhere cattle used to get flesh. In a few days,
all the oxen upor) the beach were found by
their tracks to have run unto the mouth of
Merrimack-river, and not returned ; but the next
day they were found come ashore upon Plum-
island. They that sought them used all imagina-
ble gentleness; but they would still run away
with a violence that seemed wholly diabolical,
till they came near the mouth of Merrimack
river, when they ran right into the sea, swim-
ming as far as they could be seen. One of them
then swam back again, with a switfness amazing
to the beholders, who stood ready to receive
him, and help up his tired carcass ; but the beast
^56 MATTERS
ran furiously up into the island, and from thence
through the marshes, up into Nevvbury-town, and
30 up into the woods ; and after a while was
found near Amesbury. So that, of fourteen
good oxen, there was only this saved : the rest
were all cast up, some in one place, and some in
another, drowned.
4. John Atkinson testified, that he exchanged
a cow with a son of Susanna Martin, whereat
she muttered, and was unwilling he should have
it. Going to receive this cow, though he ham-
stringed her, and haltered her, she of a tame
creature grew so mad, that they could scarce
get her along. She broke all the ropes that
TYere fastened unto her; and though she was
tied fast unto a tree, yet she made her escape,
and ofave them such further trouble, as they
could ascribe to no cause but witchcraft.
5. Bernard Peache testified, that, being in bed,
on a Lord's-day night, he heard a scrabbling at
the window, whereat he then saw Susanna Mar-
tin come in, and jump down upon the floor. She
took hold of this deponent's feet, and, drawing
his body up into an heap, she lay upon him near
two hours; in all which time he could neither
speak nor stir. At length, when he could begin
to move, he laid hold on her hand, and pulling
it up to his mouth, he bit three of hcv fingers,
as he judged, to the bone ; whereupon she went
from the chamber down the stairs, out at the
door. This deponent thereupon called unto the
people of the house to advise them of what pas-
sed; and he himself followed her. The peo-
ple saw her not; but there being a bucket at
OF FACT, kc. 2^7
the lei't hand of the door, there was a drop ol
blood on it, and several more drops of blood up-
on the snow, newly fallen abroad. There was
hkewise the print of her two feet, just without
the thrcsliold; but no more sign of any footing
further off.
At another time this deponent was desired by
the prisoner to come to husking of corn, at her
house ; and she said, If he did not cotne, it were
better that he did. He went not ; but the night
following, Susanna Martin, as he judged, and
another, came towards him. One of them said,
Here he is ; but he, having a quarterstaff, made
a blow at them : the roof of the barn broke his
blow; but, following them to the window, he
made another blow at them, and struck them
down; yet they got up, and got out, and he saw
no more of them.
About this time, there was a rumour about
the town, that Martin had a broken head ; but
the deponent could say nothing to that.
The said Peache also testified, the bewitch-
ing of cattle to death, upon Martin's discontents.
6. Robert Downer testified, that this prisoner
being some years ago prosecuted at court for a
witch, he then said unto her, he believed she was
a witch. Whereat she being dissatisfied, said,
that some she-devil would shortly fetch him away ;
which words were heard by others, as well as
himself. The night following, as he lay in his
bed, there came in at the window, the likeness
of a cat, which fiew upon him, and took fast
hold of his throat, lay on him a considerable
while, and almost killed him; at length he re-
22*
255 MATTERS
membered what Susanna Martin had threatened
the day before, and with much striving he cried
out, Avoids thou she-devil ; in the name of God
the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, avoid :
whereupon it leit him, leaped on the floor, and
flew out at the window.
And there also came in several testimonies,
that, be lore ever Downer spoke a word of this
accident, Susanna Martin and her family had re-
lated how this Downer had been iiandled.
7. John Kembal testified, that Susanna Mar-
tin, upon a causeless disgust, had threatened
him about a certain cow of his, that she should
never do him any more good, and it came to
pass accordingly ; for soon after the cow was
found stark dead on the dry ground, without
any distemper to be discerned upon her ; upon
which he was followed with a strange death
upon more of his cattle ; w-hereol he lost, in one
spring, to the value of 30/. But the said John
Kembal had a further testimony to give in against
the prisoner, which was truly admirable. Be-
ing desirous to furnish himself with a dog, he
applied himself to buy one cf this Martin, who
had a bitch with whelps in her house ; but she
not letting him have his choice, he said he
would supply himself then at one Biezdel's.
Havino; marked a puppy which he liked at
Biezdel's, he met George Martin, the husband
of the prisoner, going by, who asked whether
he would not have one of his wife's puppies;
and he answered, no. The same day one Ed-
mund Eliot, being at Martin's house, heard
(jeorge Martin relate where this Kembal had
OK FACT, 4-c. 259
been, and what he had said; whereupon Susan-
na M irtin rephcd, If I live P II give him puppies
enough. Within a lew days alter this, Kembal
coming out ol'tlie woods, there arose a httle black
eloud in the N. W. and Kcmbal immediately
felt a force upon him, which made him not able
to avoid running upon the stumps of trees that
were before him, although he had a broad,
plain cart-w'ay before him ; but though he had
his axe on his shoulder to endanger him in his
falls, he could not forbear going out of his way
to tumble over them. When he came below
the meeting-house, there appeared to him a
little thing like a puppy, of a darkish colour,
and it shot backwards and forwards between his
legs. He had the courage to use all possible
endeavours to cut it with his axe, but he could
not hit it; the puppy gave a jump from him,
and went, as to him it seemed, into the ground.
Going a litUe further, there appeared unto him
a black puppy, somewhat bigger than the first,
but as black as a coal. Its motions were quick-
er than those of his axe. It flew at his belly,
and at his throat, so over his shoulders one
way, and then over his shoulders another way.
His heart now began to fail him, and he thought
the dog would have tore his throat out ; but
he recovered himself, and called upon God in
his distress, and naming the name ol' .Tesus
Christ, it vanished away at once. The depo-
nent spoke not one word of tliese accidents, for
fear of ailrighting his wife. But the next morn-
ing, Edmund Eliot going into Martin's house,
this woman asked hioi where Kembal was.
S60 . MATTERS
He replied, At home, a-bed, for ought he knew.
She returned, They say he was frighted last
night. Ehot asked, With what? She answered,
With puppies. Ehot asked where she heard
of it, for he had heard nothing of it. She re-
joined. About the town ; although Kembal had
mentioned the matter to no creature living.
8. Wilham Brown testified, that Heaven
having blessed him with a most pious and pru-
dent wife, this wife of his one day met with
Susanna Martin ; but when she approached just
unto her, Maitin vanished out of sight, and left
her extremely atfrighted. After which time
the said Martin often appeared unto her, giving
her no htttle trouble ; and when she did come,
she was visited with birds, that sorely pecked
and pricked her ; and sometimes a bunch like a
pullet's egg would rise on her throat, ready to
choke her, till she cried out, Witch^ you shari^t
choke me I While this good woman was in this
extremity, the church appointed a day of prayer
on her behalf; whereupon the trouble ceased;
she sav^^ not Martin as formerly ; and the church,
instead of their fast, gave thanks for her deliv-
erance. But a considerable while after, she
being summoned to give in some evidence at the
court against this Martin, quicklv tliis Martin
came behind her, while she was milking her
cow, and said unto her. For thy dcjaniing me at
courts ni make thee the miserablest creature in the
ivor/d. Soon after which, she lell into a strange
kind of distemper, and became horribly frantic,
and uneatable of anv reasonable, action ; the
physicians declaring tnat her distemper was
Oh FACT, kc. 26 i
preternatural, and that some devil had certainly
bewitciied iier ; and in that condition slie now
remained.
9. Sarah Atkinson testified, that Susanna
Martin came from Amesbiny, to their house at
Newbury, in an extraordinary season, when it
was not fit for any one to travel. She came (as
she said to Atkinson) all that long way on ioot.
She bragged and showed how dry she was ; nor
could it be perceived that so much as the soles
of her shoes were w^et. Atkinson was amazed
at it, and professed that she should herself have
been wet up to the knees, ii'she had then come so
far; but Martin replied, she scorned to be drab-
bled. It \va3 nofr^d that this testimony, upon
her trial, cast her into a very singular confusion.
10. John Pressy testified, that being one even-
ing very unaccountably bewildered near a field
of Martin, and several times as one under an
enchantment, returning to the place he had left,
at length he saw a marvellous light, about the
bigness of an half bushel, near two rods out of
the way. He went and struck at it with a stick,
and laid it on with all his might. He gave it
near forty blows, and felt it a palpable substance.
But, going from it, his heels were struck up,
and he was laid with his back on the ground ;
sliding, as he thought, into a pit ; from wiience
he recovered, by taking hold on a bush ; al-
though afterwards he could find no such pit in
the place. Having after his recovery gone five
or six rods, he saw Susanna Martin standing on
his left hand, as the light had done before ; but
they changed no words with one another. He
262 * MATTERS
could scarce find his house in his return ; but at
length he got home, extremely affrighted. The
next day it was upon inquiry understood, that
Martin was in a miserable condition, by pains
and hurts that were upon her.
It was further testified by this deponent, that
after he hall given in some evidence against Su-
sanna Martin many years ago, she gave him
foul words about it, and said, he should never
prosper ; more particularly^ that he should never
have more than two cows : that thou<rh he were
ever so likely to have more^ yft he should never
have them ; and that, from that yevy day to
this, namely for twenty years together, he could
never exceed that number, bi^t oom^ ctr-an^o
thing or other «t»ll prevented his having any
more
11. Jarvis Ring testified, that about seven
years ago he was oftentimes grievously oppres-
sed in ihe night, but saw not who troubled him,
until at lengik he, lying perfectly awake, plainly
saw Susanna Martin approach him : she came
to him, and forcibly bit him by the finger ; so
that the print of the bite is now, so long after,
to be seen upon him.
12. But, besides all these evidences, there
was a most wonderful account of one Joseph
Ring produced on this occasion. This man has
been strangely carried about, by daemons, from
one witch-meeting to another, for near two
years together ; and for one quarter of this time
they made him and kept him dumb, though he
is now again able to speak. There was one
T. H. whoj having, as 'tis judged, a design of
OF FACT, &c. 263
engaging this Joseph Ring in a snare of devil-
isDi, contrived a wile to bring this Rin^ two
shilhngs in debt unto Kim. Alter wards this
poor man would be visited with unknown sha[)es,
and this T. H. sometimes among them : which
would force him away with them, unto unknown
places, where he saw meetings, feasting, dan-
cings; and alter his return, wherein they hur-
ried iiim along through the air, he gave demon-
strations to the neighbours, that he had been
so transported. When he was brought unto
these hellish meetings, one of the first thmgs
they still did unto him was, to give him a knock
on the back, whereupon he was ever, as if bound
with chains, uncapable of stirring out of the
place, till they should release him. He related,
that there often came to him a man, who pre-
sented him a book, whereto he would have him
set his hand ; promising him that he should then
have even what he would ; and presenting him
wth all the delectable things, persons and places
that he could imagine ; but he refusing to sub-
scribe, the business would end with dreadful
shapes, noises and screeches, which almost
scared him out of his wits. Once, with a book,
there was a pen offered him, and an inkhorn,
with liquor in it, that seemed like blood ; but he
never touched it.
This man did now affirm, that he saw the
prisoner at several of these hellish rendezvous.
JVote. This woman was one of the most im-
pudent, scurrilous, wicked creatures, in the
world : and she now, throughout her whole trial,
discovered herself to be such an one. Yet when
264 SCATTERS
she was asked what she had to say for herseh"^
her chief plea was, that she had led a most
virtuous and holy Hfe.
The Indictment of Elizabeth How.
Essex ss. jinno Regni Regis £( Reginai Willielmi Sf Marice, nunc
Angliit^ 8fc. quarto. — -
The jurors for our sovereign lord and lady the king
and queen present, that Elizabi^th How, wife of James
How, of Ipswich, in the county of Essex, the thirty-first
day of May, in the fourth year of the reign ot our sove-
reign lord and lady VViljiam and Mary, by the gn\ce of
God, of England, Scotland, France and Ireland, king and
queen, defenders of the faith, &c. and divers other days
and times, as well before as after, certain detestable arts,
called witchcrafts and sorceries, wickedly and feloniously
hath used, practised and exercised, at and within the town-
ship of Salem, in the county of Essex, aforesaid, in, upon
and against one Mary Wolcott, of Salem Village, in the
county aforesaid, single woman ; by which said wicked
arts the said Mary Wolcott, the said thirty-first day of
May, in the fourth year abovesaid, and divers other days
and times, as well before as after, was and is tortured,
afflicted, pined, consumed, wasted and tormented ; and
also for sundry other acts of witchc rails, by said Elizabeth
How committed and done before and since that time,
ao"ainst the peace of our sovereign lord and lady, the
king and queen, and against the form of the statute in
that case made and provided.
Witnesses — Mary Wolcott^ Ann Putman^ Abigail Wil-
liams^ Samuel Pearly^ and his wife Rnth., Joseph Andrews^
and wife Sarah^ John Sherrin^ Joseph Safford^ Francis Lane,
Lydia Foster^ Isaac Cummins^ junior.
There was also a second indictment for af-
flicting JMercij Lewis. Witnesses— Mercy Lew-
is, Mary Wolcott, Ann Putman, Sarnnei Pearly
and wife, Joseph Andrews and wile, John Sher-
rin, Joseph Saifordj Francis Lane, Lydia Foster.
OF FACT, &c. 266
The Trial of EuzABETH How, June 30, 1692;
as is printed in Wonders of the Invisible
Worlds from p. } 26 to p. i32, inclusively.
1. Elizabeth How, pleading not guilty to the
indictment of witchcralts then charged upon
her, the court, according to the usual proceed-
ing of the courts in England in such cases, be-
gan with hearing the deposition of several af-
flicted people, who were grievously tormented
by sensible and evident witchcrafts, and all com-
plained of the prisoner as the cause of their
trouble. It was also found that the sufferers
were not able to bear her look; as likewise that
in their greatest swoons they distinguished her
toucli from other people's, being thereby raised
out of them. And there was other testimony
of people, to whom the shape of this How gave
trouble nine or ten years ago.
2. It has been a most usual thing for the be-
witched persons, at the same time that the
spectres representing the witches troubled
them, to be visited with apparitions of ghosts,
pretending to have been murdered by the
witches then represented. And sometimes the
confessions of the witches afterwards acknowl-
edged those very murders, which these appa-
ritions charged upon them, although they had
never heard what information had been given
by the sutterers. There were such apparitions
of ghosts testified by some of the present
sufTerers, and the ghosts affirmed that this How
had murdered them: which things were feared,
but not proved.
3. This How had made some attempts af
23
266 MATTERS
joining to the church at Ipswich, several years
ago ; but she Avas denied an admission into that
holy society, partly through a suspicion of witch-
craft, then urged against her. And there now
came in testimony of preternatural mischiefs
pr-esently befalling some that had been instru-
mental to debar her from the communion where*
upon she was intruding.
4. There was a particular deposition of Jo-
seph Safford, that his wife had conceived an
extreme aversion to this How, on the reports
of her witchcrafts ; but How one day taking- her
by the hand, and saying, I believe you are not ig-
norant of the great scandal that I lie under by an
£vil report raised upon me, she immediately, un-
reasonably, and unpersuadably, even like one
enchanted, began to take this woman's part.
How being soon after propounded, as desiring
an admission to the table of the Lord, son'e of
the pious brethren were unsatisfied about her.
The elders appointed a meeting, to hear mat-
ters objected against her ; and no arguments in
the world could hinder this goodwife Safford
from going to the lecture. She did indeed pro-
mise, with much ado, that she would not go to
the church-meeting ; yet she could not refrain
going thither also. How's affairs were so can-
vassed, that she came off rather guilty, than
cleared ; nevertheless goodwife Safford could
not forbear taking her by the hand, and saying,
Though you are condemned before men, you are
justified before God. She was quickly taken
in a very strange manner; frantic, raving, rag-
ing, and crying out, Goody How must come into
OF FACT, kc. 267
ihe church; she is a precious saint ; and tJiough
she be condemned before nien^ she is justijied bejore
God, So she continued for the space of two or
thr^e hours, und then fell Into a trance. But,
coming to herself, she cried out, Ha! I icas mis-
taken I al'tervvards again repeated, Ha ! I was
mistaken! Being asked bj a stander-by where-
in, she replied, I thou<fht goody How had been a
precious saint of God, But now I see she is a witch:
she has bewitched me and my child, and we shall
never be well till there be testimony for her, that she
may be taken into the church.
And How said, afterwards, That she was very
sorry to see Safford at the church-meeting mention-
ed. Saiford, after this, declared hersefto be af-
flicted by the shape of How, and that from that
shape she endured many miseries,
5. John How, brother to the husband of the
prisoner, testified, that he refusing to accompa-
ny the prisoner unto her examination as was by
her desired, immediately some of his cattle were
bewitched to death, leaping three or four feet
high, turning about, squeaking, faUing and dying
at once; and going to cut off an ear, for an use
that might as well perhaps have been omitted,
tiie hand wherein he held his knife was taken
very numb; and so it remained, and full of pain,
for several days, being not well at this very time.
And he suspected this prisoner for the author
of it.
6. Nehemiah Abbot testified, that unusual
and mischievous accidents would befall his cat-
tle, whenever he had any difference with this
prisoner. Once particularly she wished his ox
268 MATTERS
choked ; and within a Httle while that ox was^
choked with a turnip in his throat. At another
time, refusing to lend his horse at the request
of her daughter, the horse was in a preternatu-
ral manner abused. ' And several other odd
things of that kind were testified.
7. There came in testimony, that one good-
wife Sherwin, upon some difference with How,
was bewitched, and that she died charging this
How of having 'an hand in her death; and that
other people had their barrels of drink unac-
countably mischiefed, spoiled, and spilt, upon
their displeasing her.
The things in themselves were trivial; but
there being such a course of them, it made them
the more to be considered. Among others,
Martha Wood gave Jier testimony, that a little
after her father had been employed in gather-
ing an account of this How's conversation, they
once and again lost great quantities of drink out
of their vessels, in such a manner as they could
ascribe to nothing but witchcraft; as also that
How giving her some apples, when she had eat-
en of them she was taken with a yery strange
kind of a maze, insomuch that she knew not
what she said or did.
8. There was likewise a cluster of depositions,
that one Isaac Cummins refusing to lend his mare
to the husband of this How, the mare was with-
in a day or two taken in a strange condition.
The beast seemed much abused, being bruised,
as if she had been running over the rocks, and
marked where the bridle went, as if burnt with
a red hot bridle. Moreover, one using a pipe
OF FACT, Lc. 2G.d
of tobacco for the cure of the beast, a bhie flame
issued out of her, took hold of her hair, and not
only spread and burnt on her, but it also flew
upwards towards the roof of the barn, and had
hke to liave set the bani on fire. And the mare
died very suddenly.
9. Timothy Pearly and his wife testified, not
only that unaccountable mischiefs befel their
cattle upon their having dilFercnces with this
prisoner, but also that they had a daughter de-
stroyed by witchcrafts ; which daughter still
charged How as the cause of her affliction; and
it was noted that she would be struck down
whenever How was spoken of. She was often
endeavoured to be thrown into the tire, and into
the water, in her strange fits ; though her father
had corrected her for charging How with be-
witching her, yet (as was testified by others also)
she said she was sure of it, and must die stand-
ing to it. Accordingly she charged How to the
very death; and said, Though How could afflict
and torment her body^ yet she could not hurt her
soul, and that the truth of this matter would appear
when she should be dead and gone,
10. Francis Lane testified, that being hired
by the husband of this How to get him a parcel
of posts and rails, this Lane hired John Pearly
to assist him. This prisoner then told Lane,
that she believed the posts and rails would not
di),. because John Pearly helped him; but that
if he had gotten them alone without John Pear-
ly's help, they might have done well enough.
\V lien James Huw came to receive his posts and
rails of Lane, How taking them up by the ends,
23*
£td MATTERS
they, though good and sound, yet unaccountably
broke off, so that Lane was forced to get thirty
or forty more. And this prisoner being inform-
ed of it, she said, she told him so before^ because-
Pearly helped about them,
11. Afterwards there came in the confessions
of several other (penitent) witches, which af-
firmed this How to be one of those who with
them had been baptized ^by the devil in the ri-
ver, at Newbury-falls ; before which, he made
them there kneel down by the brink of the river,
and worship him.
The Indictment oj* JWartha Carrier,
Essex ss. Anno Regni Regis 8f Reginas IVillielmi 8f Mari<£, nunc
Angelioei 8fc. quarto. —
The jurors for our sovereign lord and ladj the king and
queen present, that Martha Carrier, wife of Thomas Car-
rier, of Andover, in the county of Essex, husbandnjan, the
thirty-first day of May, in the fourth year of the reign of
our sovereign lord and ladj William and Mary, hy the
grace of God, of England, Scotland, France and Ireland,
king and queen, defenders of the faith, &c. and divers
other days and times, as well before as after, certain de-
testable arts, called witchcrafts and sorceries, wickedly
*nd feloniously hath used, practised and exercised, at and
within the township of Salem, in the county of Essex,
aforesaid, in, upon and against one Mary VVoicott, of Saiem
Village, in the county of Essex, single woman ; by which
said wicked arts the said Mary VVoicott, the thirty tirst
day of May, in the fourth year aforesaid, and at divers
other days and times, as well before as after, was and
is tortured, afflicted, pined, consumed, wasted and torment-
ed ; against the peace of our sovereign lord and lady,
William and Mary, king and queen of England, their
crown and dignity, and against the form of the statute, in
that case made and provided.
Witnesses— JV/ary M'okotU Elizabeth Hubbard. .^n-$
Pirt?nan>
of FACT, Lq. 271
There was also a second indictment lor afflict-
ing Elizabeth Hubbard., bj witclicrart. W itnes-
sos — Elizabeth Hubbard, Mary Wolcott, Ann
Putman, Mary Warren.
The Trial o/* Martha Carrikr, August 2, 1692 ;
as may be seen in Wonders of the Invisible
World, from p. 132, to p, 138.
1. Martha Carrier was indicted for the be-
witching of certain persons, according to the
form usual in such cases. Pleading not guilty to
her indictment, there were first brought in a
considerable number of the bewitched persons;
who not only made the court sensible of an hor-
rid witchcraft committed upon them, but also
deposed, that it was Martha Carrier, or her
shape, that grievously tormented them, by bit-
ing, pricking, pinching and choking them. It
was further deposed, that while tliis Carrier
was on her examination before the magistrates,
the poor people were so tortured, that every
one expected their death u|>on the very spot 5
but that upon the binding of Carrier they were
cased. Moreover the looks of Carrier then laid
the afflicted people for dead; and her touch, if
her eyes at the same time were off' them, raised
them again. Which things were also now seen
upon her trial. And it was testified, that upon
the mention of some havmg their necks twisted
almost round by the shape of this Carrier, she
replied. Its no matter, though their necks had been
Hoisted quite off",
2. Before the trial of this prisoner, several of
her own children had frankly and fully confessed,
27« MATTERS
not only that they were witches themselves, but
that their mother had made them so. This
confession they made with great shows of re-
pentance, and with much demonstration of truth.
They related place, time and occasion; they
gave an account of journeys, meetings and mis-
chiefs by them performed, and were very credi-
ble in wiiat they said. Nevertheless, this evi-
dence v;as not produced against the prisoner at
the bar, in as much as there was other evidence
enough to proceed upon.
3. Benjamin Abbot gave in his testimony, that,
last March was a twelve-month, this Carrier was
very angry with him, upon laying out some land
near her husband's. Her expressions in this an-
ger were, that she would stick as close to Abbot
as the bark stuck to the tree; and that he
should repent of it before seven years came to
an end, so as doctor Prescot should never cure
him. These words were heard by others be-
sides Abbot himself, who also heard her say,
she w^ould hold his nose as close to the grind-
stone as ever it v*'as held since his name was
Abbot. Presently after this he was taken with
a swelling in his foot, and then with a pain in
his side, and exceedingly tormented. It bred a
sore, whicti was lanced by Dr. Prescot, and se-
veral gallons of corruption ran out of it. For
six weeks it continued very bad ; and then anoth-
er sore bred in his groin, which was also lanced
by Dr. Prescot. Another sore bred in his groin,
which was likewise cut, and put him to very
great misery. He was brought to death's door,
and so remained until Carrier was taken and car-
OF FACT, &c. 27;i
ried away by the constable ; IVoni which very
day he began to mend, and so grew better every
day, and is well ever since.
Sarah Abbot also, his wife, testified, that her
husband was not only all this while alflicted in
his body, but also that strange, extraordinary
and unaccountable calamities befel his cattle;
their death being such as they could guess no
natural reason for.
4. Allin Toothaker testified, that Richard,
the son of Martha Carrier, having some diffe-
rence with him, pulled him down by the hair of
the head; when he rose again, he was going to
strike at Richard Carrier, but fell down flat on
his back to the ground, and had not power to
stir hand or foot, until he told Carrier he yield-
ed; and then he saw the shape of Martha Car-
rier go off his breast.
This Toothaker had received a wound in the
wars; and he now testified, that Martha Car-
rier told him, he should never be cured. Just
before llie apprehending of Carrier, he could
thrust a knitting-needle into his wound four inch-
es deep; but presently after her being seized,
he was thoroughly healed.
He further testified, that when Carrier and
he sometimes were at variance, she would clap
her hands at him, and say, he should get nothing
by it. Whereupon he several times lost his cat-
tle bv stranjre deaths, whereof no natural causes
could be given.
5. John Roger also testified, that, upon the
threatening words of this malicious Carrier, his
cattle would be strangely bewitched; as was
more particularly then described.
S74 MATTERS
6. Samuel Preston testified, that about tvvd
years ago, having some difference with Martha
Carrier, he lost a cow in a strange, preternatural,
Unusual manner; and about a month after this^
the said Carrier having again some difference
with him, she told him he had lately lost a cow,
and it should not be long before he lost another;
which accordingly came to pass; for he had a
thriving and weil-kept cow, which without any
known cause quickly fell down and died.
7. Phebe Chandler testified, that about a
fortnight before the apprehension of Martha
Carrier, on a Lord's-day, while the psalm was
singing in the church, this Carrier then took her
by the shoulder, and shaking her, asked her
>vhere she lived: she made her no answer, al-
though, as Carrier \i\ed next door to her father's
house, she could not in reason but know who
she was. Quickly after this, as she was at several
times crossing the fields, she heard a voice
that she took to be Martha Carrier's, and it
seemed as if it were over her head. The voice
told her, she should within two or three days he
poisoned : accordingly, within such a little time,
one half of her right hand became greatly
swollen and very painful, as also part of her face;
whereof she can give no account how it came.
It continued very bad for some days; and sever-
al times since she has had a great pain in her
breast ; and been so seized on her legs, that she
has hardly been able to go. She added, that
lately going well to the house of God, Richard,
'the son of Martha Carrier, looked very earnest-
ly upon her, and immediately her hand, whiok
OF FACT, <^c. 275
liad formerly been poisoned, as is abovcsaid, be-
gan to pain her greatly, and she had a strange
burning at her stomach ; but was then struck
deal', so that she could not hear any of the
prayer, or singing, till the two or three last
words of the psalm.
8. One Foster, who confessed her own share
in the witchcraft, for which the prisoner stood
indicted, afiirmed, that she had seen the prisoner
at some of their witch-meetings, and that it was
this Carrier who persuaded her te be a witch.
She confessed that-the devil carried them on a
pole to a witch-meeting; but the pole broke,
and she hanging about Carriers neck, they both
fell down, and she then received an hurt by the
fall, whereof she was not at this very time
recovered.
9. One Lacy, who likewise confessed her
share in this witchcraft, now testified, that she
and the prisoner were once bodily present at a
witch-meeting in Salem Village, and that she
knew the prisoner to be a witch, and to have
been at a diabolical sacrament, and that the
prisoner w^as the undoing of her and her chil-
dren, by enticing them into the snare ef the
devil.
10. Another Lacy, who also confessed her
share in this witchcraft, now testified, that the
prisoner was at the witch-meeting in Salem
Village, where they had bread and wine admin-
istered to them.
11. in the time of this prisoner's trial, one
Susanna Shelden, in open court, had her hands
unaccountably tied together with a wheel-band
>
276 MATTERS
so fast that without cutting it could not be loosen-
ed. It was done by a spectre; and the sufferer
affirmed it was the prisoner's.
Meinorandiim* This rampant hag, Martha
Carrier, was the person of whom the confessions
of the WMtches, and of her own children among
the rest, agreed that the devil had promised her
she should be queen of hell.
Thus far the account given in Wonders of the
Invisible World; in which (setting aside such
words as these, in the trial of G. B. viz. " They,
i. e. the witnesses, were enough to fix the char-
acter of a witch upon him" — in the trial of Bi-
shop, these words, " But there was no need of
them," i. e. of further testimony — in the trial of
How, where it is said, "And there came in tes-
timony of preternatural mischiefs presently be-
falhng some that had been instrumental to debar
her from the communion, whereupon she was
intruding,") Martin is called one of the most im-
pudent, scurrilous, wicked creatures in the world ;
in his account of Martha Carrier, he is pleased
to call her a rampant hog, <Sz;c.
These expressions, as they manifest that he
wrote more like an advocate than an historian,
so also that those that were his employers were
not mistaken in their choice of him for that
work, however he may have missed it in other
things: as, in his owning (in the trial of G. B.)
that the testimony of the beivifchedy and confes-
sors, was not enovgh against the accused ; for it is
known that not only in New-England such evi-
dence has been taken for sufficient, but also in
OF FACT, &c. 177
England, as himself there owns, and will also
hold true of Scotland, &c. they having proceed-
ed upon such evidence, to the taking away of
the lives of many. To assert that this is not
enough, is to tell the world that such executions
were but so many bloody murders; which sure-
ly was not his intent to say.
His telling that the court began to think that
Burroughs stept aside to put on invisibility, is a
rendering them so mean philosophers, and such
weak christians, as to be fit to be imposed upon
by any silly pretender.
His calling the evidence against How trivial,
and others against Burroughs he accounts no
part of his conviction, and that of lifting a gun
with one finger, its being not made use of as evi-
dence, renders the whole but the more perplext.
(Not to mention the many mistakes therein con*
tained.)
Yet all this (and more that might have been
hinted at) does nbt hinder, but that his account
of the manner of trials of those for w^itchcraft is
as faithfully related as any trials of that kind,
that were ever yet made public; and it may al-
so be reasonably thought that there was as care-
ful a scrutiny, and as unquestioned evidences im-
proved, as nad been formerly used in tlie trials
of others, for such crimes, in other places.
Though indeed a second part tnight be very use-
ful, to set forth which was the evidence convic-
tive in these trials ; for it is not supposed that
romantic or ridiculous stories should have any
influence; such as biting a spectre's finger so
that the blood flowed out; or such as Shattock's
24
ns MATTERS
story of twelve years standing, -yvhich yet was
presently eighteen years or more, and yet a man
of so excellent memory as to be able to recall a
small difference his wife' had with another w^o-
man when eighteen years were past.
As it is not to be supjiosed that such as these
could influence any judge or jury, so not unkind-
ness to relations, or God's having given to one
man more strength than to some others; the
oversetting of carts, or the death of cattle; nor
yet excrescences (called teats) nor litde bits of
'rags tied together (called poppets ;) much less
any person's illness, or having their clothes rent>
when a spectre has been well hanged; much
less the burning the mare's fart, mentioned in
the trial of How.
None of these being in the least capable of
proving the indictment, the supposed criminals
were indicted for afflicting, &c. such and such
particular persons by witchcraft, to which none
of these evidences have one word to say ; and the
afflicted and confessors being declared not
enough, the matter needs yet further explaining.
But to proceed. The general court having
set and enacted laws, particularly one against
witchcraft, assigning the penalty of death to any
that shall feed, reward or employ, &c. evil
spirits, though it has not yet been explained
what is intended thereby, or what it is to feed,
reward or employ devils, (kc yet some of the
legislators have given this, instead of an explana-
tion, that they had therein but copied the law of
another country.
January 3. By virtue of an act of the general
OF FACT, 4-c. 279
?ourt, the first superior court was held at Salcni,
for the country of Essex; the judges a[)pointed
were mr. William Stoughton (the heutenant
Governor) Thomas Danlorth, John Richards,
VVait VVinthrop, and Samuel Sewall, esquires;
^vhere ignoramus was found upon the several bills
of indictment against thirty, and billa vera against
twenty-six more ; of all these, three only were
found guilty by the jury upon trial, two of which
were (as appears by their behaviour) the most
senseless and ignorant creatures that could be
found; besides which, it does not appear what
came in aofainst those more than asfainst the rest
that were acquitted.
The third was the wife of Wardwell, whq
was one of the twenty executed, and it seems
they had both confessed themselves guilty ; but
he, retracting his said confession, was tried and
executed. It is supposed that this woman, fear-
ing her husband's fate, was not so stiff in her
denials of her former confession, such as it was.
Taese three received sentence of death.
At these trials some of the jury made inquiry
of the court, what account they ought to make
of the spectre evidence ; and received for an-
swer, c/^5 much as of chips in wort.
January 31, 1692-3. The superior court be-
gan at Charlestown, for the county of Middlesex,
mr. Stoughton, mr. Danforth, mr. Winthrop and
mr. Sewall, judges; where several had ignora-
mus returned upon their bills of indictment, and
billa vera upon others.
In the time the court sat, word was brought
in, that a reprieve was sent to Salem, and had
5«0 MATTERS
prevented the execution of seven of those thai
were there condemned; which so moved the
chief judge, that he said to this etTect, We ivere
in a tivay to have cleared the land of these, S*c.
Who it is obstructs the course oj* justice, 1 know
not ; the Lord he merciful to the coimtry ; and so
went off the bench, and came no more that court.
The most remarkable of the trials, was of
Sarah Daston. She was a woman of about sev-
enty or eightj years of age. To usher her in
to her trial, a report went before, that if there
were a witch in the W'orld she was one, as hav-
ing been so accounted of for twenty or thirty
years; which drew many people from Boston,
i&c. to hear her trial. There were a multitude
of witnesses produced against her; but what
testimony they gave in seemed wholly foreign,
as of accidents, illness, &c. befalling them, or
theirs, after seme cjuarrel ; what these testified
was much of it of actions said to be done twenty
years before that time. The spectre evidence
was not made use of in these trials, so that the
jury soon brought her in not guilty. Her daugh-
ter and grand-daughter, and the rest that were
then tried, were also acquitted. After she was
cleared, judge Danforth admonished her in these
words, Woman, woman, repent ; there are shrewd
things come in against you* She was remanded
to prison for her fees, and there in a short time
expired. One of Boston, that had been at the
trial of Daston, being the same evening in com-
pany Avith one of the judges in a public place,
acquainted him that some, that had been both
at the trials at Salem and at this at Charlestown^
or FACT, Lc. 281
had asserted, That there was more evidence against
the said Dnston than against any at Salon ; to
Aviiicli the said judge conceded, saying, that it
was so. It was replied by that person, Tliat he
dare give it under his hand, that there was not
enough come in against her to hear a just reproof.
.fpril2C), 1693. The first superior court was
held at Boston, lor the county of Suffolk; the
judges were the lieutenant Governor, mr. Dan-
forth, mr. Richards, and mr. Sewall, esquires;
where (besides the acquitting mr. John Aldin by
proclamation) the most remarkable was, what
related to Mary Watkins, who had been a ser-
vant, and lived about seven miles from Boston,
havuig formerly accused her mistress of witch-
craft, and was supposed to be distracted ; she
was threatened, it" she persisted in such accusa-
tions, to be punished. This, with the necessary
care to recover her health, had that good effect,
that she not only had her health restored, but
also wholly acquitted her mistress of any such
crimes, and continued in health till the return of
the year, and then again falling into melancholy-
humours, she was found strangling herself; her
lite being hereby prolonged, she immediately ac-
cused herself of being a witch; was carried be-
fore a magistrate, and committed. At this court
a bill of indictment was brought to the grand
jury against her, and her confession upon her ex-
amination given in as evidence ; but these, not
wholly satisfied herewith, sent for hor, who gave
such account of herself, that they (after they
had returned into the court to ask some ques-
tions) twelve of them agreed to find ignoramus,
24*
282 MATTERS
but the court was pleased to send them out
again, who again at coming in returned it as be-
fore. She was continued for some time in pri-
son, &;c. and at length was sold to Virginia. About
this time the prisoners in all the prisons were
released.
To omit here the mentioning of several wen-
ches inBoston,Akc. who pretended to be afflicted,
and accused several, the ministers often visiting
them, and praying with them, concerning whose
affliction narratives are in being, in manuscript ;
not only these, but the generality of those accus-
ers, may have since convinced the ministers, by
their vicious courses, that they might err in ex-
tending too much charity to them.
The conclusion of the whole in the Massachu-
setts colony was, sir William Phips, governor,
being called home, before he went he pardoned
such as had been condemned, for which they
gave about thirty shillings each to the king's
attorney.
In August, 1697, the superior court sat at
Hartford, in the colony of Connecticut, where
one mistress Benom was tried for witchcraft.
She had been accused by some children that
pretended to the spectral sight; they searched
her several times for teats; they tried the exper-
iment of casting her into the water, and after
this she was excommunicated by the minister of
Wallinsford. Upon her trial nothing material
appeared against her, save spectre evidence.
She was acquitted, as also her daughter, a girl
of twelve or thirteen years old, who had been
l^ikewise accused; but upon renewed complaints
OF FACT, S:c. 28S
against them, they both flew into New-York
government.
Bel'ore this, the government issued forth the
following proclamation :
By the honourable the lieutenant governor^ council
and assembly of his majesty\s province of the
Massachusetts-bay, in general court assembled.
Whereas the anger of God is not yet turned
away, but his hand is still stretched out against
his people in manifold judgments, particularly in
drawing out to such a length the troubles of
Europe, by a perplexing war ; and more espe-
cially respecting ourselves in this province, in
that God is pleased still to go on in diminishing
our substance, cutting short our harvest, blast-
ing our most promising undertakings more ways
than one, unsettling us, and by his more imme-
diate hand snatching away many out of our em-
braces by sudden and violent deaths, even at
this time when the sword is devouring so many
both at home and abroad, and that after many
days of public and solemn addressing him : and
although, considering the many sins prevailing in
the midst of us, we cannot but wonder at the
patience and mercy moderating these rebukes,
yet we cannot but also fear that there is some-
thing still wanting to accompany our supplica-
tions; and doubtless there are some particular
sins, which God is angry with our Israel for, that
hive not been duly seen and resented by us,
about which God expects to be sought, if ever
he turn again our captivity :
Wherefore it is commanded and appointed,
284 MATTERS
that Thursday, the fourteenth of January next,
be observed as a day of prayer, with fasting,
throughout this province ; strictly forbidding ail
servile labour thereon; that soall'God's people
may offer up fervent supplications unto him, for
the preservation and prosperity of his majesty^s
royal person and government, and success to at-
tend his affairs both at home and abroad; that
all iniquity may be put away, which hath stirred
God's holy jealousy against this land; that he
would shew us what we know not, and help us
wherein we have done amiss to do so no more;
and especially that whatever mistakes on either
hand have been fallen into, either by the body
of this people, or any orders of men, referring to
the late tragedy, raised among us by satan and
his instruments, through the awful judgment of
God, he would humble us therefor, and pardon
all the errors of his servants and people, that
desire to love his name ; that he would remove
the rod of the wicked from off the lot of the
righteous; that he would bring in the American
heathen, and cause them to hear and obey his
roice.
Given at Boston, December 17, 1696, in the
eighth year of his Majesty^ s reign.
Isaac Addington, Secretary.
Upon the day of the fast, in the full assembly
at the south meeting-house in Boston, one of the
honourable judges, who had sat in judicature in
Salem, delivered in a paper, and while it was in
reading stood up; but the copy being not to be
obtained at present, it can only be reported by
OF FACT, &c. 286
memory to this effect, viz. It was to desire the
prayers of God's people for him and his ; and
that God having visited his family, &;c. he was
apprehensive that he might have fallen into some
errors in the matters at Salem, and pray that
the ^uilt of such miscarriages may not be imput-
ed either to the country in general, or to him or
his family in particular.
Some, that had been of several juries, have
given forth a paper, signed with their own hands,
in these words:
" We, whose names are under written, being in
the year 1692 called to serve as jurors in court
at Salem on trial of many, who were by some
suspected guilty of doing acts of witchcraft
upon the bodies of sundry persons:
'•We confess that we ourselves were not ca-
pable to understand, nor able to withstand, the
mysterious delusions of the powers of darkness,
and prince of the air; but were, for want of
knowledge in ourselves, and better information
from others, prevailed with to take up with such
evidence against the accused, as, on further
consideration and better information, we justly
fear was insufficient for the touching the lives of
any, (^Deut. xvii. 6) whereby we fear we have
been instrumental, with others, though ignorant-
ly and unwittingly, to bring upon ourselves and
this people of the Lord the guilt of innocent
blood; which sin the Lord saith, in scripture,
he would not pardon, (2 Kings, xxiv. 4) that is,
Ave suppose, in regard of his temporal judgments.
We do therefore hereby signify to all in general
(and to the surviving sufferers in special) oar
286 MATTERS
deep sense of, and sorrow for, our errors, in act-
ing on such evidence to the condemning of any
person; and do hereby declare, that we justly
fear that we were sadly deluded and mistaken;
for which we are much disquieted and distress-
ed in our minds ; and do therefore humbly beg
forgiveness, first of God for Christ's sake, for
this our error; and pray that God would not
impute the guilt of it to ourselves, nor others;
and we also pray that we may be considered
candidly, and aright, by the living sufferers, as
being then under the power of a strong and gene-
ral delusion, utterly unacquainted with, and not
experienced in, matters of that nature.
" We do heartily ask forgiveness of you all,
whom we have justly offended; and do declare,
according to our present minds, we would none
of us do such things again on such grounds for
the whole world; praying you to accept of this
in way of satisfaction for our offence, and that
you would bless the inheritance of the Lord,
that he may be entreated for the land.
Foreman, Thomas Fisk,
William Fisk,
John Bacheler,
Thomas Fisk^ jun.
John Dane.
Joseph Evelithj
77i. Pearly, sen.
John Peabody,
Thomas Perkins,
Samuel Sayer,
Andrew Eliot,
H, Herrick, sen.''^
rOSTSClIIPT.
Since making the ibregolnor collections oi
letters, to the rev. mr. Cotton Mather, and oth-
ers, (fcc. (wliich as yet remain unanswered) a
hook is come to hand intitled, " The Life of
Sir Wn.LiA3i PiHPs," printed in London, 1697:
which book, though it beais not the author's
name, yet the style, manner and matter are such,
that, were there np other demonstration or to-
ken to know him by, it were no witchcralt to
determine that the said mr. Cotton Mather is
the author of it. But that he, who has cncoun-
tered enchantments, and gone tlirough the IVon-
ders of the Invisible WorUl, and discovered the
devil — that he sliould step aside into a remote
country to put on invisibility, thougli the reason
of this be not so manifest, yet it may be thought
to be to gratify some peculiar fancies. And
why may not this be one, that he might with
the better grace extol the actions of mr. hicrease,
Mather, as agent in England, or as president of
Harv^ard college, not forgetting his own?
As to sir Wilh'am, it will be generally ac-
knowledged, that notwitlistanding the meanne.ss
of his parentage and education, he attained to
he master of a ship, and that he had the good
liap to find a Spanish w^'eck, not only sufficient
288 POSTSCRIPT.
to repair his fortunes, but to raise hiai to a con-
siderable figure ; which king James so far assist-
ed, as to make him a knight; and that after this,
in the reign of his present majesty, he took up
with those of the agents, that were for accept-
ing the new charter, whereby himself became
governor.
It is not doubted, but that he aimed at the
good of the people ; and great pity it is that his
government was so sullied (for want of better
information and advice from those whose duty
it was to have given it) by that hobgoblin mon-
ster, witchcraft, whereby this country was night-
mared, and harassed, at such a rate as is not
easily imagined.
After which, some complaints going to Eng-
land about maladministration, in the least mat-
ters comparatively, yet were such, that he was
called home to give account thereof, where he
soon after expired, so finishing his life and gov-
ernment together.
Death having thus drawn the curtain, forbid-
ding any further scene, it might have been pru-
dent to let his dust remain without disturbance.
But the said book endeavouring to raise a
statue to him, i. e. to ascribe to him such achieve-
ments as either were never performed by him,
or else unduly aggravated, this has opened the
mouth, both of friends and enemies, to recount
the mistakes in the said book ; as also those
miscarriages wherewith sir William was charge-
able ; such as, had it not been for this book^
would have been buried with him.
In page 3, search is made over the world, to
POSTSCRIPT. - 289
whom to compare him in his advancement ; and
most unhappily Pizarro is pitched upon, as a
match for him ; who was a bastard, dropt in a
church-porch, put to suck a sow, and, being
grown, ran away, and shipt himself for Ameri-
ca ; there so prospered, as to command an ar-
my; and therewith did mighty things, particu-
larly took Atabalipa, one of the kings of Peru,
prisoner ; and, having received for his ransom,
m gold and silver, to the value of ten millions,
perfidiously put him to death; and was the
death of no man knows how many thousands of
innocents, and is certainly one of the worst that
could have been pitched upon for such compar-
ison. Though this, together with the rhetori-
cal flourishes and affected strains therein, are in-
stances of the author's variety of learning ; for
which he is recommended by these three ven-
erable persons in the entrance to the said book ;
yet the integrity, prudence and veracity thereof
are not so manifestly to be seen. Passing over
a multitude of misrepresentations that are there-
in, relating to the acts of sir William, as not de-
signing to rake in the grave of the dead, who is
it can see the veracity of those words.'* p. 40.
"He lay within pistol-shot of the enemy's can-
non, and beat them from thence, and much bat-
tered the town, having his ship shot through in
an hundred places, with four and twenty poun-
ders ;" when, in the judgment of those present,
they were not nearer to the enemy than about
half or three quarters of a mile; that there
might be in all about seven shot that struck the
hull of the vessel, none of them known to be
25
290 POSTSCRIPT.
bigger than l8 pounders, the enemy having but
one gun that would carry an 18 pound 'ball.
It were a folly, after such assertions, to take
any notice of this bedecked statue, when there
was so much the less need of erecting one (as is
asserted p. 108) having already been done so
well, that even this author himself despairs of
doing it better; and that by a man of such dif-
fused and embalmed a reputation, as that his
commendations are asserted to be enough to im-
mortalize the reputation of sir William, or
whomsoever else he should please to bestow
them upon, viz. that reverend person who was
the president of the only university then in the
English America, p. 109. Which by the way
is a much fairer statue, in honour of the president
of the university, than that erected for sir Wil-
liam.
For, notwithstanding all this noise of erecting
statues, and the great danger in plucking them
down, (S:c. yet, in p. 89, it is said that even sir
William shewed choler enough, leaving it open
for others thereby to understand that he was
wholly given over to passion and choler. And,
in p. 92, it is said he did not affect any mighty
shew of devotion. These expressions, w^ith
others, may prevail with the unbiassed render
to think that these builders of statues had some
further design in it, than to blazon the achieve-
ments of sir'William Phips, viz. to set forth mr.
1. Mather's negotiation in England, his procur-
ing the new charter, and sir W^illiam to be gov-
ernor, and himself established president of the
college, are the things principally driven at in
the book.
POSTSCRIPT. 291
Another principal thino; is, to set forth the
supposed witchcrafts in New-England, and how
well mr. Mather the younger tlierein acquitted
himself.
As to the new charter, for the right under-
standing that affair, it will be needful to say,
that the people that afterwards settled in New-
England, being about to leave their native soil,
end to seek (as the providence of God should
direct thc*.n) a settlement in remote regions,
wherein they might best secure their civil and
religious interests, before they entered upon this, ^
considering it might be needful on many accounts \ ■
lor their future well-being, they obtained a char- V
ter to be in the nature of a prime agreement,
setting forth the sovereign's prerogative, and the
people's privileges; in the enjoyment whereoi
they long continued, after having purchased the
title to their lands of the natives of their coun-
try, and settled themselves therein, without any
charge to tlie crown.
That clause in their charter for this country,
viz. " Provided that no other christian prince be
prepossessed of it," being a tacit acknowledg-
ment, that before settlement, no one christian
prince had any right thereto more than another.
During this time of New England's prosperity,
the government here were very sparing of
granting freedoms, except to such as were so
and so qualified: whereby the number of non-
freemen being much increased, they were very
uneasy, by their being shut out from any share
in the government, or having any votes for their
representatives, &c. It rendered many of them
292 POSTSCRIPT,
ready to join with such as were undermining
the government ; not duly considering that it
had been far more safe to have endeavoured to
prevail with the legislators for an enlargement.
So that it will not be wondered at, that in the
latter end of the reign of king Charles II, and
of king James, (when most of the charters in
England were vacated) this was quo icarranto^d,
and finally judgment entered wp against it, and
the country was put into such a form of govern-
ment as was most agreeable to those times, viz.
a legislative power was lodged in the governor
(or president) and some few appointed to be of
his council, without any regard therein either
to the laws of England, or those formerly of this
colony: thus rendering the circumstances of this
country beyond comparison worse than those of
any corporation in England ; the people of those
corporations being acknowledged still to have a
rio-ht to magna charta, when their particular
charters were made void ; but here, when magna
charta has been pleaded, the people have been
answered, that they must not expect that magna
charta would follow them to the end of the
world; not only their estates, but their lives,
being thereby rendered wholly precarious.
And judge Palmer has set forth in print, that the
king has power to grant such a commission over
his people.
It is not hard to imagine, that under such a
commission, not only the people were liable to
be oppressed by taxes, but also by confiscations,
and seizing of lands, unless patents were purchas-
ed at excessive prices, with many other exorbi-
tant innovations.
POSTSCRIPT. 293
The first that accepted this commission was
mr. Dudley, a gentleman born in this country,
who did but prepare the way for sir Edmond "^
Andros ; in whose time things had grown to I
such extremities, not only here, but in England, ^
as rendered the succeeding revolution absolutely
necessary ; the revolution here being no other
than an acting according to the precedent given
by England.
During the time of sir Edmond's government,
mr. Increase Mather, teacher of' the north
church in Boston, having undergone some trou-
ble by fobb-actions laid upon him, &;c. (though^ ^
with some difficulty) he made his escape, and
got passage for England, being therein assisted .
by some particular friends ; where being arri-
ved, he applied himself to king James for re-
dress of those evils the country then groaned
under; and meeting Avith a seeming kind recep-
tion, and some promises, it was as much as might
at that time be reasonably expected.
Upon the day of the revolution here, though
the greatest part of the people were for reas-
suming their ancient government, pursuant to
his royal highness's proclamation, yet matters
were so clogged, that the people were dismissed
without it, who did not in the least mistrust
but that those, who were put out of the gov-
ernment by mr. Dudley, would reassume ; mr.
Bradstreet, who had been then governor, being
heard to say that evening, when returned home,
that had not he thought they would have reas-
sumed, he would not have stirred out of his
house that day. But after this, some that were
25^
294 POSTSCRIPT.
driving at other matters, had opportunities hy
threats and other ways not only to prevail with
that good old gentleman, but with the rest of
the government, wholly to decline it; which
some few observing, they took the opportunity
to call themselves a committee of safety, and so
undertook to govern such as would be govefned
by them.
It has been an observation of long continu-
ance, that matters of state seldom prosper, when
managed by the clergy. Among the opposers
of the reassuraing, few were so strenuous as
some of the ministers ; and among the ministers,
none more vehement than mr. Cotton Mather,
pastor of the north church in Boston, who has
charged them, as they would answer it another
day, not to reassume. Among his arguments
against it, one was, that it would be to put a
slight upon his father, who, he said, was in Eng-
land, labouring for a complete restoration of
charter privileges, not doubting but they would
be speedily obtained. Any man that knows
New-England cannot but be sensible, that such
discourses, from such men, have always been
very prevalent. And hence it was, that even
those that would think themselves wronged, if
they were not numbered among the best friends
to New-England, and to its char tei-, would not
so much as stoop to take it up, when there was
really nothing to hinder them from the enjoy-
ment thereof.
After the committee of safety had continued
about seven weeks, or rather after anarchy had
been so long triumphant, an assembly having
POSTSCRIPT. 295
been called came to this resolution, and laid it
before those gentlemen that had been ol' the
government, — that if they would not act upon
the foundation of the charter, that, pursuant to
it, the assembly would appoint some others in
that station. The answer to which was, that
they would accept, &c. And when a declara-
tion, signifying such a reassuming, was prepared,
with the good liking of the deputies, in order to
be published, some, that were opposers, so ter-
rified those gentlemen, that, before publishing,
it was underwritten that they would not have it
understood that they did reassume charter-
government, to the no small amazement of the
people, and disappointment of the deputies, who,
if these had not promised so to act, had taken
other care, and put in those that would.
The next principal thing done was, they chose
two of their members, viz. one of the upper
house, the other of the lower, both of them
gentlemen of known integrity as w^ell as ability,
to go to England, in order to obtain their reset-
tlement; and in regard mr. I. Mather was
already there, they joined him, as also a certain
gentleman in London, with these other two.
Those from hence being arrived in London,
they all united for the common interest of the
country, though without the desired effect.
They were in doubt whether it were best to
improve their utmost for a reversal of the judg-
ment in a course of law, or to obtain it in a
parliamentary way, or to petition his majesty
for a new grant of former privileges ; and, con-
sidering that the two first might prove dilatory
i:>9G POSTSCRIPT.
and expensive, as well as for other reasons, they
resolved upon the latter, and petitioned his ma-
jesty for the country's resettlement, with form-
er privileges, and what further additions his ma-
jesty in his princely wisdom should think fit.
Accordingly it pleased his majesty to declare in
council his determination, viz. That there
should be a charter granted to New-England.
But the minutes then taken thereof, and a
draught of the new charter, being seen, it was
the opinion of the two gentlemen sent from
hence, that it were best to tarry his majesty's
return from Flanders, in hopes then to obtain
ease in such things as might be any ways deem-
ed grievous. And this was the result of the ad-
vice of such as were best able to give it, that
they could meet with; and accordingly they
wholly desisted taking it out of the offices.
But mr. Mather and that other gentleman
had, as it is said, other advice given them, which
they strenuously pursued ; and his majesty hav-
ing left it (as is asserted in the life of sir Wil-
liam, p. 57) to them to nominate a governor,
they pitched upon sir William Phips, Avho Avas
then in England, as the most likely and able to
serve the king's interests* among the people
there, under the changes, in some things unac-
ceptable, now brought upon them, p. 62 ; and,
without tarrying for the concurrence of those
other agents, the charter was taken out, &:c,
Bnt mr. Mather, perhaps fearing he should
have but small thanks here for his having so
far an hand in bringing upon them those unac-
ceptable changes, wrote, and caused to be print-
POSTSCRIPT. sot
ed, an account of his negotiation; but, surelj by
some error in the conception, it proved only an
embryo, and was stifled as soon as born. One
indeed, designed to be as it were a posthumous,
was lel't with mr. Bailey, formerly of Boston,
and a member of the north church, with a
charge not to suflfer it to be seen till he were
gone to New-England; yet it seems some other
person got a sight of it, which was the occasion
of mr. Mathers sending him that minatory epis-
tle, by some called a bull. But besides this,
for fear of the worst, mr. Mather got several
non-con. ministers to give him a testimonial, or
letters of commendation, for his great service
herein.
In the mean time, mr. Cotton Mather, being
in some doubt of the same thing, handed about
a paper of fables; wherein his father, under the
name of Mercurius, and himself under the name
of Orpheus, are extolled, and the great actions
of Mercurius magnified; the present charter
exalted, by trampling on the former, as bemg
very defective, and all those called unreasona-
ble that did not readily agree with the new one.
And indeed the whole country are compared to
no better than beasts, excejjt Mercurius and
Orpheus; the governor himself must not escape
being termed an elephant, though as good as he
was great; and the inferiors told by Orpheus,
that for the quiet enjoyment of their land, (fee.
they were beholding to Mercurius. Though
this paper was judged not convenient to be
printed, yet some copies were taken, the author
having shewn variety of heathen learning in it.
298 POSTSCRIPT.
This is in short that eminent service for which
the said mr. I. M. is in the present book so highly
extolled, in so many pages, that to repeat them,
were to transcribe a considerable part of the
said book.
And no doubt he deserves as much thanks as
dr. Sharp did, when he was sent by the pres-
bytery of Scotland to procure the settlement
of their kirk by king Charles II at his restora-
tion.
Not but that the present charter of New-
England is indeed truly valuable, as containing
in it peculiar privileges, which abundantly en-
gages this people to pay the tribute of thank-
fulness to his majesty, and all due subjection to
whom it shall please him to substitute as gov-
ernor over us; and to pray that the King of
kings Avould pour out his richest blessings upon
him, giving him a long and prosperous reign
over the nations, under the benign influences
whereof oppression and tyranny may flee away.
And if his majesty hath put this people into
the present form of government, that they
might be in the better condition of defence in a
time of war, or that they might better under-
stand the privilege of choosing their own gov-
ernor by the want of it, and should be gracious-
ly pleased (the war being over) to restore to
these, as has been already granted to the rest of
his majesty's subjects, the full enjoyment of
their ancient privileges, it would be such an
obligation upon them to thankfulness and duty,
as could never be forgotten, nor sufficiently ex-
prest, and would rather abate than increase
charge to the crown.
POSTSCRIPT. 29t»
As to the supposed witchcrafts in New-Eng-
land, liavlng ah'cady said so much thereof, there
is the less remains to be added.
In tlie times of sir Edmond Andres's govern-
ment, goody Glover, a despised, crazy, ill-con-
ditioned old woman, an Irish Roman Catholic,
was tried for afflicting Goodwin's children; by
the account of which trial, taken in short hand
for the use of the jury, it may appear that the
generality of her answers were nonsense, and
her behaviour like that of one distracted. Yet
the doctors, finding her as she had been for many-
years, brought her in compos mentis ; and setting
aside her crazy answers to some ensnaring ques-
tions, the proof against her w^as wholly deficient.
The jury brought her in guilty.
Mr. Cotton Mather was the most active and
forward of any minister in the country in those
matters, taking home one of the children, and
managing such intrigues with that child, and
printing such an account of the whole in his Me-
morable Providences^ as conduced much to the
kindling of those flames, that in sir William's
time threatened the destruction of this country.
King Saul in destroying the witches out of Is-
rael is thought by many to have exceeded, and
in his zeal to have slain the Glbconltes wrong-
fully under that notion ; yet went aiter this to a
witch to know his fortune. For his wrongfully
destroying the Glbeonites (besides the judg-
ments of God upon the land) his sons were
hanged ; and for his going to the witch, himself
was cut oft'. Our sir William Phips did not do
this ; but, as appears by this book, had first his
300 POSTSCRIPT.
fortune told him, (by such as the author counts
no better) and though he put it off (to his pas-
tor, who he knew approved not thereof) as if it
were brought to him in writing, without his
seeking, &o yet by his bringing it so far, and
safe keeping it so many years, it appears he
made some account of it; for which he gave the
writer, after he had found the wTeck, as a re-
ward, more than tw^o hundred pounds. His
tehing his wife, (p. 6) that he should be a com-
mander, should have a brick house inGreenlane,
&c. might be in confidence of some such predic-
tion; and that he could foretel to him (p. 90)
that he should be governor of New-England,
was probably such an one, the scriptures not
having revealed it. Such predictions would
have been counted, at Salem, pregnant proofs
of witchcraft, and much better than what were
against several that suffered there. But sir
William, when the witchcrafts at Salem began
(in his esteem) to look formidable, that he
might act safely in this affair, asked the advice
of the ministers in and near Boston. The
whole of their advice and answer is printed in
Cases of Conscience, the last pages. But lest the
world should be ignorant who it was that drew
the said advice, in this book of the life of sir
William Phips, p. 77, are these words, The mi-
nisters made to his excellency and the council a
return, drawn up at their desire, by mr. Mather
the younger, as I have been informed. Mr. C. M.
therein intending to beguile the world, and
make them think that another, and not himself,
had taken that notice of his (supposed) good
POSTSCRIPT. 301
service done therein, which otherwise would
have been ascribed to those ministers in general ;
though indeed the advice then given looks most
like a thing of his composing, as carrying both
fire to increase, and water to quench, the con-
flagration ; particularly after the devil's testi-
mony, by the supposed afflicted, had so prevail-
ed, as to take away the life of one, and the liber-
ty of an hundred, and the whole country set in-
to a most dreadful consternation, then this ad-
vice is given, ushered in with thanks for what
^vas already done, and in conclusion putting the
government upon a speedy and vigorous prose-
cution, according to the laws of God, and the
wholesome statutes of the English nation; so
adding oil, rather than water, to the flame: for
who so little acquainted with the proceedings
of England, as not to know that they have ta-
ken some methods, with those here used, to dis-
cover who were witches ? The rest of the ad-
vice, consisting of cautions and directions, is in-
serted in this book of the life of sir William : so
that if sir William, looking upon the thanks for
what was past, and exhortation to proceed, went
on to take away the lives of nineteen more, this
is according to the advice said ta be given him
by the ministers; and if the deyil, after those
executions, be affronted, by disbelieving his testi-
mony, and by clearing and pardoning all the rest of
the accused, yet this also is, according to that ad-
vice, but to cast the scale. The same that drew
this advice aaith, in Wonders of the Invisible Worlds
Enchantments Encountered^ that to have a hand
in any thing that may stifle or obstruct a regular
26
302 POSTSCRIPT
detection of that witchcraft, is what we may
well with a holy fear avoid : their majesties-
good subjects must not every day be torn to pie-
ces by horrid witchcraft, and those bloody fel-
ons be wholly left unprosecuted; the witchcraft
is a business that will not be shammed. The
pastor of that church, of which sir William was
a member, being of this principle, and thus de-
claring it, after the former advice, no wonder
though it cast the scale against those cautions.
It is rather a wonder that no more blood was
shed ; for if that advice of his pastor could still
have prevailed with the governor, witchcraft
had not been so shammed off as it was. Yet
now, in this book of the life of sir William, the
pardoning the prisoners when condemned, and
clearing the gaols, is called (p. 82) a vanquishing
the devil; adding this conquest to the rest of
the noble achievements of sir William, though
gerformed not only without, but directly against,
is pastor's advice. But this is not all; though
this book pretends to raise a statue in honour of
sir William, yet it appears it was the least part
of the design of the author to honour him, but
it was rather to honour himself, and the minis-
ters; it being so unjust to sir William, as to give
a full account of the cautions given him, but de-
signedly hiding from the reader the encourage-
ments and exhortations to proceed, that were
laid before him, (under the name of the minis-
ters' advice ;) in effect telling the world that
those executions at Salem were without and
against the advice of the ministers, exprest in
those cautions, purposely hiding their giving
POSTSCRIPT. 303
thanks for what was already done, and exhort-
ing to proceed ; thereby rendering sir VViNiam
ot" so sanguinary a complexion, that the ministers
had such cause to fear his going on with the
tragedy, though against their advice, that they
desired the president to write his Gases of Don"
science^ (fee. To plead misinformation will not
salve here, however it may seem to palliate
other things, but is a manifest, designed traves-
ty, or misrepresentation, of tlic minister's advice
to sir William, a hiding the truth, and a wrong-
ing the dead, whom the author so much pretends
to honour i for which the acknowledgments ought
to be as universal as the offence. But though
the ministers' advice, or rather mr. Cotton Ma-
ther's, was perfectly ambidexter, giving as great
or greater encouragement to proceed in those
dark methods, than cautions against them; yet
many eminent persons being accused, there was
a necessity of a stop to be put to it. If it be
true, what w^as said at the council-board in an-
swer to the commendations of sir William for
his stopping the proceedings about witchcral't,
viz. that it was high time for him to stop it, his
own lady being accused; if that assertion were
a truth, then New-England may seem to be more
beholden to the accusers for accusing her, and
thereby necessitating a stop, than to sir William,
or to the advice that was given him by his pastor.
Mr. Cotton Mather, having been very forward
to write books of witchcraft, has not been so
forward either to explain or to defend the doc-
trinal part thereof; and his belief (which he had
ai year's time to compose) he durst not venture,
304 POSTSCRIPT.
SO as to be copied. Yet in this book of the Hfe
of sir WilHam he sufficiently testifies his retain-
ing that heterodox behef, seeking by frightful
stories of the sutiierings of some, and the refined
sight of others, &lc. (p. 69) to obtrude upon the
world, and confirm it in such a belief as hither-
to he either cannot or will not defend, as if the
blood already shed thereby were not sufficient.
Mr. 1. Mather, in his Cases of Conscience, p.
25, tells of a bewitched eye, and that such can
see more than others. They were certainly
bewitched eyes, that could see as well shut as
open, and that could see what never was ;
that could see the prisoners upon the afflicted,
harming them, when those whose eyes were
not bewitched could have sworn that they
did not stir irora the bar. The accusers are
said to have suffered much by biting, (p. 73)
and the prints of just such a set of teeth, as '
those they accused had, would be seen on their
flesh; but such as had not such bewitched eyes
have seen the accusers bite themselves, and then
complain of the accused- It has also been seen,
when the accused, instead of having just such a»
set of teeth, has not had one in his head. They
Avere such bewitched eyes, that could see the
poisonous powder (brought by spectres, p. 70)
and that could see in the ashes the print of the
brand, there invisibly heating to torment the
pretended suffierers with, <fec.
These, with the rest of such legends, have
this direct tendency, viz. to tell the world that
the devil is more ready to serve his votaries, by
his doing for them things above or against the
course of nature, shewing himself to them and
POSTSCRIPT. 305
inakinoj explicit contracts with them, &c. than
the Divine Being is to his faithful servants ; and
that as he is vvilhng, so also able, to perform their
desires. The way whereby these people are be-
lieved to arrive at a power to afflict their neigh-
bours, is by a compact with the devil, and that
they have a power to commission him to those
evils, p. 72. However irrational, or unscriptural,
such assertions are, yet they seemi a necessary
part o( the Jaith of such as maintain the belief
of such a sort of witches.
As the scriptures know nothing of a covenant-
ing or commissioning witch, so reason cannot
conceive how mortals should by their wicked-
ness arrive at a power to commission angels, fall-
en angels, against their innocent neighbours. But
the scriptures are full in it, and the instances nu-
merous, that the Almighty Divine Being has this
prerogative, to make use of what instruments he
please th, in afflicting any, and consequently to
commission devils : and though this word, com-
missioning, in the author's former books, might
be thought to be by inadvertency, yet now, after
he hath been cautioned of it, still to persist in it
seems highly criminal; and therefore, in the
name of God, I here charge such belief as guil-
ty of sacrilege in the highest nature, and so much
worse than stealing church plate, &c. as it is a
higher olFence to steal any of the glorious attri-
butes of the Almighty, to bestow them upon
mortals, than it is to steal the utensils appropri-
ated to his service. And whether to ascribe
such power of commissioning devils to the worst
of men, be not direct blasphemy, 1 leave to oth-
26*
^06 Jf-OSTSCRIPT.
ers better able to determine. When the Pha^
risees were so wicked as to ascribe to Beelzebub
the mighty works of Christ (whereby he did
manifestly shew forth his power and godhead)
then it was that our Saviour declared the sin
against the Holy Ghost to be unpardonable.
When the righteous God is contending with
apostate sinners for their departures from him,
by his judgments, as plagues, earthquakes, storms
and tempests, sicknesses and diseases, wars, loss
of cattle, &c. then not only to ascribe this to the
devil, but to charge one another with sending or
commissioning those devils to do these things, is so
abominable and so wicked, that it requires a bet-
ter judgment than mine to give it its just de-
nomination.
But that christians, so called, should not only
charge their fellow christians therewith, but
proceed to trials and executions ; crediting that
enemy to all goodness, and accuser of the breth-
ren, rather than believe their neighbours in their
own defence; this is so diabolical a wickedness,
as cannot proceed but from a doctrine of devils ;
how far damnable it is, let others discuss.
ThouQ^h such things were acting in this country
in sir William's time, yet (p. 65) there is a dis-
course of a guardian angel, as then over-seeing
it : which notion, however it may suit the faith of
Ethnicks, or the fancies of Tritheinius, it is cer-
tain that the Omnipresent Being stands not in
need, as earthly potentates do, of governing the
world by vicegerents. And if sir William had
such an invisible pattern to imitate, no wonder
though some of his actions were unaccountable,
POSTSCRIPT'. 307
especially those relating to witchcraft : for if
there was in those actions an angel superintending,
there is little reason to think it was Gabriel, or
the spirit of Mercury ; nor Hanael, the angel or
spirit of Venus ; nor yd Samuel, the angel or
spirit of Mars; names feigned by the said Tri-
themius, &;c. ft may rather be thought to be
Apollyon, or Abaddon.
Objection. But here it will be said, What, are
there no witches? Does not the law of God
command that they should be extirpated ? Is
the command vain and unintelligible ?
Sol. For any to say that a witch is one that
makes a compact with, and commissions devils,
&c. is indeed to render the law of God vain and
unintelligible, as having provided no way where-
by they might be detected, and proved to be
such ; and how the Jews waded through this
dilKculty for so many ages, without the supple-
ment of mr. Perkins and Bernard thereto, would
be very mysterious. But to him that can read
the scriptures without prejudice from education,
&c. it will manifestly appear that the scripture is
full and intelligible, both as to the crime, and
means to detect the culpable. He that shall here-
after see any person, who, to conhrm people in
a false belief about the power of witches and
devils, pretending to a sign to confirm it ; such
as knocking oli' of invisible chains w^ith the hand,
driving away devils by brushing, striking with a
sword or stick, to wound a person at a great
distance, c^c. may (according to that head of mr.
Gaule's, quoted by mr.C. M. and so often herein
before recited, and so well proved by scripture)
conclude that he has seen witchcraft performed.
308 POSTSCRIPT.
If Balaam became a sorcerer by sacrificing
and praying to the true God against his visible
people, then he that shall praj that the afflict-
ed (by their spectral sight) maj accuse some
other persons (whereby their reputations and
lives may be endangered) such will justly deserve
the name of a sorcerer. If any person pretends
to know more than can be known by human
means, and professeth at the same time that
they have it from the black man, u e. the devih
and shall from hence give testimony against the
lives of others, they are manifestly such as have
a familiar spirit ; and if any, knowing them to
have their information from the black man, shall
be inquisitive of them for their testimony against
others, they therein are dealing with such as
have di familiar spirit
And if these shall pretend to see the dead by
their spectral sight, and others shall be inquisitive
of them, and receive their answers what it is
the dead say, and who it is they accuse, both
the one and the other are by scripture i,'•w^7/l/ of
7iecromancy.
These are all of them crimes as easily proved
as any whatsoever, and that by such proof as
the law of God requires, so that it is no unin-
ieUigible law.
But if the iniquity of the times be such that
these criminals not only escape, being indemni-
fied, but are encouraged in their wickedness, and
made use of to take away the lives of others,
this is worse than a making the law of God vain,
it being a rendering of it dangerous, against the
lives of innocents, and without all hopes of bet-
ter, so long as these bloody principles remain.
POSTSCRIPT. 309
As long as christians do esteeta the law of
God to be imperfect^ as not describing that crime
that it requires to be punished by death :
As long as men suffer themselves to be poi-
lioned in their education, and be grounded in a
false belief by the books of the heathen :
As long as the devil shall be believed to have
a natural power to act above and against the course
of nature :
As long as the ivitches shall be believed to
have a power to commission him:
As long as the devil'' s testimony, by the pre-'
tended afflicted, shall be received as more valid
to condemn, than their plea of not guilty to acquit :
As long a* the accused shall have their lives
and liberties confirmed and restored to them upon
their confessing themselves guilty :
As long as the accused shall be forced to w«-
dergo hardships and torments for their not con-
fessing :
As long asteats for the devil to suck are search-
ed for upon the bodies of the accused, as a to-
ken of guilt :
As long as the Lord'^s prayer shall be profan-
ed, by being made a test, who are culpable:
As long as ivitchcraft, sorcery, familiar spirits,
and necromancy, shall be improved to discover
who are witches, &c.
So long it may be expected that innocents
will suffer as witches :
So long God will be daily dishonoured, and so
long his judgments must be expected to be con-
tinued.
GILES CORY.
The files of qfice contain numerous documents of the absurd
and ridiculous proceedings and testimonies^ by zvhich the
victims of a pretended witchcraft "zvere driven on to their
tragical end: of which the follozeing will serve as a specie
men.
The examination of Giles Cory, at a Court at Salem
Village, held bj John Hathorn and Jona, Curwin, Esqrs.
April 19, 1692.
Giles Cory, you are brought before authority upon high
suspicion of sundry acts of witchcraft ; now tell us the
truth in this matter.
I hope through the goodness of God 1 shall, for that
matter I never had no hand in, in my life.
Which of you have seen this man hurt you?
Mary Woicott, Mercy Lewis, Ann Putman, jr. and Abi-
gail Williams affirmed he had hurt them.
Hath he hurt you too ? speaking to Elizabeth Hubbard.
She going to answer was prevented by a fit.
Benjamin Gold, hath he hurt you ?
I have seen him several times, and been hurt after it,
but cannot affirm that it was he.
Hath he brought the book to any of you?
Mary Woicott and Abigail Williams and others affirmed
lie had brought the book to them,
Giles Cory, they accuse you, or your appearance, of
hurting them, and bringing the book to them. What do
you say? Why do you hurt them? Tell us the truth.
I never did hurt them. ■
It is your appearance hurts them, they charge you ; tell
us what have you done.
I have done nothing to damage them.
Have you never entered into contract with the devil ?
i never did.
What temptations have you had ?
I never had temptations in my life.
What, have you done it without temptations?
What was the reason (said goodvvife Bibber) that you
were frighted m the cow-house ? and then the questioaist
was suddenly seized with a violent fit.
GILES CORY. 31 i
Samuel Braybrook, goodman Bibber, and his daughter,
testliiod that he had told them this morning that he was
frighted m the cow-house.
Cory denied it.
This was not your appearance but your person, and you
(old them so this morning: why do you deny it ?
What did you see in the cow-house ?
I never saw nothing but my cattle.
Divers witnessed that he told them he was frighted.
Well, what do you say to these witnesses? What was
it frighted you?
1 do not know that ever I spoke the word in my life.
Tell the truth, what was it frighted you ?
I do not know any thing that frighted me.
All the afflicted were seized now with tits, and troubled
with pinches. Then the court ordered his hands to be tied.
V\ hat, is it not enough to act witchcraft at other times,
but must you do it now in the face of authority?
1 am a poor creature, and cannot help it.
Upon the motion ot his head again, they had their heads
and necks aOlicted.
Why do you tell such wicked lies against witnesses, that
heard you speak after this manner, this very morning?
I never saw any thing but a black hog.
You said that you were stopt once in prayer ; what
stopt you ?
1 cannot tell; my wife came towards me and iound fault
with me tor saying living to God and dying to sin.
What was it frighted you in the barn?
I know nothing frighted me there.
Why here are three witnesses that heard you say so
io-dixy.
1 do not remember it.
Thomas Gold testified that he heard him sav, that he
knew enough against his wife, that would do her business.
What was that you knew against your wife ?
Why that of living to God, and dying to sin.
The Marshal and Bibber's daughter confirmed the same,
that he said he co\ild say that that would do his wife's
business.
I have said what I can say to that.
What was that about your ox?
I thought he was hipt.
312 GILES CORY.
What ointment was that your wife had when she was
seized? You said it was ointment she made by major
Gidney's direction.
He denied it, and said she had it of goody Bibber, or
from her direction.
Goody Bibber said it is not like that ointment.
You said you knew, upon your own knowledge, that she
had it of major Gidney.
He denied it.
Did not you say, when you went to the ferry with your
wife, you would not go over to Boston now, for you should
come yourself the next week ?
I would not go over, because I had not money.
The Marshal testified he said as before.
One of his hands was let go, and several were afflicted.
He held his head on one side, and then the heads of seve-
ral of the afflicted were held on one side. He drew in
his cheeks, and the cheeks of some of the afflicted were
suckt in.
John Bibber and his wife gave in testimony concerning
seme temptations he had lo make away with himself.
How doth this agree with what you said, that you had
no temptations ?
I meant temptations to witchcraft.
If you can give way to self murther, that will make way
to temptation to witchcraft.
Note. There was witness by several, that he said he
would make away with himself, and charge his death up-
on his son.
Goody Bibber testified that' the said Cory called said
Bibbers husband, damn'd, devilish rogue.
Other vile expressions testified in open court by several
others.
Salem Village^ April 19, 1692.
Mr. Samuel Parris being desired to take in tfriting the
examination of Giles Cory^ delivered it in ; and vpon hcar^
ing the same., and seeing what we did see at the time of his
examination.) together vnth the charge of the afflicted persons
against him^ we committed him to their majesties'' gaol.
JoHJf Hathora*.
4>